On the Method of Zadig: Essay #1 from "Science and Hebrew Tradition" — Page 7
Those who are interested in learning more of the fateful history of Zadig must turn to the original; we are dealing with him only as a philosopher, and this brief excerpt suffices for the exemplification of the nature of his conclusions and of the methods by which he arrived at them.
자디그의 운명적인 역사에 대해 더 알고 싶은 사람들은 원문을 참고해야 한다. 우리는 그를 오직 철학자로서만 다루고 있으며, 이 짧은 발췌문은 그의 결론의 성격과 그가 그 결론에 도달한 방법을 예시하기에 충분하다.
These conclusions may be said to be of the nature of retrospective prophecies; though it is perhaps a little hazardous to employ phraseology which perilously suggests a contradiction in terms--the word "prophecy" being so constantly, in ordinary use, restricted to "foretelling."
이러한 결론들은 회고적 예언의 성격을 띤다고 할 수 있다. 다만 용어상의 모순을 위험스럽게 암시하는 어법을 사용하는 것은 다소 위험할 수도 있는데, "예언"이라는 단어가 일상적인 용법에서는 너무나 일관되게 "예고"로만 한정되어 있기 때문이다.
Strictly, however, the term prophecy applies as much to outspeaking as to foretelling; and, even in the restricted sense of "divination," it is obvious that the essence of the prophetic operation does not lie in its backward or forward relation to the course of time, but in the fact that it is the apprehension of that which lies out of the sphere of immediate knowledge; the seeing of that which, to the natural sense of the seer, is invisible.
그러나 엄밀히 말하면, 예언이라는 용어는 예고만큼이나 공언에도 적용된다. 심지어 "점술"이라는 제한된 의미에서도, 예언적 작업의 본질은 시간의 흐름에 대한 과거 혹은 미래의 관계에 있는 것이 아니라, 직접적인 지식의 영역 밖에 놓인 것을 파악하는 것, 즉 예언자의 자연적 감각으로는 보이지 않는 것을 보는 것에 있음이 분명하다.
The foreteller asserts that, at some future time, a properly situated observer will witness certain events; the clairvoyant declares that, at this present time, certain things are to be witnessed a thousand miles away; the retrospective prophet (would that there were such a word as "backteller!") affirms that, so many hours or years ago, such and such things were to be seen.
예고자는 미래의 어느 시점에 적절한 위치에 있는 관찰자가 특정 사건들을 목격하게 될 것이라고 주장한다. 천리안을 가진 자는 현재 이 순간에 특정한 일들이 천 마일 떨어진 곳에서 목격되고 있다고 선언한다. 회고적 예언자("역보고자"와 같은 단어가 있었으면 얼마나 좋을까!)는 몇 시간 혹은 몇 년 전에 이러저러한 것들이 보였을 것이라고 단언한다.
Vocabulary
- 운명적인
- unmyeongjeok-in — Fateful, destined, or related to fate
- 역사에
- yeoksae — To or regarding history
- 대해
- daehae — About, regarding, or concerning something
- 더
- deo — More, additionally, or further
- 알고
- algo — Knowing; gerund form of 'to know'
- 싶은
- sipeun — Wanting to; modifier expressing desire
- 사람들은
- saramdeureun — People (topic-marked plural form)
- 원문을
- wonmuneul — The original text (object-marked)
- 참고해야
- chamgohaeya — Must refer to or consult something
- 한다
- handa — Does; plain declarative verb ending
- 우리는
- urineun — We (topic-marked first-person plural)
- 그를
- geureul — Him (object-marked third-person singular)
- 오직
- ojik — Only, solely, exclusively
- 철학자로서만
- cheolhakjaroseo-man — Only as a philosopher (role-limiting particle)
- 다루고
- darugo — Handling, dealing with, or treating
- 있으며
- isseuMyeo — And there is; connective continuative form
- 이
- i — This; demonstrative determiner for nearby referent
- 짧은
- jjalbeun — Short, brief in length or duration
- 발췌문은
- balchwemuneun — The excerpt or extract (topic-marked)
- 그의
- geuui — His; third-person singular possessive
- 결론의
- gyeolronui — Of the conclusion (possessive form)
- 성격과
- seonggyeokgwa — Nature or character, and (conjunctive)
- 그가
- geuga — He; third-person singular subject form
- 그
- geu — That; definite determiner or third-person pronoun
- 결론에
- gyeolrone — To or at the conclusion (locative)
- 도달한
- dodaran — Having reached or arrived at something
- 방법을
- bangbeobeul — The method or way (object-marked)
- 예시하기에
- yesihagie — For the purpose of illustrating or exemplifying
- 충분하다
- chungbunhada — Is sufficient, enough, or adequate
- 이러한
- ireuhan — Such, this kind of, these sorts of
- 결론들은
- gyeolrondeureun — The conclusions (plural, topic-marked)
- 회고적
- hoegojjeok — Retrospective, looking back at the past
- 예언의
- yeeoni — Of prophecy or prediction (possessive)
- 성격을
- seonggyeogeul — The nature or character (object-marked)
- 띤다고
- ttindago — Is said to bear or exhibit a quality
- 할
- hal — Will do; prospective modifier of action
- 수
- su — Ability or possibility (bound noun)
- 있다
- itda — There is; to exist or to have
- 다만
- daman — However, but, only with a caveat
- 용어상의
- yongeosangui — Terminological, relating to specific terminology
- 모순을
- mosuneul — Contradiction or inconsistency (object-marked)
- 위험스럽게
- wiheomseureobge — Dangerously, in a risky or hazardous manner
- 암시하는
- amsihaneun — Suggesting, implying, or hinting at something
- 어법을
- eobeob-eul — Usage or phrasing of language (object-marked)
- 사용하는
- sayonghaneun — Using, employing, or making use of
- 것은
- geoseun — The thing or act of (topic-marked nominalizer)
- 다소
- daso — Somewhat, rather, to some degree
- 위험할
- wiheomhal — Will be or may be dangerous or risky
- 수도
- sudo — Also possibly; possibility with inclusive particle
- 있는데
- inneunde — There is, but; contrastive connective existence
- 예언
- yeon — Prophecy, prediction, or prophetic declaration
- 이라는
- iraneun — Called, known as (quotative modifier)
- 단어가
- daneo-ga — The word or term (subject-marked)
- 일상적인
- ilsangjeok-in — Everyday, ordinary, or commonly used
- 용법에서는
- yongbeobeseo-neun — In common usage or practice (topic-marked)
- 너무나
- neomuna — So very, excessively, or extremely so
- 일관되게
- ilgwandoege — Consistently, uniformly, without deviation
- 예고
- yego — Advance notice, prior announcement, or foretelling
- 로만
- roman — Only as, limited solely to (particle combo)
- 한정되어
- hanjeongdoeeo — Being restricted or limited to something
- 있기
- itgi — Being in a state; nominalized existence form
- 때문이다
- ttaemunida — It is because; causal concluding expression
- 그러나
- geureona — However, but, yet (contrastive conjunction)
- 엄밀히
- eomilhi — Strictly, precisely, or rigorously speaking
- 말하면
- malhaMyen — If one says; conditional speaking expression
- 예언이라는
- yeeon-iraneun — Called or known as prophecy (quotative modifier)
- 용어는
- yongeoneun — The term or terminology (topic-marked)
- 예고만큼이나
- yegomankeum-ina — As much as foretelling or advance notice
- 공언에도
- gongeone-do — Also to public declaration or avowal
- 적용된다
- jeogyongdoenda — Is applied, is applicable to something
- 심지어
- simjeo — Even, going so far as to say
- 점술
- jeomsul — Divination, fortune-telling, or mantic arts
- 제한된
- jehandan — Limited, restricted, or constrained sense
- 의미에서도
- uimieseo-do — Even in the sense or meaning of
- 예언적
- yeeeonjeok — Prophetic, of or relating to prophecy
- 작업의
- jageobi — Of the work or task (possessive form)
- 본질은
- bonjireun — The essence or nature (topic-marked)
- 시간의
- siganui — Of time (possessive, relating to time)
- 흐름에
- heureum-e — In the flow or passage of something
- 대한
- daehan — Regarding, about, or toward something
- 과거
- gwageo — The past, former times or history
- 혹은
- hogeun — Or, alternatively (formal disjunctive conjunction)
- 미래의
- miraeui — Of the future (possessive modifier)
- 관계에
- gwangye-e — In relation or relationship to something
- 있는
- inneun — That exists or is present (modifier form)
- 것이
- geosi — The thing that is (subject-marked nominalizer)
- 아니라
- anira — Not that, but rather (negating connector)
- 직접적인
- jikjeobjeok-in — Direct, immediate, or firsthand
- 지식의
- jisigui — Of knowledge (possessive form)
- 영역
- yeongyeok — Domain, realm, or sphere of something
- 밖에
- bakke — Outside of, beyond, except for
- 놓인
- nonin — Placed, situated, or lying outside
- 것을
- geoseul — The thing (object-marked nominalizer)
- 파악하는
- paaghaneun — Grasping, comprehending, or perceiving something
- 것
- geot — Thing, act, or fact (general nominalizer)
- 즉
- jeuk — That is, namely, in other words
- 예언자의
- yeeonjaui — Of the prophet (possessive form)
- 자연적
- jayeonjeok — Natural, relating to nature or natural ability
- 감각으로는
- gamgageuro-neun — With or through the natural senses (topic)
- 보이지
- boiji — Not visible; negated form of 'to be seen'
- 않는
- anneun — Not doing; negative continuous modifier
- 보는
- boneun — Seeing, looking at (present modifier form)
- 것에
- geose — In the act of; locative nominalizer form
- 있음이
- isseum-i — The fact of being (subject-marked nominalization)
- 분명하다
- bunMyeonghada — Is clear, evident, or obvious
- 어느
- eoneu — Some, a certain, or which (indefinite determiner)
- 시점에
- sijeome — At a certain point in time
- 적절한
- jeokjeolhan — Appropriate, suitable, or fitting
- 위치에
- wichie — In a position or location (locative)
- 관찰자가
- gwanchalJaga — The observer or watcher (subject-marked)
- 특정
- teukjeong — Specific, particular, or designated
- 사건들을
- sageondeureur — The events or incidents (plural, object-marked)
- 목격하게
- mokgyeokhage — So as to witness or observe something
- 될
- doel — Will become; future prospective modifier
- 것이라고
- geosirago — Saying that it will be (quotative form)
- 주장한다
- jujangHanda — Claims, asserts, or argues something
- 천리안을
- cheollian-eul — Clairvoyance or far-sight ability (object-marked)
- 가진
- gajin — Having or possessing something
- 자는
- janeun — The person who (topic-marked relative form)
- 현재
- hyeonjae — The present moment or current time
- 순간에
- sungane — At the moment or instant (locative)
- 특정한
- teukjeonghan — Specific, particular, or definite things
- 일들이
- ildeuri — Things or affairs (plural, subject-marked)
- 천
- cheon — One thousand (numeral)
- 마일
- mail — Mile (unit of distance, loanword)
- 떨어진
- tteoheojin — Separated, distant, or removed from
- 곳에서
- goseseo — From or at a place or location
- 목격되고
- mokgyeokdoego — Being witnessed or observed (passive continuative)
- 있다고
- itdago — Saying that there is or it exists
- 선언한다
- seoneonhanda — Declares, proclaims, or announces formally
- 예언자
- yeeonja — Prophet, seer, or prophetic person
- 와
- wa — And, with (conjunctive particle after vowel)
- 같은
- gateun — Same as, like, or similar to
- 있었으면
- isseosse-umyeon — If only there had been (conditional wish)
- 얼마나
- eolmana — How much, to what extent (exclamatory)
- 좋을까
- joeulkka — How nice it would be (rhetorical wish)
- 는
- neun — Topic particle marking the subject of sentence
- 몇
- myeot — Several, a few, or how many
- 시간
- sigan — Time, hour, or duration
- 년
- nyeon — Year (counter for years)
- 전에
- jeone — Before, ago, or prior to something
- 것들이
- geotdeuri — Things (plural, subject-marked nominalizer)
- 보였을
- boyeotsseul — Would have been seen (past conjecture modifier)
- 단언한다
- daneonhanda — Asserts definitively, declares with certainty
Unlock audio playback, vocabulary games, and reading progress tracking.
Create free account →