On the Method of Zadig: Essay #1 from "Science and Hebrew Tradition" — Page 11
History, in the ordinary acceptation of the word, is based upon the interpretation of documentary evidence; and documents would have no evidential value unless historians were justified in their assumption that they have come into existence by the operation of causes similar to those of which documents are, in our present experience, the effects.
A história, na acepção comum da palavra, baseia-se na interpretação de evidências documentais; e os documentos não teriam nenhum valor probatório a menos que os historiadores estivessem justificados em seu pressuposto de que vieram a existir pela operação de causas semelhantes àquelas das quais os documentos são, em nossa experiência presente, os efeitos.
If a written history can be produced otherwise than by human agency, or if the man who wrote a given document was actuated by other than ordinary human motives, such documents are of no more evidential value than so many arabesques.
Se uma história escrita pode ser produzida de outra forma que não pela ação humana, ou se o homem que escreveu determinado documento foi movido por outros motivos que não os humanos ordinários, tais documentos não têm mais valor probatório do que tantos arabescos.
Archaeology, which takes up the thread of history beyond the point at which documentary evidence fails us, could have no existence, except for our well grounded confidence that monuments and works of art or artifice, have never been produced by causes different in kind from those to which they now owe their origin.
A arqueologia, que retoma o fio da história além do ponto em que as evidências documentais nos faltam, não poderia existir, senão pela nossa confiança bem fundamentada de que monumentos e obras de arte ou artifício jamais foram produzidos por causas de natureza diferente daquelas às quais devem agora sua origem.
And geology, which traces back the course of history beyond the limits of archaeology, could tell us nothing except for the assumption that, millions of years ago, water, heat, gravitation, friction, animal and vegetable life, caused effects of the same kind as they now cause.
E a geologia, que remonta o curso da história além dos limites da arqueologia, não poderia nos dizer nada, exceto pelo pressuposto de que, há milhões de anos, a água, o calor, a gravitação, o atrito, a vida animal e vegetal, causavam efeitos do mesmo tipo que causam agora.
Nay, even physical astronomy, in so far as it takes us back to the uttermost point of time which palaetiological science can reach, is founded upon the same assumption.
Mais ainda, até mesmo a astronomia física, na medida em que nos leva de volta ao ponto mais remoto do tempo que a ciência paletiológica pode alcançar, está fundada no mesmo pressuposto.
If the law of gravitation ever failed to be true, even to a small extent, for that period, the calculations of the astronomer have no application.
Se a lei da gravitação alguma vez deixou de ser verdadeira, mesmo que em pequena medida, para aquele período, os cálculos do astrônomo não têm nenhuma aplicação.
Vocabulary
- história
- is-TO-ria — History; the study of past events
- na
- na — Contraction of em + a: in the
- acepção
- a-sep-SAO — Meaning or sense of a word
- comum
- ko-MUM — Common; ordinary; widely shared
- palavra
- pa-LA-vra — Word; a unit of spoken or written language
- baseia-se
- ba-ZEI-a-se — It is based; relies upon something
- interpretação
- in-ter-pre-ta-SAO — Interpretation; explanation of meaning or evidence
- evidências
- e-vi-DEN-si-as — Evidence; facts supporting a conclusion
- documentais
- do-ku-men-TAIS — Documentary; relating to or based on documents
- documentos
- do-ku-MEN-tos — Documents; written records or official papers
- teriam
- te-RI-am — They would have — conditional of ter
- nenhum
- ne-NHUM — None; not any; no one
- valor
- va-LOR — Value; worth; importance
- probatório
- pro-ba-TO-rio — Probative; serving to prove or demonstrate something
- menos
- ME-nos — Less; fewer; unless
- historiadores
- is-to-ri-a-DO-res — Historians; scholars who study history
- estivessem
- es-ti-VE-sem — Were; subjunctive past of estar
- justificados
- zhus-ti-fi-KA-dos — Justified; having valid reason or grounds
- seu
- SEU — His; her; its; their; your — possessive pronoun
- pressuposto
- pre-su-POS-to — Presupposition; assumption taken for granted
- vieram
- vi-E-ram — They came; past tense of vir
- existir
- e-zis-TIR — To exist; to have being or reality
- pela
- PE-la — Contraction of por + a: by the
- operação
- o-pe-ra-SAO — Operation; process or action producing an effect
- causas
- KAU-zas — Causes; reasons that produce an effect
- semelhantes
- se-me-LHAN-tes — Similar; resembling something else closely
- àquelas
- a-KE-las — To those; contraction of a + aquelas
- quais
- KWAIS — Which; that — relative pronoun plural
- nossa
- NO-sa — Our; first person plural possessive adjective
- experiência
- ex-pe-ri-EN-sia — Experience; knowledge gained through observation
- presente
- pre-ZEN-te — Present; current time or existing now
- efeitos
- e-FEI-tos — Effects; results produced by a cause
- Se
- se — If; whether — conditional conjunction
- escrita
- es-KRI-ta — Writing; written text or script
- ser
- ser — To be — permanent state or identity
- produzida
- pro-du-ZI-da — Produced; made or created
- outra
- O-tra — Another; other — feminine adjective
- forma
- FOR-ma — Form; way; manner; shape
- ação
- a-SAO — Action; act; deed performed
- humana
- u-MA-na — Human; relating to human beings
- se
- se — Reflexive pronoun or conditional: if; oneself
- homem
- O-mem — Man; human being; adult male
- escreveu
- es-kre-VEU — He wrote; past tense of escrever
- determinado
- de-ter-mi-NA-do — Determined; specific; a particular one
- documento
- do-ku-MEN-to — Document; an official written record
- foi
- foi — Was; went — past tense of ser/ir
- movido
- mo-VI-do — Moved; motivated; driven by something
- por
- por — By; for; through — preposition
- outros
- O-tros — Others; other — masculine plural adjective
- motivos
- mo-TI-vos — Motives; reasons behind an action
- humanos
- u-MA-nos — Human; relating to people or mankind
- ordinários
- or-di-NA-rios — Ordinary; common; not special or unusual
- tais
- TAIS — Such; those — plural demonstrative adjective
- mais
- MAIS — More; most; additionally
- tantos
- TAN-tos — So many; as many — plural masculine
- arabescos
- a-ra-BES-kos — Arabesques; intricate ornamental patterns or designs
- arqueologia
- ar-ke-o-lo-ZHI-a — Archaeology; study of ancient human remains
- retoma
- re-TO-ma — Resumes; takes up again; recovers
- fio
- FI-o — Thread; wire; thin strand connecting things
- além
- a-LEM — Beyond; further; in addition to
- ponto
- PON-to — Point; dot; place; specific location
- faltam
- FAL-tam — They lack; are missing; we are without
- poderia
- po-de-RI-a — Could; would be able to — conditional
- senão
- se-NAO — Unless; except; otherwise; if not
- confiança
- kon-fi-AN-sa — Confidence; trust; reliance on something
- bem
- bem — Well; good; very — adverb
- fundamentada
- fun-da-men-TA-da — Well-founded; based on solid grounds or evidence
- monumentos
- mo-nu-MEN-tos — Monuments; structures commemorating events or people
- obras
- O-bras — Works; creations; construction projects
- arte
- AR-te — Art; creative expression or skill
- artifício
- ar-ti-FI-sio — Artifice; craft; human skill or contrivance
- jamais
- zha-MAIS — Never; at no time; ever — strong negation
- foram
- FO-ram — Were; they were — past tense of ser
- produzidos
- pro-du-ZI-dos — Produced; made; created by some process
- natureza
- na-tu-RE-za — Nature; the natural world or character
- diferente
- di-fe-REN-te — Different; distinct; not the same
- daquelas
- da-KE-las — From those; contraction of de + aquelas
- às
- as — To the; contraction of a + as (plural)
- devem
- DE-vem — They owe; they must; they should
- agora
- a-GO-ra — Now; at this present moment
- sua
- SU-a — His; her; its; their — feminine possessive
- origem
- o-RI-zhem — Origin; source; starting point of something
- geologia
- zhe-o-lo-ZHI-a — Geology; science of Earth's structure and rocks
- remonta
- re-MON-ta — Goes back; traces back to a period
- curso
- KUR-so — Course; path; progression of events
- limites
- li-MI-tes — Limits; boundaries; maximum extent allowed
- dizer
- di-ZER — To say; to tell; to express in words
- nada
- NA-da — Nothing; not anything at all
- exceto
- ex-SE-to — Except; excluding; apart from
- pelo
- PE-lo — Contraction of por + o: by the
- há
- a — There is; there are; ago — from haver
- milhões
- mi-LHOES — Millions; very large numbers of something
- anos
- A-nos — Years; units of time equal to twelve months
- água
- A-gua — Water; liquid essential for life
- calor
- ka-LOR — Heat; thermal energy; warmth
- gravitação
- gra-vi-ta-SAO — Gravitation; force of attraction between masses
- atrito
- a-TRI-to — Friction; resistance between two surfaces
- vida
- VI-da — Life; living existence; animate being
- animal
- a-ni-MAL — Animal; living creature; non-plant organism
- vegetal
- ve-zhe-TAL — Plant; vegetable; relating to plant life
- causavam
- kau-ZA-vam — They caused; were causing — imperfect tense
- mesmo
- MES-mo — Same; even; itself — adjective or adverb
- tipo
- TI-po — Type; kind; sort of something
- causam
- KAU-zam — They cause; produce — present tense
- Mais
- MAIS — More; additionally; to a greater degree
- ainda
- a-IN-da — Still; yet; even; furthermore
- até
- a-TE — Until; up to; even — preposition
- astronomia
- as-tro-no-MI-a — Astronomy; science of celestial bodies and space
- física
- FI-zi-ka — Physics; science of matter and energy
- medida
- me-DI-da — Measure; extent; dimension; as far as
- leva
- LE-va — Takes; carries; leads — third person singular
- volta
- VOL-ta — Return; turn; back — noun or verb form
- remoto
- re-MO-to — Remote; distant; very far away in time
- tempo
- TEM-po — Time; weather; period or duration
- ciência
- si-EN-sia — Science; systematic knowledge through observation
- alcançar
- al-kan-SAR — To reach; to achieve; to attain something
- fundada
- fun-DA-da — Founded; based; established on something
- lei
- LEI — Law; rule; legal principle or regulation
- alguma
- al-GU-ma — Some; any — feminine indefinite adjective
- vez
- ves — Time; instance; occasion — uma vez: once
- deixou
- dei-XHOU — Left; stopped; let — past tense of deixar
- verdadeira
- ver-da-DEI-ra — True; genuine; real; authentic
- pequena
- pe-KE-na — Small; little; tiny — feminine adjective
- para
- PA-ra — For; to; in order to — preposition
- aquele
- a-KE-le — That; that one — masculine demonstrative pronoun
- período
- pe-RI-o-do — Period; span of time; historical era
- cálculos
- KAL-ku-los — Calculations; computations; mathematical workings
- astrônomo
- as-TRO-no-mo — Astronomer; scientist who studies celestial bodies
- nenhuma
- ne-NHUM-a — None; not any — feminine form of nenhum
- aplicação
- a-pli-ka-SAO — Application; use; practical employment of something
Unlock audio playback, vocabulary games, and reading progress tracking.
Create free account →