On the Method of Zadig: Essay #1 from "Science and Hebrew Tradition" — Page 15
The whole fabric of palaeontology, in fact, falls to the ground unless we admit the validity of Zadig's great principle, that like effects imply like causes, and that the process of reasoning from a shell, or a tooth, or a bone, to the nature of the animal to which it belonged, rests absolutely on the assumption that the likeness of this shell, or tooth, or bone, to that of some animal with which we are already acquainted, is such that we are justified in inferring a corresponding degree of likeness in the rest of the two organisms.
사실, 고생물학의 전체 체계는 자디그의 위대한 원리, 즉 유사한 결과는 유사한 원인을 내포한다는 원리의 타당성을 인정하지 않으면 무너지고 만다. 그리고 조개껍데기나 이빨, 혹은 뼈로부터 그것이 속했던 동물의 본질을 추론하는 과정은, 이 조개껍데기나 이빨, 혹은 뼈가 우리가 이미 알고 있는 어떤 동물의 것과 유사하다는 사실이 두 생물체의 나머지 부분에서도 그에 상응하는 정도의 유사성을 추론하는 데 정당성을 부여할 만큼 충분하다는 가정에 전적으로 의존한다.
It is on this very simple principle, and not upon imaginary laws of physiological correlation, about which, in most cases, we know nothing whatever, that the so-called restorations of the palaeontologist are based.
소위 고생물학자의 복원은 대부분의 경우 우리가 전혀 알지 못하는 생리학적 상관관계에 관한 가상의 법칙이 아니라, 바로 이 매우 단순한 원리에 기초하고 있다.
Abundant illustrations of this truth will occur to every one who is familiar with palaeontology; none is more suitable than the case of the so-called _Belemnites._
이 진리에 대한 풍부한 사례들은 고생물학에 익숙한 모든 사람에게 떠오를 것이다. 그 중 소위 벨렘나이트의 사례보다 더 적합한 것은 없다.
In the early days of the study of fossils, this name was given to certain elongated stony bodies, ending at one extremity in a conical point, and truncated at the other, which were commonly reputed to be thunderbolts, and as such to have descended from the sky.
화석 연구 초기에 이 이름은 한쪽 끝이 원뿔형 뾰족한 점으로 끝나고 다른 쪽은 잘린 형태의 특정 길쭉한 돌 같은 물체들에 붙여졌는데, 이것들은 흔히 벼락이라고 여겨졌으며 하늘에서 내려온 것으로 간주되었다.
They are common enough in some parts of England; and, in the condition in which they are ordinarily found, it might be difficult to give satisfactory reasons for denying them to be merely mineral bodies.
그것들은 잉글랜드의 일부 지역에서 꽤 흔하게 발견된다. 그리고 그것들이 통상적으로 발견되는 상태에서는, 그것들이 단순한 광물 덩어리가 아니라고 부정할 만한 충분한 이유를 제시하기가 어려울 수도 있다.
Vocabulary
- 사실
- sasil — fact, truth, reality in a given context
- 전체
- jeonche — whole, entire, total amount or group
- 체계는
- chegyeneun — the system (topic-marked); organized structure
- 위대한
- widaehan — great, magnificent, of remarkable importance
- 원리
- wolli — principle, fundamental rule or law
- 즉
- jeuk — that is, namely, in other words
- 유사한
- yusahan — similar, analogous, resembling something else
- 결과는
- gyeolgwaneun — the result, outcome (topic-marked)
- 원인을
- wonineul — the cause, reason (object-marked)
- 원리의
- wolliui — of the principle; principle's (possessive)
- 타당성을
- tadangseong-eul — validity, reasonableness (object-marked)
- 인정하지
- injeonghaji — not acknowledging, not admitting (negated form)
- 않으면
- aneumyeon — if one does not; unless something is done
- 무너지고
- muneoijigo — collapses, crumbles (and then continues)
- 만다
- manda — ends up doing; resultant inevitability marker
- 그리고
- geurigo — and, furthermore, connecting two statements
- 조개껍데기나
- jogaekkeopdeogina — a shell or; seashell used as example
- 이빨
- ippal — tooth, teeth of an animal
- 혹은
- hogeun — or, alternatively, either one option
- 뼈로부터
- ppyeoreobuto — from the bone; starting from bone evidence
- 그것이
- geugeosi — it, that thing (subject-marked)
- 속했던
- sokhaetdeon — had belonged to; was part of previously
- 동물의
- dongmurui — of the animal; animal's (possessive form)
- 본질을
- bonjireul — the essence, nature (object-marked)
- 추론하는
- churonhaneun — inferring, deducing, reasoning toward a conclusion
- 과정은
- gwajeongeun — the process, procedure (topic-marked)
- 뼈가
- ppyeoga — the bone (subject-marked)
- 우리가
- uriga — we (subject-marked); first-person plural subject
- 이미
- imi — already, previously known or completed
- 알고
- algo — knowing (and); gerund form of to know
- 있는
- inneun — existing, being; present tense modifier
- 어떤
- eotteon — some, certain, what kind of thing
- 것과
- geotgwa — with the thing; compared to something known
- 유사하다는
- yusahadaneun — that it is similar; stating similarity as fact
- 사실이
- sasiri — the fact (subject-marked); fact that something is true
- 두
- du — two, a pair of (numeral modifier)
- 생물체의
- saengmulcheui — of the organism; belonging to living organism
- 나머지
- nameoji — remainder, the rest, remaining parts
- 부분에서도
- bubun-eseodo — even in the parts; also in remaining sections
- 그에
- geue — corresponding to that; in relation to it
- 상응하는
- sangeunghaneun — corresponding, matching proportionally to something
- 정도의
- jeongdoui — of the degree, extent (possessive modifier)
- 유사성을
- yusaseong-eul — similarity, resemblance (object-marked)
- 데
- de — the fact that; nominalizing grammatical particle
- 정당성을
- jeongdangseong-eul — justification, legitimacy (object-marked)
- 부여할
- buyeohal — to grant, to confer (future modifier form)
- 만큼
- mankeum — as much as, to the extent that
- 충분하다는
- chungbunhadaneun — that it is sufficient, enough for purpose
- 가정에
- gajeong-e — on the assumption, premise (locative-marked)
- 전적으로
- jeonjeog-euro — entirely, wholly, completely dependent on something
- 의존한다
- uijonhanda — depends on, relies upon something completely
- 소위
- sowi — so-called, what is termed, named as such
- 복원은
- bogwon-eun — the restoration, reconstruction (topic-marked)
- 대부분의
- daebubunui — most of, the majority of cases
- 경우
- gyeong-u — case, instance, circumstance, situation
- 전혀
- jeonhyeo — not at all, entirely not, completely none
- 알지
- alji — knowing (negation base); to know (verb stem)
- 못하는
- motaneun — unable to do; incapable of knowing
- 상관관계에
- sanggwangwangyee — in the correlation, relationship (locative-marked)
- 관한
- gwanhan — regarding, concerning, about a topic
- 가상의
- gasang-ui — hypothetical, imaginary, supposed (modifier form)
- 법칙이
- beopchigi — the law, rule (subject-marked)
- 아니라
- anira — not; it is not the case that
- 바로
- baro — right, exactly, directly, precisely
- 매우
- maeu — very, extremely, highly (adverb)
- 단순한
- dansunhan — simple, plain, uncomplicated in nature
- 기초하고
- gichohago — is based on, grounded in (and continues)
- 있다
- itda — exists, is present; to be, to have
- 진리에
- jillie — to truth, in truth (locative-marked)
- 대한
- daehan — regarding, about, concerning (prepositional modifier)
- 풍부한
- pungbuhan — rich, abundant, plentiful in amount
- 사례들은
- saryedeureun — the examples, cases (plural topic-marked)
- 익숙한
- ikssukan — familiar with, accustomed to something
- 모든
- modeun — every, all, each one without exception
- 사람에게
- sarame-ge — to a person, for someone (dative-marked)
- 떠오를
- tteooреul — will come to mind, arise in thought
- 것이다
- geosida — it is the thing that; emphatic statement ending
- 그
- geu — that, the (demonstrative or article-like)
- 중
- jung — among, in the middle of a group
- 사례보다
- saryeboda — than the example; comparative particle used
- 더
- deo — more, further, additionally (comparative adverb)
- 적합한
- jeokhapan — suitable, appropriate, fitting for purpose
- 것은
- geoseun — the thing (topic-marked); that which is
- 없다
- eopda — does not exist, there is none, lacking
- 화석
- hwaseok — fossil; preserved remains of ancient organism
- 연구
- yeongu — research, study, investigation of a subject
- 초기에
- chogie — in the early stage, at the beginning
- 이름은
- ireumeun — the name (topic-marked); what something is called
- 한쪽
- hanjjok — one side, one direction, one end
- 끝이
- kkeuti — the end, tip (subject-marked)
- 뾰족한
- ppyojokhan — pointed, sharp-tipped, tapering to a point
- 점으로
- jeomeuro — to a point, ending as a dot or tip
- 끝나고
- kkeunnago — ending, concluding (and continuing further)
- 다른
- dareun — other, different, another (modifier)
- 쪽은
- jjogeun — the side, direction (topic-marked)
- 잘린
- jallin — cut off, severed (past modifier form)
- 형태의
- hyeongtaeui — of the shape, form (possessive modifier)
- 특정
- teukjeong — specific, particular, designated item
- 길쭉한
- gilttukan — elongated, oblong, stretched-out in shape
- 돌
- dol — stone, rock (noun)
- 같은
- gateun — same, like, similar to (modifier)
- 물체들에
- mulchedeure — to the objects, things (locative-marked plural)
- 이것들은
- igeotdeureun — these things (plural topic-marked demonstrative)
- 흔히
- heunhi — commonly, often, frequently encountered
- 벼락이라고
- byeoragirago — called thunderbolt; quoted as being lightning bolt
- 여겨졌으며
- yeoggyeojeosseumeyo — was considered, regarded as (and furthermore)
- 하늘에서
- haneureseo — from the sky, heaven (source-marked)
- 내려온
- naeryeon — came down, descended from above
- 것으로
- geoseuro — as the thing, regarded as; directional particle
- 간주되었다
- ganjudoeotda — was regarded, considered, deemed as something
- 그것들은
- geugeotdeureun — they, those things (plural topic-marked)
- 일부
- ilbu — part, some portion of a whole
- 지역에서
- jiyeog-eseo — in the region, area (locative source-marked)
- 꽤
- kkwae — quite, fairly, considerably (degree adverb)
- 흔하게
- heunhage — commonly, frequently, in an abundant manner
- 발견된다
- balgyeondoinda — is found, discovered (passive present tense)
- 그것들이
- geugeotdeuri — they, those things (subject-marked plural)
- 통상적으로
- tongsangjeog-euro — ordinarily, typically, in the usual manner
- 발견되는
- balgyeondoeneun — being found, discovered (present modifier form)
- 상태에서는
- sangtae-eseo-neun — in the state of; under given conditions (topic)
- 광물
- gwangmul — mineral, ore, inorganic natural substance
- 덩어리가
- deong-eoriga — the lump, chunk, mass (subject-marked)
- 아니라고
- anirago — saying it is not; quoted negation statement
- 부정할
- bujeonghal — to deny, negate (future modifier form)
- 만한
- manhan — worth doing, sufficient enough to justify
- 충분한
- chungbunhan — sufficient, enough, adequate for purpose
- 이유를
- iyureul — the reason, cause (object-marked)
- 제시하기가
- jesihagiga — presenting, suggesting (nominalized subject-marked)
- 어려울
- eoryeoul — difficult, hard (future/prospective modifier)
- 수도
- sudo — may also; possibility marker (also possible)
Unlock audio playback, vocabulary games, and reading progress tracking.
Create free account →