On the Method of Zadig: Essay #1 from "Science and Hebrew Tradition" — Page 13
All that can be said is, that the prospective prophecies of the astronomer are always verified; and that, inasmuch as his retrospective prophecies are the result of following backwards, the very same method as that which invariably leads to verified results, when it is worked forwards, there is as much reason for placing full confidence in the one as in the other.
言えることはただ、天文学者の将来予測は常に検証されるということ、そして彼の遡及的予測は、前向きに適用すれば必ず検証済みの結果をもたらすのとまったく同じ方法を逆向きにたどった結果であるがゆえに、一方を完全に信頼するのと同じだけの理由が他方を信頼することにも存在するということである。
Retrospective prophecy is therefore a legitimate function of astronomical science; and if it is legitimate for one science it is legitimate for all; the fundamental axiom on which it rests, the constancy of the order of nature, being the common foundation of all scientific thought.
遡及的予測はゆえに天文学の正当な機能であり、ある科学にとって正当であるならばすべての科学にとって正当である。その根拠となる根本的な公理、すなわち自然の秩序の不変性は、あらゆる科学的思考の共通の基盤をなすものだからである。
Indeed, if there can be grades in legitimacy, certain branches of science have the advantage over astronomy, in so far as their retrospective prophecies are not only susceptible of verification, but are sometimes strikingly verified.
実際、正当性に程度があるとすれば、いくつかの科学分野は天文学より有利な立場にある。それらの遡及的予測は検証が可能なだけでなく、時として著しく鮮やかに検証されることがあるからだ。
Such a science exists in that application of the principles of biology to the interpretation of the animal and vegetable remains imbedded in the rocks which compose the surface of the globe, which is called Palaeontology.
そのような科学が、地球の表面を構成する岩石の中に埋め込まれた動植物の遺骸の解釈に生物学の原理を応用したものとして存在しており、それは古生物学と呼ばれる。
At no very distant time, the question whether these so-called "fossils," were really the remains of animals and plants was hotly disputed.
それほど遠くない時代には、いわゆる「化石」が本当に動植物の遺骸であるかどうかという問題が激しく議論されていた。
Very learned persons maintained that they were nothing of the kind, but a sort of concretion, or crystallisation, which had taken place within the stone in which they are found; and which simulated the forms of animal and vegetable life, just as frost on a window-pane imitates vegetation.
非常に博識な人々は、それらはそのようなものでは全くなく、発見された石の内部で生じた一種の結核または結晶化であり、窓ガラスの霜が植物を模倣するように、動植物の形を模していたにすぎないと主張した。
Vocabulary
- 言え
- ie — Even so; that being said (concessive expression)
- こと
- koto — Thing; fact; matter (nominalizer)
- は
- wa — Topic marker particle
- ただ
- tada — Only; merely; however; but
- 天文
- tenmon — Astronomy; relating to celestial phenomena
- 学者
- gakusha — Scholar; academic; learned person
- の
- no — Possessive or nominalizing particle
- 将来
- shōrai — Future; one's prospects going forward
- 予測
- yosoku — Prediction; forecast; anticipation of future events
- 常に
- tsuneni — Always; constantly; at all times
- 検証
- kenshō — Verification; testing; confirming validity of something
- される
- sareru — Passive verb ending; to be done to
- という
- to iu — Called; known as; the fact that
- そして
- soshite — And then; and; furthermore
- 彼
- kare — He; him; that person (male)
- 的
- teki — Suffix meaning '-like', '-al', or '-ive'
- 前向き
- maemuki — Forward-looking; positive; proactive attitude
- に
- ni — Particle indicating direction, time, or purpose
- 適用
- tekiyō — Application; putting a rule into practice
- すれ
- sure — Conditional form of suru (to do)
- ば
- ba — Conditional particle meaning 'if' or 'when'
- 必ず
- kanarazu — Certainly; without fail; always
- 済み
- zumi — Already done; completed; finished (suffix)
- 結果
- kekka — Result; outcome; consequence
- を
- wo — Object marker particle
- もたらす
- motarasu — To bring about; to cause; to produce a result
- と
- to — Quotation or conjunctive particle; and; with
- まったく
- mattaku — Completely; entirely; absolutely; indeed
- 同じ
- onaji — Same; identical; equal
- 方法
- hōhō — Method; way; means of doing something
- 逆向き
- sakamuki — Reversed direction; backward-facing orientation
- たどっ
- tadot- — Traced; followed a path (stem of tadoru)
- た
- ta — Past tense auxiliary verb ending
- で
- de — Particle indicating means, location, or cause
- ある
- aru — To be; to exist (for inanimate things)
- が
- ga — Subject marker particle; but; however
- ゆえ
- yue — Because; therefore; reason; cause
- 一方
- ippō — On one hand; meanwhile; one side
- 完全
- kanzen — Complete; perfect; total; absolute
- 信頼
- shinrai — Trust; confidence; reliance on someone
- する
- suru — To do; to perform; general action verb
- だけ
- dake — Only; just; as much as
- 理由
- riyū — Reason; grounds; cause for something
- 他方
- tahō — On the other hand; the other side
- も
- mo — Also; too; even; as well
- 存在
- sonzai — Existence; being; presence of something
- 学
- gaku — Learning; study; science; academic discipline
- 正当
- seitō — Legitimate; justifiable; proper; rightful
- な
- na — Adjectival ending for na-adjectives
- 機能
- kinō — Function; capability; role something plays
- あり
- ari — There is; exists; having (classical/formal form)
- 科学
- kagaku — Science; natural or empirical study
- とっ
- tot- — Stem form of toru; here used in 'totte' (for)
- て
- te — Conjunctive particle connecting verb phrases
- なら
- nara — If; in that case; as for (conditional)
- すべて
- subete — All; everything; entirely
- その
- sono — That (demonstrative adjective near listener)
- 根拠
- konkyo — Basis; grounds; evidence for a claim
- なる
- naru — To become; to form; to be (predicative)
- 根本
- konpon — Root; foundation; fundamental basis
- 公理
- kōri — Axiom; self-evident fundamental principle
- すなわち
- sunawachi — That is; namely; in other words
- 自然
- shizen — Nature; natural; occurring without human intervention
- 秩序
- chitsujo — Order; discipline; organized arrangement
- 不変
- fuhen — Invariance; constancy; unchanging nature
- 性
- sei / shō — Suffix indicating nature, quality, or property
- あらゆる
- arayuru — Every; all kinds of; any possible
- 思考
- shikō — Thought; thinking; reasoning process
- 共通
- kyōtsū — Common; shared; mutual to all parties
- 基盤
- kiban — Foundation; base; underlying platform
- なす
- nasu — To form; to constitute; to make up
- もの
- mono — Thing; object; that which is (nominalizer)
- だ
- da — Copula; plain form of 'to be'
- から
- kara — Because; from; since (reason or origin)
- 実際
- jissai — In reality; actually; in practice
- 程度
- teido — Degree; extent; level; measure
- いくつ
- ikutsu — How many; several; a number of
- か
- ka — Question particle or 'some-' prefix in compounds
- 分野
- bun'ya — Field; area; domain of study or work
- より
- yori — More than; compared to; from
- 有利
- yūri — Advantageous; favorable; beneficial position
- 立場
- tachiba — Position; standpoint; one's situation or stance
- それら
- sorera — Those (plural demonstrative pronoun)
- 可能
- kanō — Possible; feasible; capable of being done
- なく
- naku — Without; not having; lacking (negative conjunctive)
- 時
- toki — Time; moment; occasion; when
- として
- toshite — As; in the capacity of; sometimes
- 著しく
- ichijirushiku — Remarkably; notably; to a striking degree
- 鮮やか
- azayaka — Vivid; brilliant; clear; striking in appearance
- よう
- yō — Like; as if; seeming; in the manner of
- 地球
- chikyū — Earth; the planet we live on
- 表面
- hyōmen — Surface; outer face; exterior layer
- 構成
- kōsei — Composition; structure; forming a whole
- 岩石
- ganseki — Rock; stone; geological mineral matter
- 中
- naka — Inside; within; middle; among
- 埋め込ま
- umekoma — Embedded; buried within (stem form)
- れ
- re — Passive auxiliary verb stem
- 動植物
- dōshokubutsu — Animals and plants; living organisms collectively
- 遺骸
- igai — Remains; corpse; dead body of organism
- 解釈
- kaishaku — Interpretation; explanation; reading of meaning
- 生物
- seibutsu — Living organism; life form; creature
- 原理
- genri — Principle; fundamental law or theory
- 応用
- ōyō — Application; applied use of knowledge
- し
- shi — Conjunctive verb form; and (listing reasons)
- おり
- ori — Continuous state; being (humble/formal form)
- それ
- sore — That; it (mid-distance demonstrative pronoun)
- 古
- ko / furu — Old; ancient; prefix meaning antiquity
- 呼ば
- yoba — Called; named (stem of yobu, to call)
- れる
- reru — Passive or potential auxiliary verb ending
- それほど
- sorehodo — That much; to that extent; so very
- 遠く
- tōku — Far away; distant; long ago
- ない
- nai — Not; negative adjective or auxiliary
- 時代
- jidai — Era; age; period of history
- いわゆる
- iwayuru — So-called; what is known as
- 化石
- kaseki — Fossil; preserved remains of ancient life
- 本当
- hontō — Really; truly; genuine; the truth
- どう
- dō — How; in what way; what about
- 問題
- mondai — Problem; question; issue; matter of concern
- 激しく
- hageshiku — Fiercely; intensely; violently; vigorously
- 議論
- giron — Argument; debate; discussion of an issue
- さ
- sa — Nominalizing suffix or softening sentence particle
- い
- i — Verb stem ending or adjective base form
- 非常
- hijō — Extremely; very; unusual; extraordinary
- 博識
- hakushiki — Erudite; broadly knowledgeable; well-read person
- 人々
- hitobito — People; persons; various individuals
- 全く
- mattaku — Completely; entirely; not at all (with negative)
- 発見
- hakken — Discovery; finding something previously unknown
- 石
- ishi — Stone; rock; pebble
- 内部
- naibu — Interior; inside; internal part
- 生じ
- shōji — Arising; occurring; being produced (stem form)
- 一種
- isshu — A kind of; a type of; a sort
- 結核
- kekkaku — Tuberculosis; also nodule or concretion
- または
- matawa — Or; either; alternatively
- 結晶
- kesshō — Crystal; crystallization; beautiful product of effort
- 化
- ka — Suffix meaning '-ization' or becoming something
- 窓
- mado — Window; opening in a wall
- ガラス
- garasu — Glass; transparent material (loanword)
- 霜
- shimo — Frost; ice crystals formed on cold surfaces
- 植物
- shokubutsu — Plant; vegetation; flora
- 模倣
- mohō — Imitation; mimicry; copying another's form
- 形
- katachi — Shape; form; figure; appearance
- 模し
- moshi — Imitating; modeled after (stem of masu)
- すぎ
- sugi — Too much; excessively; going beyond proper limit
- 主張
- shuchō — Claim; assertion; insisting on one's view
Unlock audio playback, vocabulary games, and reading progress tracking.
Create free account →