The Odyssey: Rendered into English prose for the use of those who cannot read the original — Page 8
Any one who at the present day discusses the questions that have arisen round the "Iliad" since Wolf's time, without keeping it well before his reader's mind that the "Odyssey" was demonstrably written from one single neighbourhood, and hence (even though nothing else pointed to this conclusion) presumably by one person only—that it was written certainly before 750, and in all probability before 1000 B.C.—that the writer of this very early poem was demonstrably familiar with the "Iliad" as we now have it, borrowing as freely from those books whose genuineness has been most impugned, as from those which are admitted to be by Homer—any one who fails to keep these points before his readers, is hardly dealing equitably by them.
Chiunque al giorno d'oggi discuta le questioni sorte attorno all'«Iliade» dai tempi di Wolf, senza tenere ben presente al suo lettore che l'«Odissea» fu dimostrabilmente scritta da un'unica località, e quindi (anche se nient'altro indicasse questa conclusione) presumibilmente da una sola persona—che fu scritta certamente prima del 750, e con ogni probabilità prima del 1000 a.C.—che l'autore di questo poema molto antico aveva una dimostrabile familiarità con l'«Iliade» così come la possediamo oggi, attingendo con la stessa libertà da quei libri la cui autenticità è stata maggiormente messa in discussione, come da quelli che si ammettono essere di Omero—chiunque manchi di tenere questi punti presenti ai propri lettori, difficilmente si comporta equamente nei loro confronti.
Any one on the other hand, who will mark his "Iliad" and his "Odyssey" from the copies in the British Museum above referred to, and who will draw the only inference that common sense can draw from the presence of so many identical passages in both poems, will, I believe, find no difficulty in assigning their proper value to a large number of books here and on the Continent that at present enjoy considerable reputations.
Chiunque d'altro canto voglia annotare la propria «Iliade» e la propria «Odissea» a partire dalle copie del British Museum sopra citate, e voglia trarre la sola conclusione che il buon senso può trarre dalla presenza di così tanti passi identici in entrambi i poemi, non troverà, credo, alcuna difficoltà nell'attribuire il loro giusto valore a un gran numero di libri qui e sul Continente che al momento godono di considerevole reputazione.
Furthermore, and this perhaps is an advantage better worth securing, he will find that many puzzles of the "Odyssey" cease to puzzle him on the discovery that they arise from over-saturation with the "Iliad.
Inoltre, e questo forse è un vantaggio che vale ancor più la pena di conseguire, egli scoprirà che molti enigmi dell'«Odissea» cessano di sconcertarlo non appena si scopre che essi derivano da un'eccessiva saturazione dell'«Iliade».
Vocabulary
- Chiunque
- kˈjunkwe — whoever, anyone who (indefinite pronoun)
- al
- al — to the, at the (masculine singular contraction)
- giorno
- dʒˈorno — day, daytime
- d'
- d — of, from (elided preposition before vowel)
- oggi
- ˈɔddʒi — today, nowadays
- discuta
- disˈkuta — discusses, debates (present subjunctive of discutere)
- le
- le — the (feminine plural definite article)
- questioni
- kwesˈtjoni — questions, issues, matters under debate
- sorte
- ˈsorte — arisen, emerged (past participle of sorgere)
- attorno
- atˈtorno — around, surrounding
- all'
- all — to the, at the (elided contraction before vowel)
- dai
- dai — from the (masculine plural contraction)
- tempi
- ˈtɛmpi — times, periods, eras
- di
- di — of, from (basic Italian preposition)
- senza
- ˈsɛntsa — without (preposition indicating absence)
- tenere
- teˈnere — to keep, to hold in mind
- ben
- bɛn — well, clearly (adverb, shortened form)
- presente
- preˈzɛnte — present, in mind, aware of
- suo
- ˈsuo — his, her, its (possessive adjective)
- lettore
- letˈtore — reader, person who reads texts
- che
- ke — that, which, who (conjunction/pronoun)
- l'
- l — the (elided definite article before vowel)
- fu
- fu — was (third person singular past absolute of essere)
- dimostrabilmente
- dimostrabilˈmente — demonstrably, provably, in a demonstrable manner
- scritta
- ˈskritta — written (past participle of scrivere, feminine)
- da
- da — by, from (preposition of origin or agent)
- un'
- un — a, an (feminine indefinite article before vowel)
- unica
- ˈunika — single, unique, one and only
- località
- lokalitˈa — location, place, specific locality
- e
- e — and (basic Italian conjunction)
- quindi
- ˈkwindi — therefore, thus, consequently
- anche
- ˈanke — also, even, too
- se
- se — if (conditional conjunction)
- nient'
- njɛnt — nothing (elided form of niente before vowel)
- altro
- ˈaltro — other, else, another thing
- indicasse
- indiˈkasse — indicated, pointed to (imperfect subjunctive)
- questa
- ˈkwesta — this (feminine singular demonstrative adjective)
- conclusione
- konkluˈzjone — conclusion, final determination, outcome
- presumibilmente
- prezumibilˈmente — presumably, in all likelihood, probably
- una
- ˈuna — a, one (feminine singular indefinite article)
- sola
- ˈsola — alone, single, only one person
- persona
- perˈsona — person, individual human being
- certamente
- tʃertaˈmente — certainly, definitely, without doubt
- prima
- ˈprima — before, earlier, prior to
- del
- del — of the (masculine singular contraction)
- con
- kon — with (basic Italian preposition)
- ogni
- ˈoɲɲi — every, each, all
- probabilità
- probabilitˈa — probability, likelihood, chance
- a
- a — to, at (basic Italian preposition)
- autore
- auˈtore — author, writer, creator of a work
- questo
- ˈkwesto — this (masculine singular demonstrative adjective)
- poema
- poˈɛma — poem, especially a long epic poem
- molto
- ˈmolto — very, much, a great deal
- antico
- anˈtiko — ancient, old, from a distant past
- aveva
- aˈvɛva — had (third person singular imperfect of avere)
- dimostrabile
- dimoˈstrabile — demonstrable, capable of being proven
- familiarità
- familjaritˈa — familiarity, intimate knowledge of something
- così
- koˈzi — so, thus, in this way
- come
- ˈkome — as, like, how
- la
- la — the (feminine singular definite article)
- possediamo
- possˈedjamo — we possess, we have knowledge of
- attingendo
- attinˈdʒɛndo — drawing from, deriving, tapping into a source
- stessa
- ˈstɛssa — same, very same (feminine singular adjective)
- libertà
- libertˈa — freedom, liberty, latitude of choice
- quei
- ˈkwɛi — those (masculine plural demonstrative adjective)
- libri
- ˈlibri — books, volumes (plural of libro)
- cui
- kwi — whose, of which (relative pronoun)
- autenticità
- autentitʃitˈa — authenticity, genuineness of a work
- è
- ɛ — is (third person singular present of essere)
- stata
- ˈstata — been (past participle of essere, feminine)
- maggiormente
- maddʒorˈmente — most, especially, to the greatest degree
- messa
- ˈmɛssa — put, placed (past participle of mettere)
- in
- in — in, into (basic Italian preposition)
- discussione
- diskusˈsjone — discussion, debate, dispute
- quelli
- ˈkwɛlli — those (masculine plural demonstrative pronoun)
- si
- si — oneself, itself (reflexive pronoun)
- ammettono
- amˈmɛttono — admit, acknowledge (third person plural present)
- essere
- ˈɛssere — to be (infinitive of the verb essere)
- chiunque
- kˈjunkwe — whoever, anyone who (indefinite pronoun)
- manchi
- ˈmanki — lacks, is missing (present subjunctive of mancare)
- questi
- ˈkwɛsti — these (masculine plural demonstrative pronoun)
- punti
- ˈpunti — points, aspects, elements
- presenti
- preˈzɛnti — presents, shows (present subjunctive of presentare)
- ai
- ai — to the (masculine plural contraction)
- propri
- ˈprɔpri — own, one's own (masculine plural adjective)
- lettori
- letˈtori — readers, persons who read texts
- difficilmente
- difiˈtʃilmente — with difficulty, hardly, not easily
- comporta
- komˈporta — behaves, acts (third person singular present)
- equamente
- ekwaˈmente — fairly, equitably, in a just manner
- nei
- nɛi — in the (masculine plural contraction)
- loro
- ˈloro — their, them, they (pronoun/adjective)
- confronti
- konˈfronti — regards, comparisons; nei confronti means toward
- canto
- ˈkanto — song, canto, section of an epic poem
- voglia
- ˈvoʎʎa — wants, wishes (present subjunctive of volere)
- annotare
- annoˈtare — to annotate, to add notes to a text
- propria
- ˈprɔprja — own, one's own (feminine singular adjective)
- partire
- parˈtire — to depart, to start from (infinitive)
- dalle
- ˈdalle — from the (feminine plural contraction)
- copie
- ˈkopje — copies, reproductions of a manuscript
- sopra
- ˈsopra — above, over, mentioned earlier
- citate
- tʃiˈtate — cited, mentioned (past participle of citare, feminine plural)
- trarre
- ˈtrarre — to draw, to derive, to extract
- il
- il — the (masculine singular definite article)
- buon
- bwon — good (masculine singular adjective before noun)
- senso
- ˈsɛnso — sense, meaning, judgment, direction
- può
- pwɔ — can, is able to (third person singular present)
- dalla
- ˈdalla — from the (feminine singular contraction)
- presenza
- preˈzɛntsa — presence, existence of something somewhere
- tanti
- ˈtanti — so many, so much (masculine plural adjective)
- passi
- ˈpassi — passages, excerpts from a text
- identici
- iˈdɛntitʃi — identical, exactly the same (masculine plural)
- entrambi
- enˈtrambi — both (masculine plural, referring to both poems)
- i
- i — the (masculine plural definite article)
- poemi
- poˈɛmi — poems, epic poems (plural of poema)
- non
- non — not (basic negation adverb)
- troverà
- troverˈa — will find (third person singular future of trovare)
- credo
- ˈkrɛdo — I believe, I think (first person singular present)
- alcuna
- alˈkuna — any, no (feminine singular indefinite adjective)
- difficoltà
- difikoltˈa — difficulty, obstacle, challenge
- nell'
- nell — in the (elided contraction before vowel)
- attribuire
- attriˈbwire — to attribute, to assign due value or credit
- giusto
- ˈdʒusto — right, correct, fair, just
- valore
- vaˈlore — value, worth, importance
- un
- un — a, one (masculine singular indefinite article)
- gran
- gran — great, large (shortened form of grande)
- numero
- ˈnumero — number, quantity, amount
- qui
- kwi — here, in this place
- sul
- sul — on the (masculine singular contraction)
- momento
- moˈmɛnto — moment, time, instant
- godono
- ˈgodono — enjoy, have the benefit of (third person plural)
- considerevole
- konsiˈdɛrevole — considerable, significant, noteworthy in size
- reputazione
- reputaˈtsjone — reputation, standing, esteem among others
- Inoltre
- inˈoltre — furthermore, moreover, in addition
- forse
- ˈforse — perhaps, maybe, possibly
- vantaggio
- vanˈtaddʒo — advantage, benefit, gain over something
- vale
- ˈvale — is worth, has value (third person singular present)
- ancor
- anˈkor — still, yet, even more (shortened form)
- più
- pju — more, most (comparative/superlative adverb)
- pena
- ˈpɛna — effort, trouble; vale la pena means worth it
- conseguire
- konseˈgwire — to achieve, to attain, to obtain a result
- egli
- ˈɛʎʎi — he (formal third person singular masculine pronoun)
- scoprirà
- skopriˈra — will discover (third person singular future)
- molti
- ˈmolti — many (masculine plural adjective/pronoun)
- enigmi
- eˈniɡmi — enigmas, puzzles, mysteries (plural of enigma)
- dell'
- dell — of the (elided contraction before vowel)
- cessano
- ˈtʃessano — cease, stop (third person plural present)
- sconcertarlo
- skontʃerˈtarlo — to disconcert him, to perplex or confuse him
- appena
- apˈpɛna — as soon as, just, barely
- scopre
- ˈskopre — discovers, finds out (third person singular present)
- essi
- ˈɛssi — they (third person plural masculine pronoun)
- derivano
- deˈrivano — derive, originate, stem from (third person plural)
- eccessiva
- etʃˈtʃessiva — excessive, too much, beyond normal limits
- saturazione
- saturaˈtsjone — saturation, overloading, excessive concentration
Unlock audio playback, vocabulary games, and reading progress tracking.
Create free account →