The Odyssey: Rendered into English prose for the use of those who cannot read the original — Page 8
Any one who at the present day discusses the questions that have arisen round the "Iliad" since Wolf's time, without keeping it well before his reader's mind that the "Odyssey" was demonstrably written from one single neighbourhood, and hence (even though nothing else pointed to this conclusion) presumably by one person only—that it was written certainly before 750, and in all probability before 1000 B.C.—that the writer of this very early poem was demonstrably familiar with the "Iliad" as we now have it, borrowing as freely from those books whose genuineness has been most impugned, as from those which are admitted to be by Homer—any one who fails to keep these points before his readers, is hardly dealing equitably by them.
ウルフの時代以来「イーリアス」をめぐって生じてきた諸問題を今日論じる者が、「オデュッセイア」が明らかに一つの地域から書かれたものであり、それゆえ(他に何も手がかりがないとしても)おそらく一人の人物によってのみ書かれたものであること、それが確実に紀元前750年以前に、そしてほぼ間違いなく紀元前1000年以前に書かれたものであること、この非常に古い詩の作者が、我々が現在持っているような「イーリアス」に明らかに精通しており、その真正性が最も疑われてきた書物からも、ホメロスの作と認められている書物からも、同様に自由に借用していたということを、読者の心にしっかりと留めておかなければ、その読者に対して公平に接しているとはほとんど言えない。
Any one on the other hand, who will mark his "Iliad" and his "Odyssey" from the copies in the British Museum above referred to, and who will draw the only inference that common sense can draw from the presence of so many identical passages in both poems, will, I believe, find no difficulty in assigning their proper value to a large number of books here and on the Continent that at present enjoy considerable reputations.
一方、先に言及した大英博物館所蔵の写本によって自分の「イーリアス」と「オデュッセイア」に印をつけ、両詩に非常に多くの同一箇所が存在することから常識が導き出せる唯一の結論を引き出そうとする者は、国内および大陸において現在かなりの名声を享受している多数の書物にその適切な価値を割り当てることに、何ら困難を見出さないだろうと私は信じる。
Furthermore, and this perhaps is an advantage better worth securing, he will find that many puzzles of the "Odyssey" cease to puzzle him on the discovery that they arise from over-saturation with the "Iliad.
さらに、そしてこれはおそらくより確保する価値のある利点であるが、「オデュッセイア」の多くの謎が「イーリアス」への過度の傾倒から生じていることを発見することで、それらの謎が謎でなくなることに気づくだろう。
Vocabulary
- の
- no — Possessive or linking particle connecting nouns
- 時代
- jidai — Era, age, period of time
- 以来
- irai — Since, ever since a certain point in time
- を
- wo — Object marker particle indicating direct object
- めぐって
- megutte — Concerning, surrounding, revolving around a topic
- 生じ
- shōji — To arise, occur, come into being (stem form)
- て
- te — Conjunctive particle connecting clauses or actions
- き
- ki — Auxiliary indicating action continuing up to now
- た
- ta — Past tense auxiliary verb particle
- 諸問題
- shomondai — Various problems, multiple issues or questions
- 今日
- kyō / konnichi — Today; the present day or era
- 論じる
- ronjiru — To discuss, argue, or debate a topic
- 者
- mono / sha — Person, one who does something, scholar
- が
- ga — Subject marker particle identifying the subject
- 明らか
- akiraka — Clear, obvious, evident, apparent
- に
- ni — Particle indicating direction, location, or manner
- 一つ
- hitotsu — One thing, one item (native Japanese numeral)
- 地域
- chiiki — Region, area, local district or zone
- から
- kara — From; particle indicating origin or cause
- 書か
- kaka — Written (stem of 書く, to write)
- れ
- re — Passive auxiliary indicating something was done
- もの
- mono — Thing, object, that which is something
- で
- de — Particle indicating means, location of action, or copula
- あり
- ari — To be, to exist (conjunctive form of ある)
- それ
- sore — That, it; refers to something previously mentioned
- ゆえ
- yue — Therefore, for that reason, hence
- 他
- hoka / ta — Other, another, else, remaining things
- 何
- nani / nan — What; used in questions or indefinite references
- も
- mo — Also, too, even; inclusive or emphatic particle
- 手がかり
- tegakari — Clue, lead, hint, something to go on
- ない
- nai — Not exist, there is no; negative form
- と
- to — And; quotation or conditional particle
- し
- shi — Conjunctive form of する; also listing reasons
- おそらく
- osoraku — Probably, presumably, most likely
- 一人
- hitori — One person, a single individual
- 人物
- jinbutsu — Person, individual, character, personage
- によって
- ni yotte — By means of, by (agent marker in passive)
- のみ
- nomi — Only, merely, solely, nothing but
- ある
- aru — To exist, to be (for inanimate things)
- こと
- koto — Thing, fact, matter (nominalizer)
- 確実
- kakujitsu — Certain, definite, sure, reliable
- 紀元前
- kigenzen — Before the Common Era, BC (before Christ)
- 年
- nen — Year; counter for years
- 以前
- izen — Before, previously, earlier than a point
- そして
- soshite — And then, and also, furthermore
- ほぼ
- hobo — Almost, nearly, approximately
- 間違い
- machigai — Mistake, error; without doubt (間違いなく)
- なく
- naku — Without, not being (conjunctive negative form)
- この
- kono — This (demonstrative adjective modifying a noun)
- 非常
- hijō — Extraordinary, very, extremely; unusual
- 古い
- furui — Old, ancient, aged (adjective for things)
- 詩
- shi — Poem, poetry, verse
- 作者
- sakusha — Author, creator, writer of a work
- 我々
- wareware — We, us (formal or literary first-person plural)
- 現在
- genzai — Present time, currently, now
- 持っ
- mott(e) — To have, hold, possess (te-form stem)
- いる
- iru — To exist, to be (animate); auxiliary for ongoing action
- よう
- yō — Appearance, manner; seems like, in the way of
- な
- na — Adjectival noun linking particle (na-adjective form)
- 精通
- seitsū — Thorough knowledge, expertise, being well-versed
- おり
- ori — To be (humble/literary form of いる)
- その
- sono — That (demonstrative adjective; refers to something mentioned)
- 真正性
- shinshōsei — Authenticity, genuineness of a text or work
- 最も
- mottomo — Most, extremely (superlative adverb)
- 疑わ
- utagawa — Doubted, questioned (stem of 疑う, to doubt)
- 書物
- shomotsu — Book, written work, volume, publication
- 作
- saku — Work, production, authored by someone
- 認め
- mitome — To acknowledge, recognize, admit (stem form)
- られ
- rare — Passive or potential auxiliary verb ending
- 同様
- dōyō — Likewise, in the same way, similarly
- 自由
- jiyū — Freedom, liberty; free, unrestricted
- 借用
- shakuyō — Borrowing, using something borrowed from another
- い
- i — Conjunctive form of いる or adjective ending
- いう
- iu — To say, to call, to be called
- 読者
- dokusha — Reader, reading audience of a text
- 心
- kokoro — Heart, mind, spirit, feelings
- しっかり
- shikkari — Firmly, securely, properly, clearly
- 留め
- tome — To keep in mind, note, fasten (stem form)
- おか
- oka — To keep, leave in a state (stem of おく)
- なけれ
- nakere — Must (conditional form of ない for obligation)
- ば
- ba — Conditional particle meaning if or unless
- 対し
- taishi — Toward, with respect to, against (stem of 対する)
- 公平
- kōhei — Fair, impartial, just, unbiased
- 接し
- sesshi — To deal with, interact with, come into contact
- は
- wa — Topic marker particle highlighting the subject
- ほとんど
- hotondo — Almost, nearly, hardly (with negative: barely)
- 言え
- ie — Can say, it can be said (potential form of 言う)
- 一方
- ippō — On the other hand; one side or direction
- 先
- saki — Previously, earlier, ahead, prior
- 言及
- genkyū — Mention, reference to something in speech or writing
- 所蔵
- shozō — In the collection of, owned and stored by
- 写本
- shahon — Manuscript, handwritten copy of a text
- 自分
- jibun — Oneself, myself, yourself (reflexive pronoun)
- 印
- shirushi / in — Mark, sign, seal, indicator placed on something
- つけ
- tsuke — To attach, mark, put on (stem of つける)
- 多く
- ōku — Many, much, a large number or amount
- 同一
- dōitsu — Same, identical, one and the same
- 箇所
- kasho — Place, passage, section, specific location in text
- 存在
- sonzai — Existence, presence, being
- する
- suru — To do, to perform an action
- 常識
- jōshiki — Common sense, general knowledge, conventional wisdom
- 導き出せる
- michibikidaseru — Can derive, draw out, or deduce a conclusion
- 唯一
- yuiitsu — Only, sole, unique, the one and only
- 結論
- ketsuron — Conclusion, final judgment or decision
- 引き出そ
- hikidaso — To draw out, extract, elicit (volitional stem)
- う
- u — Volitional ending meaning let's or intend to
- 国内
- kokunai — Domestic, within the country, internal
- および
- oyobi — And, as well as (formal conjunction)
- 大陸
- tairiku — Continent, mainland
- において
- ni oite — In, at, regarding (formal locative expression)
- かなり
- kanari — Considerably, fairly, quite, rather
- 名声
- meisei — Fame, reputation, renown, celebrity
- 享受
- kyōju — To enjoy, receive and appreciate (a benefit)
- 多数
- tasū — Large number, many, majority
- 適切
- tekisetsu — Appropriate, suitable, proper, fitting
- 価値
- kachi — Value, worth, merit
- 割り当てる
- wariateru — To assign, allocate, apportion to something
- 何ら
- nanra — Any, whatever; (with negative) no, none at all
- 困難
- konnan — Difficulty, hardship, trouble
- 見出さ
- miidasa — To find, discover, identify (negative stem here)
- だろ
- daro — Probably, I suppose (informal conjecture form)
- 私
- watashi — I, me (first-person singular pronoun)
- 信じる
- shinjiru — To believe, trust, have faith in
- さらに
- sara ni — Furthermore, even more, additionally
- これ
- kore — This, this thing (near demonstrative pronoun)
- より
- yori — Than; from; by means of (comparative particle)
- 確保
- kakuho — To secure, ensure, guarantee, obtain
- 利点
- riten — Advantage, merit, benefit, strong point
- 謎
- nazo — Mystery, puzzle, enigma, riddle
- へ
- e — Toward, to (directional particle)
- 過度
- kado — Excessive, too much, extreme, immoderate
- 傾倒
- keitō — Deep devotion, absorption, infatuation with something
- 発見
- hakken — Discovery, finding, detection
- それら
- sorera — Those (plural demonstrative pronoun)
- なくなる
- nakunaru — To disappear, cease to exist, run out
- 気づく
- kizuku — To notice, realize, become aware of
Unlock audio playback, vocabulary games, and reading progress tracking.
Create free account →