The Odyssey: Rendered into English prose for the use of those who cannot read the original — Page 8
Any one who at the present day discusses the questions that have arisen round the "Iliad" since Wolf's time, without keeping it well before his reader's mind that the "Odyssey" was demonstrably written from one single neighbourhood, and hence (even though nothing else pointed to this conclusion) presumably by one person only—that it was written certainly before 750, and in all probability before 1000 B.C.—that the writer of this very early poem was demonstrably familiar with the "Iliad" as we now have it, borrowing as freely from those books whose genuineness has been most impugned, as from those which are admitted to be by Homer—any one who fails to keep these points before his readers, is hardly dealing equitably by them.
Quiconque, de nos jours, discute les questions qui ont surgi autour de l'« Iliade » depuis l'époque de Wolf, sans rappeler clairement à l'esprit de son lecteur que l'« Odyssée » fut de toute évidence écrite depuis un seul et même lieu, et donc (même si rien d'autre ne conduisait à cette conclusion) vraisemblablement par une seule personne — qu'elle fut écrite certainement avant 750, et selon toute probabilité avant 1000 av. J.-C. — que l'auteur de ce poème très ancien connaissait manifestement l'« Iliade » telle que nous la possédons aujourd'hui, empruntant aussi librement aux livres dont l'authenticité a été le plus mise en doute qu'à ceux qui sont reconnus comme étant d'Homère — quiconque néglige de rappeler ces points à ses lecteurs ne se montre guère équitable envers eux.
Any one on the other hand, who will mark his "Iliad" and his "Odyssey" from the copies in the British Museum above referred to, and who will draw the only inference that common sense can draw from the presence of so many identical passages in both poems, will, I believe, find no difficulty in assigning their proper value to a large number of books here and on the Continent that at present enjoy considerable reputations.
Quiconque, en revanche, annotera son « Iliade » et son « Odyssée » d'après les exemplaires du British Museum mentionnés plus haut, et tirera la seule conclusion que le bon sens puisse tirer de la présence de tant de passages identiques dans les deux poèmes, ne trouvera, je crois, aucune difficulté à attribuer leur juste valeur à un grand nombre d'ouvrages publiés ici et sur le Continent qui jouissent actuellement d'une réputation considérable.
Furthermore, and this perhaps is an advantage better worth securing, he will find that many puzzles of the "Odyssey" cease to puzzle him on the discovery that they arise from over-saturation with the "Iliad.
De plus, et c'est là peut-être un avantage qui mérite davantage d'être recherché, il découvrira que bien des énigmes de l'« Odyssée » cessent de l'intriguer lorsqu'il constate qu'elles résultent d'une imprégnation excessive de l'« Iliade ».
Vocabulary
- Quiconque
- ki-kɔ̃k — Whoever; anyone who does something
- de
- də — Of, from; general-purpose preposition
- nos
- no — Our; first-person plural possessive adjective
- jours
- ʒuʁ — Days; periods of time
- discute
- dis-kyt — Discusses; debates a topic or question
- les
- le — The; definite article for plural nouns
- questions
- kɛs-tjɔ̃ — Questions; issues or topics under discussion
- qui
- ki — Who, which, that; relative or interrogative pronoun
- ont
- ɔ̃ — Have; third-person plural of avoir
- surgi
- syʁ-ʒi — Arisen; emerged or appeared suddenly
- autour
- o-tuʁ — Around; surrounding a topic or object
- l'
- l — The; elided definite article before vowel
- Iliade
- i-ljad — The Iliad; Homer's epic poem about Troy
- depuis
- də-pwi — Since, for; indicating a starting point in time
- époque
- e-pɔk — Era, period; a specific time in history
- sans
- sɑ̃ — Without; indicating absence or lack of something
- rappeler
- ʁa-pəl-e — To remind, recall; to bring back to mind
- clairement
- klɛʁ-mɑ̃ — Clearly; in a clear and obvious manner
- à
- a — To, at, in; common French preposition
- esprit
- ɛs-pʁi — Mind, spirit; mental faculty or consciousness
- son
- sɔ̃ — His, her, its; third-person singular possessive
- lecteur
- lɛk-tœʁ — Reader; person who reads a text
- que
- kə — That, which; subordinating conjunction or pronoun
- Odyssée
- o-di-se — The Odyssey; Homer's epic of Odysseus's journey
- fut
- fy — Was; third-person singular simple past of être
- toute
- tut — All, whole, every; feminine form of tout
- évidence
- e-vi-dɑ̃s — Evidence; obvious proof or clear indication
- écrite
- e-kʁit — Written; feminine past participle of écrire
- un
- œ̃ — A, an, one; masculine indefinite article
- seul
- sœl — Alone, only, single; one and no other
- et
- e — And; basic coordinating conjunction
- même
- mɛm — Same, even, itself; emphasizing identity or similarity
- lieu
- ljø — Place, location; a specific spot or setting
- donc
- dɔ̃k — Therefore, so; indicating a logical conclusion
- si
- si — If, so; conditional conjunction or intensifier
- rien
- ʁjɛ̃ — Nothing; absence of anything relevant
- d'
- d — Of, from; elided preposition before vowel
- autre
- otʁ — Other, another; different from what was mentioned
- ne
- nə — Not; negation particle used with pas or rien
- conduisait
- kɔ̃-dɥi-zɛ — Led, drove; imperfect of conduire meaning guide
- cette
- sɛt — This, that; feminine demonstrative adjective
- conclusion
- kɔ̃-kly-zjɔ̃ — Conclusion; final judgment reached through reasoning
- vraisemblablement
- vʁɛ-sɑ̃-bla-blə-mɑ̃ — Probably, in all likelihood; with great plausibility
- par
- paʁ — By, through, per; preposition indicating agent or means
- une
- yn — A, an, one; feminine indefinite article
- seule
- sœl — Alone, only, single; feminine form of seul
- personne
- pɛʁ-sɔn — Person; an individual human being
- qu'
- k — That, which; elided form of que
- elle
- ɛl — She, it; third-person feminine singular pronoun
- certainement
- sɛʁ-tɛn-mɑ̃ — Certainly; without doubt, definitely true
- avant
- a-vɑ̃ — Before; prior to a time or event
- selon
- sə-lɔ̃ — According to; based on a source or opinion
- probabilité
- pʁɔ-ba-bi-li-te — Probability; likelihood of something being true
- av.
- a-vɑ̃ — Before; abbreviation of avant in dates
- J.-C.
- ʒe-ze-kʁi — BC; abbreviation for avant Jésus-Christ
- auteur
- o-tœʁ — Author; person who wrote a literary work
- ce
- sə — This, that; masculine demonstrative adjective or pronoun
- poème
- po-ɛm — Poem; literary work written in verse form
- très
- tʁɛ — Very; intensifying adverb modifying adjectives or adverbs
- ancien
- ɑ̃-sjɛ̃ — Ancient, old, former; existing from long ago
- connaissait
- kɔ-nɛ-sɛ — Knew, was familiar with; imperfect of connaître
- manifestement
- ma-ni-fɛst-mɑ̃ — Manifestly, obviously; in a clear evident manner
- telle
- tɛl — Such, as; feminine form of tel indicating manner
- nous
- nu — We, us; first-person plural pronoun
- la
- la — The; definite article for feminine singular nouns
- possédons
- pɔ-se-dɔ̃ — We possess, have; first-person plural of posséder
- aujourd'hui
- o-ʒuʁ-dɥi — Today; at the present time or day
- empruntant
- ɑ̃-pʁœ̃-tɑ̃ — Borrowing; taking or using from another source
- aussi
- o-si — Also, too, so; expressing addition or comparison
- librement
- li-bʁə-mɑ̃ — Freely; without restriction, openly and willingly
- aux
- o — To the, at the; contraction of à + les
- livres
- livʁ — Books; written works or sections of a text
- dont
- dɔ̃ — Whose, of which; relative pronoun indicating possession
- authenticité
- o-tɑ̃-ti-si-te — Authenticity; quality of being genuine or original
- a
- a — Has; third-person singular present of avoir
- été
- e-te — Been; past participle of être; also means summer
- le
- lə — The; definite article for masculine singular nouns
- plus
- ply — More, most; comparative or superlative adverb
- mise
- miz — Put, placed; feminine past participle of mettre
- en
- ɑ̃ — In, into, as; preposition indicating state or place
- doute
- dut — Doubt; uncertainty about the truth of something
- ceux
- sø — Those, the ones; masculine plural demonstrative pronoun
- sont
- sɔ̃ — Are; third-person plural present of être
- reconnus
- ʁə-kɔ-ny — Recognized, acknowledged; accepted as genuine or valid
- comme
- kɔm — As, like; indicating comparison or equivalence
- étant
- e-tɑ̃ — Being; present participle of être
- quiconque
- ki-kɔ̃k — Whoever; anyone who does a particular thing
- néglige
- ne-gliʒ — Neglects, ignores; fails to attend to something
- ces
- se — These, those; plural demonstrative adjective
- points
- pwɛ̃ — Points; specific matters or issues under consideration
- ses
- se — His, her, its; third-person plural possessive adjective
- lecteurs
- lɛk-tœʁ — Readers; people who read a given text
- se
- sə — Himself, herself, itself; reflexive pronoun
- montre
- mɔ̃tʁ — Shows, proves; demonstrates a quality or behavior
- guère
- gɛʁ — Hardly, scarcely; rarely used negative adverb
- équitable
- e-ki-tabl — Fair, equitable; just and impartial toward others
- envers
- ɑ̃-vɛʁ — Toward, with regard to; preposition of relation
- eux
- ø — Them; masculine plural disjunctive pronoun
- revanche
- ʁə-vɑ̃ʃ — Revenge; en revanche means on the other hand
- annotera
- a-nɔ-tə-ʁa — Will annotate; will add notes to a text
- après
- a-pʁɛ — After; following in time, order, or place
- exemplaires
- ɛg-zɑ̃-plɛʁ — Copies; individual physical copies of a publication
- du
- dy — Of the, from the; contraction of de + le
- mentionnés
- mɑ̃-sjɔ-ne — Mentioned; referred to earlier in the text
- haut
- o — Above, high; referring to something stated earlier
- tirera
- ti-ʁə-ʁa — Will draw, derive; will extract meaning or value
- bon
- bɔ̃ — Good; positive quality or satisfactory result
- sens
- sɑ̃s — Sense, meaning; significance or rational interpretation
- puisse
- pɥis — Can, may; subjunctive of pouvoir expressing possibility
- tirer
- ti-ʁe — To draw, pull, derive; to extract or obtain
- présence
- pʁe-zɑ̃s — Presence; the fact of being present or occurring
- tant
- tɑ̃ — So many, so much; indicating a large quantity
- passages
- pa-saʒ — Passages; sections of a text or literary work
- identiques
- i-dɑ̃-tik — Identical; exactly the same in every respect
- dans
- dɑ̃ — In, within; indicating location or inclusion
- deux
- dø — Two; the number 2
- poèmes
- po-ɛm — Poems; literary works written in verse form
- trouvera
- tʁu-və-ʁa — Will find; will discover or encounter something
- je
- ʒə — I; first-person singular subject pronoun
- crois
- kʁwa — Believe, think; first-person singular of croire
- aucune
- o-kyn — No, none, any; feminine negative indefinite adjective
- difficulté
- di-fi-kyl-te — Difficulty; something hard to understand or accomplish
- attribuer
- a-tʁi-bɥe — To attribute, assign; to credit something to someone
- leur
- lœʁ — Their, to them; possessive or indirect object pronoun
- juste
- ʒyst — Just, fair, exact; correct or precisely appropriate
- valeur
- va-lœʁ — Value, worth; importance or merit of something
- grand
- gʁɑ̃ — Great, large, big; significant in size or importance
- nombre
- nɔ̃bʁ — Number; quantity or count of items
- ouvrages
- u-vʁaʒ — Works; literary or scholarly publications or books
- publiés
- py-blje — Published; made available to the public in print
- ici
- i-si — Here; in this place or context
- sur
- syʁ — On, about, over; preposition of position or topic
- jouissent
- ʒwis — Enjoy, benefit from; third-person plural of jouir
- actuellement
- ak-tɥɛl-mɑ̃ — Currently, at present; at this moment in time
- réputation
- ʁe-py-ta-sjɔ̃ — Reputation; general opinion held about someone or something
- considérable
- kɔ̃-si-de-ʁabl — Considerable; notably large or significant in extent
- De
- də — Of, from; preposition beginning a phrase or name
- c'
- s — It, this; elided form of ce before est
- est
- ɛ — Is; third-person singular present of être
- là
- la — There; referring to a place or previously stated idea
- peut-
- pø — Can, may; beginning of peut-être meaning perhaps
- être
- ɛtʁ — To be; fundamental linking verb in French
- avantage
- a-vɑ̃-taʒ — Advantage; a benefit or favorable circumstance
- mérite
- me-ʁit — Merit, deserves; quality worthy of recognition or reward
- davantage
- da-vɑ̃-taʒ — More; to a greater degree or extent
- recherché
- ʁə-ʃɛʁ-ʃe — Sought after, researched; carefully pursued or investigated
- il
- il — He, it; third-person masculine singular pronoun
- découvrira
- de-ku-vʁi-ʁa — Will discover; will find out or uncover something
- bien
- bjɛ̃ — Well, much, indeed; adverb of quality or emphasis
- des
- de — Some, of the; plural indefinite article
- énigmes
- e-nigm — Enigmas; puzzling mysteries or riddles to be solved
- cessent
- sɛs — Stop, cease; third-person plural present of cesser
- intriguer
- ɛ̃-tʁi-ge — To intrigue, puzzle; to cause curiosity or perplexity
- lorsqu'
- lɔʁsk — When; temporal conjunction used before a vowel
- constate
- kɔ̃-stat — Notices, observes; ascertains or finds something to be true
- elles
- ɛl — They; third-person feminine plural subject pronoun
- résultent
- ʁe-zyl-t — Result from; originate or arise from a cause
- imprégnation
- ɛ̃-pʁɛɲ-a-sjɔ̃ — Impregnation; deep saturation or permeation with influence
- excessive
- ɛk-sɛ-siv — Excessive; going beyond what is necessary or appropriate
Unlock audio playback, vocabulary games, and reading progress tracking.
Create free account →