On the Method of Zadig: Essay #1 from "Science and Hebrew Tradition" — Page 15
The whole fabric of palaeontology, in fact, falls to the ground unless we admit the validity of Zadig's great principle, that like effects imply like causes, and that the process of reasoning from a shell, or a tooth, or a bone, to the nature of the animal to which it belonged, rests absolutely on the assumption that the likeness of this shell, or tooth, or bone, to that of some animal with which we are already acquainted, is such that we are justified in inferring a corresponding degree of likeness in the rest of the two organisms.
事实上,古生物学的整个体系将会土崩瓦解,除非我们承认扎迪格伟大原则的有效性,即相同的结果意味着相同的原因,并且从一枚贝壳、一颗牙齿或一根骨骼推断其所属动物之本性的推理过程,完全依赖于这样一个假设:这枚贝壳、牙齿或骨骼与我们已知的某种动物的相应部分之间的相似程度,足以使我们有理由推断两个生物体其余部分之间存在相应程度的相似性。
It is on this very simple principle, and not upon imaginary laws of physiological correlation, about which, in most cases, we know nothing whatever, that the so-called restorations of the palaeontologist are based.
古生物学家所谓的复原工作,正是建立在这一极为简单的原则之上,而非建立在那些虚构的生理相关性法则之上——对于后者,在大多数情况下,我们根本一无所知。
Abundant illustrations of this truth will occur to every one who is familiar with palaeontology; none is more suitable than the case of the so-called Belemnites.
熟悉古生物学的人都能轻易想到大量印证这一真理的例子;其中最为恰当的莫过于所谓箭石的案例。
In the early days of the study of fossils, this name was given to certain elongated stony bodies, ending at one extremity in a conical point, and truncated at the other, which were commonly reputed to be thunderbolts, and as such to have descended from the sky.
在化石研究的早期,这个名称被赋予某些细长的石质体,其一端呈圆锥形尖状,另一端则截平,这些石质体通常被认为是雷电之石,据称是从天而降的。
They are common enough in some parts of England; and, in the condition in which they are ordinarily found, it might be difficult to give satisfactory reasons for denying them to be merely mineral bodies.
它们在英格兰某些地区相当常见;而且,在通常被发现时的状态下,要给出令人满意的理由来否认它们不过是普通矿物体,或许并非易事。
Vocabulary
- 事实
- shìshí — fact; actual state of affairs
- 上
- shàng — on; above; in terms of (particle)
- 古生物学
- gǔshēngwùxué — paleontology; study of ancient life forms
- 的
- de — structural particle indicating possession or modification
- 整个
- zhěnggè — entire; whole; the complete thing
- 体系
- tǐxì — system; organized framework or structure
- 将会
- jiāng huì — will; shall; is going to happen
- 土崩瓦解
- tǔbēng wǎjiě — completely collapse; fall apart like crumbling earth
- 除非
- chúfēi — unless; only if; except when
- 我们
- wǒmen — we; us; our group
- 承认
- chéngrèn — acknowledge; admit; recognize as valid
- 伟大
- wěidà — great; magnificent; of outstanding significance
- 原则
- yuánzé — principle; fundamental rule or guideline
- 有效性
- yǒuxiàoxìng — validity; effectiveness; state of being valid
- 即
- jí — namely; that is; i.e.
- 相同
- xiāngtóng — identical; the same; alike in nature
- 结果
- jiéguǒ — result; outcome; consequence of something
- 意味着
- yìwèizhe — implies; means; signifies something specific
- 原因
- yuányīn — cause; reason; underlying factor
- 并且
- bìngqiě — and; moreover; in addition to that
- 从
- cóng — from; based on; starting from a point
- 一枚
- yī méi — one (small flat object); a single piece
- 贝壳
- bèiké — shell; hard outer covering of mollusks
- 一颗
- yī kē — one (small round object); a single grain or tooth
- 牙齿
- yáchǐ — tooth; teeth; hard biting structure in mouth
- 或
- huò — or; either; alternatively
- 一根
- yī gēn — one (long thin object); a single bone or stick
- 骨骼
- gǔgé — skeleton; bones; the skeletal structure of body
- 推断
- tuīduàn — infer; deduce; draw a logical conclusion
- 其
- qí — its; his; their (literary third-person possessive)
- 所属
- suǒshǔ — belonging to; affiliated with; the group it belongs
- 动物
- dòngwù — animal; living creature; fauna
- 之
- zhī — literary possessive particle; of (classical Chinese)
- 本性
- běnxìng — nature; innate character; fundamental essence
- 推理
- tuīlǐ — reasoning; logical inference; deductive thinking
- 过程
- guòchéng — process; course; sequence of steps
- 完全
- wánquán — completely; entirely; fully; without exception
- 依赖于
- yīlài yú — depends on; relies upon; is contingent on
- 这样
- zhèyàng — such; like this; of this kind
- 一个
- yī gè — one; a single (general measure word)
- 假设
- jiǎshè — assumption; hypothesis; suppose that something is true
- 这枚
- zhè méi — this (small flat object); this particular piece
- 与
- yǔ — and; with; together with (literary)
- 已知
- yǐzhī — known; already established; previously determined
- 某种
- mǒu zhǒng — a certain kind; some type of something
- 相应
- xiāngyìng — corresponding; matching; respective counterpart
- 部分
- bùfen — part; portion; section of a whole
- 之间
- zhījiān — between; among; in the middle of
- 相似
- xiāngsì — similar; resembling; alike in appearance
- 程度
- chéngdù — degree; extent; level of something
- 足以
- zúyǐ — sufficient to; enough to; adequate to do
- 使
- shǐ — cause; make; enable something to happen
- 有
- yǒu — have; there is; possess
- 理由
- lǐyóu — reason; justification; grounds for a claim
- 两个
- liǎng gè — two; a pair of; both objects
- 生物体
- shēngwùtǐ — organism; living body; biological entity
- 其余
- qíyú — the rest; the remainder; other parts
- 存在
- cúnzài — exist; existence; to be present
- 相似性
- xiāngsìxìng — similarity; resemblance; degree of being alike
- 古生物学家
- gǔshēngwùxuéjiā — paleontologist; scientist studying ancient life
- 所谓
- suǒwèi — so-called; what is known as; supposedly
- 复原
- fùyuán — reconstruct; restore; recreate original form
- 工作
- gōngzuò — work; task; job or professional activity
- 正是
- zhèng shì — precisely is; exactly; just what it is
- 建立
- jiànlì — establish; build; found on a basis
- 在
- zài — at; in; located at; based on
- 这一
- zhè yī — this one; this particular (emphatic reference)
- 极为
- jí wéi — extremely; exceedingly; to a very high degree
- 简单
- jiǎndān — simple; straightforward; uncomplicated
- 之上
- zhī shàng — above; on top of; based upon (literary)
- 而非
- ér fēi — rather than; instead of; not but rather
- 那些
- nàxiē — those; those particular things or people
- 虚构
- xūgòu — fictional; fabricated; invented and not real
- 生理
- shēnglǐ — physiological; relating to bodily functions
- 相关性
- xiāngguānxìng — correlation; relatedness; degree of connection between things
- 法则
- fǎzé — law; rule; principle governing phenomena
- 对于
- duìyú — regarding; with respect to; concerning
- 后者
- hòuzhě — the latter; the second of two mentioned items
- 大多数
- dàduōshù — majority; most; the greater number of
- 情况下
- qíngkuàng xià — under circumstances; in situations; given conditions
- 根本
- gēnběn — fundamentally; at all; completely (with negation)
- 一无所知
- yī wú suǒ zhī — know nothing at all; completely ignorant about something
- 熟悉
- shúxī — familiar with; well acquainted; to know well
- 人
- rén — person; people; human being
- 都能
- dōu néng — all can; everyone is able to; capable of
- 轻易
- qīngyì — easily; without difficulty; lightly done
- 想到
- xiǎngdào — think of; come up with; bring to mind
- 大量
- dàliàng — large quantity; abundant; a great deal of
- 印证
- yìnzhèng — confirm; corroborate; verify with evidence
- 真理
- zhēnlǐ — truth; universal truth; absolute fact
- 例子
- lìzi — example; instance; illustrative case
- 其中
- qízhōng — among them; within; in the midst of
- 最为
- zuì wéi — most; the most; to the greatest extent
- 恰当
- qiàdàng — appropriate; fitting; suitable for the purpose
- 莫过于
- mò guòyú — nothing surpasses; best exemplified by; most apt is
- 案例
- ànlì — case; example; specific instance for study
- 化石
- huàshí — fossil; preserved remains of ancient organisms
- 研究
- yánjiū — research; study; investigate systematically
- 早期
- zǎoqī — early period; early stage; initial phase
- 这个
- zhège — this; this one; this particular thing
- 名称
- míngchēng — name; designation; term used to identify
- 被
- bèi — passive marker; by (indicating passive voice)
- 赋予
- fùyǔ — bestow; grant; endow with a quality
- 某些
- mǒuxiē — certain; some particular; a number of unspecified
- 细长
- xìcháng — slender; long and thin; elongated in shape
- 体
- tǐ — body; object; physical form or structure
- 一端
- yī duān — one end; one extremity of an object
- 呈
- chéng — present; exhibit; take on a shape
- 圆锥形
- yuánzhuīxíng — conical; cone-shaped; tapering to a point
- 另一端
- lìng yī duān — the other end; the opposite extremity
- 则
- zé — then; whereas; on the other hand (contrast)
- 这些
- zhèxiē — these; these particular items or things
- 通常
- tōngcháng — usually; normally; under ordinary circumstances
- 认为
- rènwéi — believe; think; consider to be true
- 是
- shì — is; are; am; to be
- 雷电
- léidiàn — thunder and lightning; thunderbolt; electrical storm
- 石
- shí — stone; rock; mineral material
- 据称
- jùchēng — allegedly; reportedly; it is said that
- 从天而降
- cóng tiān ér jiàng — fall from the sky; descend from heaven suddenly
- 它们
- tāmen — they; them (referring to inanimate objects)
- 英格兰
- Yīnggélán — England; the southern part of Great Britain
- 地区
- dìqū — region; area; district; geographic zone
- 相当
- xiāngdāng — quite; fairly; considerably; rather common
- 常见
- chángjiàn — common; frequently seen; encountered often
- 而且
- érqiě — moreover; furthermore; and also in addition
- 发现
- fāxiàn — discover; find; come across something
- 时
- shí — when; at the time of; during
- 状态
- zhuàngtài — state; condition; current status of something
- 下
- xià — under; below; in a given condition
- 要
- yào — want; need; require; it is necessary to
- 给出
- gěichū — provide; give; offer an explanation or answer
- 令人满意
- lìng rén mǎnyì — satisfactory; pleasing; meeting expectations adequately
- 来
- lái — come; in order to; directional complement particle
- 否认
- fǒurèn — deny; refute; reject the truth of something
- 不过
- búguò — however; but; merely; only
- 普通
- pǔtōng — ordinary; common; regular; not special
- 矿物
- kuàngwù — mineral; naturally occurring inorganic substance
- 或许
- huòxǔ — perhaps; maybe; possibly; not certain
- 并非
- bìng fēi — is not; by no means; definitely not so
- 易事
- yìshì — easy matter; simple task; something done easily
Unlock audio playback, vocabulary games, and reading progress tracking.
Create free account →