On the Method of Zadig: Essay #1 from "Science and Hebrew Tradition" — Page 14
At the present day, it would probably be impossible to find any sane advocate of this opinion; and the fact is rather surprising, that among the people from whom the circle-squarers, perpetual-motioners, flat-earthed men and the like, are recruited, to say nothing of table-turners and spirit-rappers, somebody has not perceived the easy avenue to nonsensical notoriety open to any one who will take up the good old doctrine, that fossils are all _lusus naturae._
現代においては、この意見の正気な支持者を見つけることはおそらく不可能であろう。そして、円積問題狂や永久機関信奉者、地球平面論者などの類いを輩出する人々の中から、テーブル・ターナーや心霊術師はもちろんのこと、化石はすべて「自然の戯れ」であるという由緒ある教義を掲げようとする者なら誰にでも開かれている、たわいもない悪名への安易な道を、誰も見出していないという事実はかなり意外である。
The position would be impregnable, inasmuch as it is quite impossible to prove the contrary.
その立場は難攻不落であろう。なぜなら、その反対を証明することはまったく不可能だからである。
If a man choose to maintain that a fossil oyster shell, in spite of its correspondence, down to every minutest particular, with that of an oyster fresh taken out of the sea, was never tenanted by a living oyster, but is a mineral concretion, there is no demonstrating his error.
ある人が、化石のカキの殻は、海から取り出したばかりのカキの殻と細部に至るまで一致しているにもかかわらず、生きたカキが宿ったことはなく、単なる鉱物の凝集物に過ぎないと主張することを選ぶならば、その誤りを証明する方法はない。
All that can be done is to show him that, by a parity of reasoning, he is bound to admit that a heap of oyster shells outside a fishmonger's door may also be "sports of nature," and that a mutton bone in a dust-bin may have had the like origin.
できることはただ、同じ論法によれば、魚屋の戸口の外に積まれたカキの殻の山もまた「自然の戯れ」である可能性があり、ごみ箱の中の羊の骨も同様の起源を持つ可能性があることを認めざるを得ないと、彼に示すことだけである。
And when you cannot prove that people are wrong, but only that they are absurd, the best course is to let them alone.
そして、人々が間違っていることを証明できず、ただ彼らが馬鹿げていることしか示せないときには、そっとしておくのが最善の策である。
Vocabulary
- 現代
- gendai — Modern era; the present age or times.
- において
- ni oite — In; at; regarding a specific place or context.
- は
- wa — Topic marker particle indicating the sentence topic.
- この
- kono — This; referring to something near the speaker.
- 意見
- iken — Opinion; a personal view or judgment on something.
- の
- no — Possessive or linking particle connecting nouns.
- 正気
- shōki — Sanity; being in a sound or rational mental state.
- な
- na — Adjectival particle linking na-adjectives to nouns.
- 支持者
- shijisha — Supporter; a person who backs or endorses something.
- を
- wo — Object marker particle indicating the direct object.
- 見つける
- mitsukeru — To find; to discover or locate something.
- こと
- koto — Thing; nominalizer turning verbs into noun phrases.
- おそらく
- osoraku — Probably; most likely; used to express conjecture.
- 不可能
- fukanō — Impossible; not able to be done or achieved.
- で
- de — Particle indicating means, location of action, or state.
- あろう
- arō — Probably is; volitional form expressing supposition.
- そして
- soshite — And then; furthermore; connecting sequential statements.
- や
- ya — And; listing particle for non-exhaustive enumeration.
- 信奉者
- Devotee; a fervent believer or follower of something.
- など
- nado — Etc.; and so on; used for non-exhaustive listing.
- 類い
- tagui — Kind; sort; a group of similar types or people.
- 輩出
- haishutsu — Producing; bringing forth many talented or notable people.
- する
- suru — To do; general verb indicating action or performance.
- 人々
- hitobito — People; multiple persons or individuals in general.
- 中
- naka — Among; inside; within a group or space.
- から
- kara — From; indicating origin, cause, or starting point.
- もちろん
- mochiron — Of course; naturally; goes without saying.
- 化石
- kaseki — Fossil; preserved remains of ancient organisms in rock.
- すべて
- subete — All; everything; the entirety of something.
- 自然
- shizen — Nature; the natural world; also means natural or spontaneous.
- 戯れ
- tawamure — Play; jest; a playful or capricious act or whim.
- ある
- aru — To exist; to be; used for inanimate things or abstract existence.
- という
- to iu — Called; known as; used to define or label something.
- 由緒
- yuisho — History; lineage; time-honored origin or distinguished pedigree.
- 教義
- kyōgi — Doctrine; a set of principles or beliefs taught formally.
- と
- to — And; with; quotation particle connecting clauses or items.
- 者
- mono / sha — Person; one who does something; a practitioner or agent.
- なら
- nara — If; conditional particle implying a contextual supposition.
- 誰
- dare — Who; anyone; referring to an unspecified person.
- に
- ni — To; at; in; directional or target marker particle.
- でも
- demo — Even; anyone; used for inclusive or concessive meaning.
- 開か
- hiraka — Open (stem form); be accessible or available to someone.
- れて
- rete — Passive auxiliary indicating something is done to the subject.
- いる
- iru — To be; exists as ongoing state; auxiliary for progressive actions.
- たわいも
- tawai mo — Trivial; worthless; used in phrase meaning utterly insignificant.
- ない
- nai — Not; negative form negating verbs or adjectives.
- 悪名
- akumyō — Infamy; a bad or notorious reputation among others.
- へ
- e — To; toward; directional particle indicating movement or direction.
- 安易
- an'i — Easy; simplistic; taking the path of least resistance.
- 道
- michi — Road; path; way toward a destination or goal.
- も
- mo — Also; too; even; inclusive addition particle.
- 見出して
- miidashite — Having found; discovering or identifying something new.
- いない
- inai — Is not; negative progressive indicating absence of action.
- 事実
- jijitsu — Fact; an actual truth or verified piece of information.
- かなり
- kanari — Quite; considerably; to a fairly great degree.
- 意外
- igai — Unexpected; surprising; contrary to what was anticipated.
- その
- sono — That; referring to something previously mentioned or understood.
- 立場
- tachiba — Standpoint; position; one's viewpoint or situational stance.
- なぜなら
- nazenara — Because; the reason is; introducing a causal explanation.
- 反対
- hantai — Opposition; against; the contrary side or disagreement.
- 証明
- shōmei — Proof; demonstration; establishing truth through evidence.
- まったく
- mattaku — Completely; utterly; absolutely; used for strong emphasis.
- だ
- da — Is; plain form copula asserting identity or state.
- 人
- hito — Person; human being; an individual.
- が
- ga — Subject marker particle indicating the grammatical subject.
- カキ
- kaki — Oyster; a bivalve shellfish found in the sea.
- 殻
- kara — Shell; the hard outer casing of a creature.
- 海
- umi — Sea; ocean; a large body of salt water.
- 取り出した
- toridashita — Took out; extracted something from a place or container.
- ばかり
- bakari — Just; only; immediately after doing something.
- 細部
- saibu — Detail; minute particulars of something examined closely.
- 至る
- itaru — To reach; to extend to; arriving at every detail.
- まで
- made — Until; up to; as far as a certain point.
- 一致
- itchi — Agreement; correspondence; matching exactly in all respects.
- して
- shite — Doing; te-form of suru connecting sequential actions.
- かかわらず
- kakawarazu — Regardless; in spite of; notwithstanding certain conditions.
- 生き
- iki — Living (stem); being alive, as in a living organism.
- た
- ta — Past tense auxiliary indicating completed action or state.
- 宿った
- yadotta — Dwelled in; inhabited; a spirit or life lodged within.
- なく
- naku — Without; not having; negative connective form of nai.
- 単なる
- tan naru — Mere; nothing but; simply a particular thing and no more.
- 鉱物
- kōbutsu — Mineral; an inorganic naturally occurring solid substance.
- 過ぎ
- sugi — Merely; just; nothing more than a certain thing.
- 主張
- shuchō — Claim; assertion; insisting on a particular viewpoint.
- 選ぶ
- erabu — To choose; to select from among available options.
- ば
- ba — If; conditional particle expressing a hypothetical situation.
- 誤り
- ayamari — Error; mistake; something incorrect or wrongly done.
- 方法
- hōhō — Method; way; a means of doing something effectively.
- できる
- dekiru — Can; to be able to; capable of doing something.
- ただ
- tada — Only; merely; simply; nothing more than what follows.
- 同じ
- onaji — Same; identical; the very same thing or kind.
- 論法
- ronpō — Reasoning; logic; a method or style of argumentation.
- よれ
- yore — According to; based on; following a certain logic or standard.
- 魚屋
- sakanaya — Fishmonger; a shop or person selling fish.
- 戸口
- toguchi — Doorway; entrance; the threshold of a door or shop.
- 外
- soto — Outside; exterior; the area beyond a boundary.
- 積まれ
- tsummare — Piled up; stacked; placed in a heap or accumulation.
- 山
- yama — Mountain; also a large pile or heap of things.
- また
- mata — Also; again; furthermore; adding another point or item.
- 可能性
- kanōsei — Possibility; likelihood; the chance something may occur.
- あり
- ari — There is; exists; connective form of aru.
- ごみ箱
- gomibako — Trash can; a container for disposing of waste or rubbish.
- 羊
- hitsuji — Sheep; a domesticated woolly farm animal.
- 骨
- hone — Bone; the hard skeletal structure inside an animal body.
- 同様
- dōyō — Similarly; in the same way; likewise comparable.
- 起源
- kigen — Origin; source; the point from which something derives.
- 持つ
- motsu — To have; to hold; to possess something physically or abstractly.
- 認め
- mitome — Acknowledging; admitting; recognizing something as true.
- ざる
- zaru — Negative attributive form; cannot; must not do something.
- 得
- e / u — To obtain; can; auxiliary indicating ability or compulsion.
- 彼
- kare — He; him; a male third-person pronoun.
- 示す
- shimesu — To show; to indicate; to demonstrate or point out.
- だけ
- dake — Only; just; limiting to a specific degree or amount.
- 間違って
- machigatte — Wrongly; incorrectly; in an erroneous manner.
- でき
- deki — Can; stem form of dekiru indicating capability.
- ず
- zu — Without; not; classical negative connective auxiliary.
- 彼ら
- karera — They; them; a group of people referred to previously.
- 馬鹿げて
- bakagete — Being absurd; acting foolishly or ridiculously in manner.
- しか
- shika — Only; nothing but; used with negatives for exclusivity.
- 示せ
- shimese — Show (imperative/conditional stem); demonstrate or prove something.
- とき
- toki — When; time; the moment or occasion something occurs.
- そっと
- sotto — Gently; quietly; softly; doing something with care or stealth.
- おく
- oku — To put; to leave as is; auxiliary indicating doing in advance.
- 最善
- saizen — Best; the optimal course of action available.
- 策
- saku — Strategy; plan; a course of action or clever measure.
Unlock audio playback, vocabulary games, and reading progress tracking.
Create free account →