On the Method of Zadig: Essay #1 from "Science and Hebrew Tradition" — Page 11
History, in the ordinary acceptation of the word, is based upon the interpretation of documentary evidence; and documents would have no evidential value unless historians were justified in their assumption that they have come into existence by the operation of causes similar to those of which documents are, in our present experience, the effects.
역사는, 통상적인 의미에서, 문서적 증거의 해석에 기반을 두고 있다. 그리고 문서는, 역사가들이 그것이 현재 우리의 경험상 문서를 결과로 낳는 것과 유사한 원인들의 작용에 의해 존재하게 되었다는 가정을 정당하게 품을 수 없다면, 아무런 증거적 가치도 지니지 못할 것이다.
If a written history can be produced otherwise than by human agency, or if the man who wrote a given document was actuated by other than ordinary human motives, such documents are of no more evidential value than so many arabesques.
만약 기록된 역사가 인간의 행위가 아닌 다른 방식으로 만들어질 수 있다면, 혹은 특정 문서를 작성한 사람이 평범한 인간적 동기가 아닌 다른 것에 의해 움직였다면, 그러한 문서들은 수많은 아라베스크 문양과 다를 바 없는 증거적 가치밖에 지니지 못한다.
Archaeology, which takes up the thread of history beyond the point at which documentary evidence fails us, could have no existence, except for our well grounded confidence that monuments and works of art or artifice, have never been produced by causes different in kind from those to which they now owe their origin.
고고학은, 문서적 증거가 우리에게 더 이상 도움이 되지 않는 지점을 넘어서 역사의 실마리를 이어가는 학문인데, 기념물과 예술 작품 혹은 인공물이 현재 그것들의 기원을 이루는 원인들과 본질적으로 다른 원인들에 의해 만들어진 적이 없다는 우리의 확고한 신뢰가 없다면 존재할 수 없을 것이다.
And geology, which traces back the course of history beyond the limits of archaeology, could tell us nothing except for the assumption that, millions of years ago, water, heat, gravitation, friction, animal and vegetable life, caused effects of the same kind as they now cause.
그리고 지질학은, 고고학의 한계를 넘어서 역사의 흐름을 추적하는 학문인데, 수백만 년 전에도 물, 열, 중력, 마찰, 동물과 식물의 생명이 지금과 동일한 종류의 결과를 야기했다는 가정이 없다면 우리에게 아무것도 말해줄 수 없을 것이다.
Nay, even physical astronomy, in so far as it takes us back to the uttermost point of time which palaetiological science can reach, is founded upon the same assumption.
아니, 심지어 자연 천문학도, 고생물학적 과학이 도달할 수 있는 시간의 가장 먼 지점까지 우리를 데려가는 한, 동일한 가정 위에 기반을 두고 있다.
If the law of gravitation ever failed to be true, even to a small extent, for that period, the calculations of the astronomer have no application.
만약 중력의 법칙이 그 시기에 조금이라도 사실이 아닌 것으로 판명된다면, 천문학자의 계산은 아무런 적용 가능성도 갖지 못하게 된다.
Vocabulary
- 역사는
- yeoksa-neun — History (topic marker attached)
- 통상적인
- tongsangjeogin — Conventional, ordinary, or typical in nature
- 의미에서
- uimi-eseo — In the sense or meaning of something
- 문서적
- munseojeok — Documentary, relating to written documents or records
- 증거의
- jeunggeo-ui — Of evidence; possessive form of evidence
- 해석에
- haeseok-e — In the interpretation of something
- 기반을
- giban-eul — Foundation or basis (object marker attached)
- 두고
- dugo — Placing or basing upon something
- 있다
- itda — To exist or to be present
- 그리고
- geurigo — And; used to connect sentences or clauses
- 문서는
- munseo-neun — Document or written record (topic marker attached)
- 역사가들이
- yeoksaga-deul-i — Historians (subject marker attached)
- 그것이
- geugeos-i — It or that thing (subject marker attached)
- 현재
- hyeonjae — Present time; currently or at this moment
- 우리의
- uri-ui — Our; possessive form of we
- 경험상
- gyeongheom-sang — Based on experience; from an experiential standpoint
- 문서를
- munseo-reul — Document (object marker attached)
- 결과로
- gyeolgwa-ro — As a result; as an outcome of something
- 낳는
- nanneun — Producing or giving rise to a result
- 것과
- geot-gwa — Thing and; connecting clauses with comparison
- 유사한
- yusahan — Similar or analogous to something else
- 원인들의
- wonin-deul-ui — Of causes; possessive plural form of cause
- 작용에
- jagyong-e — In the operation or action of something
- 의해
- uihae — By means of; through the agency of
- 존재하게
- jonjaeha-ge — So as to exist; to come into existence
- 되었다는
- doeeotda-neun — That it became; reported past tense modifier
- 가정을
- gajeong-eul — Assumption or hypothesis (object marker attached)
- 정당하게
- jeongdanghage — Legitimately or justifiably; in a rightful manner
- 품을
- pumеul — To hold or harbor (an idea) (object marker)
- 수
- su — Ability or possibility; used in potential constructions
- 없다면
- eopda-myeon — If there is not; conditional absence
- 아무런
- amureon — Any; used in negative sentences meaning no whatsoever
- 증거적
- jeungeojeok — Evidential; relating to the nature of evidence
- 가치도
- gachi-do — Even value; not even worth or value
- 지니지
- jinji — Not possessing or holding something
- 못할
- mothal — Unable to; future modifier of inability
- 것이다
- geosida — It is the case that; assertive sentence ending
- 만약
- manyak — If; conditional conjunction introducing a hypothesis
- 기록된
- girokdoen — Recorded or documented in written form
- 역사가
- yeoksaga — History or historian depending on context
- 인간의
- ingan-ui — Human; possessive form relating to humanity
- 행위가
- haengwi-ga — Act or action (subject marker attached)
- 아닌
- anin — Not being; negative attributive modifier
- 다른
- dareun — Different or other; another kind
- 방식으로
- bangsik-euro — By way of; in a manner or method
- 만들어질
- mandeureojil — To be made or created (future passive modifier)
- 있다면
- itda-myeon — If there is; conditional existence clause
- 혹은
- hogeun — Or; alternatively used to present another option
- 특정
- teukjeong — Specific or particular; referring to a designated item
- 작성한
- jakseongan — Who wrote or composed a document
- 사람이
- saram-i — Person (subject marker attached)
- 평범한
- pyeongbeomhan — Ordinary or average; not special or unusual
- 인간적
- inganjeok — Human; characteristic of or relating to humans
- 동기가
- donggi-ga — Motive or motivation (subject marker attached)
- 것에
- geot-e — In the thing; locative form of a nominalizer
- 움직였다면
- umjigyeotda-myeon — If one was moved or motivated by something
- 그러한
- geureohan — Such; of that kind or nature
- 문서들은
- munseo-deul-eun — Documents (plural, topic marker attached)
- 수많은
- sumaneun — Countless or numerous; a very large number
- 문양과
- munyang-gwa — Pattern and; decorative motif with connector
- 다를
- dareul — To be different (object or modifier form)
- 바
- ba — Way or difference; used in comparative expressions
- 없는
- eomneun — Not having; lacking something entirely
- 가치밖에
- gachi-bakke — Nothing but value; only worth this much
- 못한다
- mothanda — Cannot; is unable to do something
- 고고학은
- gogohak-eun — Archaeology (topic marker attached)
- 증거가
- jeunggeo-ga — Evidence (subject marker attached)
- 우리에게
- uri-ege — To us; dative form of the first-person plural
- 더
- deo — More; to a greater degree or extent
- 이상
- isang — More than; beyond a certain point or limit
- 도움이
- doum-i — Help or assistance (subject marker attached)
- 되지
- doeji — Not becoming; negative connective form of become
- 않는
- anneun — Not doing; negative present attributive form
- 지점을
- jijeom-eul — Point or spot (object marker attached)
- 넘어서
- neomeoseo — Going beyond or surpassing a certain point
- 역사의
- yeoksa-ui — Of history; possessive form of history
- 실마리를
- silmari-reul — Clue or thread of a story (object marker)
- 이어가는
- ieoganeun — Continuing or carrying on something further
- 학문인데
- hangmun-inde — It is an academic discipline; explanatory connector
- 기념물과
- ginyeommul-gwa — Monument and; commemorative structure with connector
- 예술
- yesul — Art; creative expression in various forms
- 작품
- jakpum — Work of art or literary creation
- 인공물이
- ingongmul-i — Artifact or man-made object (subject marker)
- 그것들의
- geugeot-deul-ui — Their; possessive plural form of those things
- 기원을
- giwon-eul — Origin or source (object marker attached)
- 이루는
- iruneun — Forming or constituting something
- 원인들과
- wonin-deul-gwa — Causes and; plural causes with connector
- 본질적으로
- bonjiljeok-euro — Essentially or fundamentally by nature
- 원인들에
- wonin-deul-e — In or by causes; locative plural of cause
- 만들어진
- mandeureojin — That was made or created; past passive modifier
- 적이
- jeogi — Experience of having done; used in past experience
- 없다는
- eopda-neun — That there is not; reported negative existence
- 확고한
- hwakgohan — Firm or unwavering; solidly established belief
- 신뢰가
- sinroe-ga — Trust or confidence (subject marker attached)
- 존재할
- jonjaehal — That will exist; future modifier of existence
- 없을
- eopseul — There will not be; future negative existence modifier
- 지질학은
- jijilhak-eun — Geology (topic marker attached)
- 고고학의
- gogohak-ui — Of archaeology; possessive form of archaeology
- 한계를
- hangye-reul — Limit or boundary (object marker attached)
- 흐름을
- heureum-eul — Flow or current (object marker attached)
- 추적하는
- chujeokaneun — Tracing or tracking something over time
- 수백만
- subaengman — Millions; several million in number
- 년
- nyeon — Year; unit of time measurement
- 전에도
- jeone-do — Even before; also in the past time
- 물
- mul — Water; basic liquid substance
- 열
- yeol — Heat; thermal energy
- 중력
- jungnyeok — Gravity; force of attraction between masses
- 마찰
- machal — Friction; resistance between surfaces in contact
- 동물과
- dongmul-gwa — Animal and; fauna with connector
- 식물의
- singmul-ui — Of plants; possessive form of plant life
- 생명이
- saengmyeong-i — Life (subject marker attached)
- 지금과
- jigeum-gwa — Now and; present time with connector
- 동일한
- dongilhan — Identical or the same; exactly alike
- 종류의
- jongnyu-ui — Of a kind or type; possessive of category
- 결과를
- gyeolgwa-reul — Result or outcome (object marker attached)
- 야기했다는
- yagihaeotda-neun — That it caused or brought about something
- 가정이
- gajeong-i — Assumption or hypothesis (subject marker attached)
- 아무것도
- amugeotdo — Nothing at all; not anything whatsoever
- 말해줄
- malhaejul — To tell or inform someone something
- 아니
- ani — No; negation or denial
- 심지어
- simjieo — Even; used to emphasize an extreme case
- 자연
- jayeon — Nature; the natural world and environment
- 천문학도
- cheonmunhak-do — Even astronomy; astronomy with additive particle
- 과학이
- gwahak-i — Science (subject marker attached)
- 도달할
- dodalhal — That can reach; future modifier of reaching
- 있는
- inneun — That exists or is present; present modifier
- 시간의
- sigan-ui — Of time; possessive form of time
- 가장
- gajang — Most; superlative degree marker
- 먼
- meon — Far or distant; remote in space or time
- 지점까지
- jijeom-kkaji — Up to a point; as far as a certain place
- 우리를
- uri-reul — Us (object marker attached)
- 데려가는
- deryeoganeun — Taking someone along to a place
- 한
- han — One; as long as; a limiting condition
- 가정
- gajeong — Assumption or hypothesis; a presupposed condition
- 위에
- wie — On top of; above or based upon
- 중력의
- jungnyeok-ui — Of gravity; possessive form of gravitational force
- 법칙이
- beopchik-i — Law or rule (subject marker attached)
- 그
- geu — That; a demonstrative determiner
- 시기에
- sigi-e — At that time; in that period or era
- 조금이라도
- jogeumira-do — Even a little; even slightly at all
- 사실이
- sasil-i — Fact or truth (subject marker attached)
- 것으로
- geoseuro — As something; instrumental nominalizer form
- 판명된다면
- panmyeongdoendaemyeon — If it turns out or is proven to be
- 천문학자의
- cheonmunhakja-ui — Astronomer's; possessive form of astronomer
- 계산은
- gyesan-eun — Calculation (topic marker attached)
- 적용
- jeogyong — Application; putting something into practical use
- 가능성도
- ganeungseong-do — Even possibility; feasibility with additive particle
- 갖지
- gatji — Not having or possessing something
- 못하게
- mothage — So as to be unable to; causing inability
- 된다
- doenda — It becomes; present tense of to become
Unlock audio playback, vocabulary games, and reading progress tracking.
Create free account →