On the Method of Zadig: Essay #1 from "Science and Hebrew Tradition" — Page 11
History, in the ordinary acceptation of the word, is based upon the interpretation of documentary evidence; and documents would have no evidential value unless historians were justified in their assumption that they have come into existence by the operation of causes similar to those of which documents are, in our present experience, the effects.
历史,在这个词的通常含义上,是建立在对文献证据的解释之上的;而文献若要具有证据价值,历史学家就必须有理由相信,这些文献是由与我们目前经验中产生文献的原因相类似的原因所造成的。
If a written history can be produced otherwise than by human agency, or if the man who wrote a given document was actuated by other than ordinary human motives, such documents are of no more evidential value than so many arabesques.
如果一部文字历史可以由非人类的力量产生,或者如果撰写某一文献的人是受非寻常人类动机所驱使,那么这些文献的证据价值便与一堆阿拉伯式花纹无异。
Archaeology, which takes up the thread of history beyond the point at which documentary evidence fails us, could have no existence, except for our well grounded confidence that monuments and works of art or artifice, have never been produced by causes different in kind from those to which they now owe their origin.
考古学在文献证据无能为力之处接续历史的线索,若非我们有充分根据地相信,那些纪念碑以及艺术或人工制品,从未由与其现今起源原因在性质上不同的原因所产生,考古学便无从存在。
And geology, which traces back the course of history beyond the limits of archaeology, could tell us nothing except for the assumption that, millions of years ago, water, heat, gravitation, friction, animal and vegetable life, caused effects of the same kind as they now cause.
而地质学将历史的进程追溯至考古学的界限之外,若非基于这样一个假设,即数百万年前,水、热、引力、摩擦、动植物生命所造成的效果与它们如今所造成的效果属于同一类型,地质学便无从告诉我们任何事情。
Nay, even physical astronomy, in so far as it takes us back to the uttermost point of time which palaetiological science can reach, is founded upon the same assumption.
不仅如此,就连物理天文学,就其将我们带回古因学所能抵达的时间最远端而言,也是建立在同样的假设之上的。
If the law of gravitation ever failed to be true, even to a small extent, for that period, the calculations of the astronomer have no application.
如果引力定律在那一时期曾有过哪怕是微小程度的失效,天文学家的计算便毫无适用之处。
Vocabulary
- 历史
- lìshǐ — History; the study of past events.
- 在
- zài — At, in, on; indicates location or time.
- 这个
- zhège — This; referring to a specific thing nearby.
- 词
- cí — Word; term; a unit of language.
- 的
- de — Structural particle indicating possession or modification.
- 通常
- tōngcháng — Usually; normally; under ordinary circumstances.
- 含义
- hányì — Meaning; implication; the sense a word carries.
- 上
- shàng — On; above; used to indicate scope or aspect.
- 是
- shì — To be; linking verb indicating identity or state.
- 建立
- jiànlì — To establish; to build; to found something.
- 对
- duì — Toward; regarding; correct; directed at something.
- 文献
- wénxiàn — Documents; literature; written historical records.
- 证据
- zhèngjù — Evidence; proof; material supporting a claim.
- 解释
- jiěshì — To explain; to interpret; to clarify meaning.
- 之上
- zhī shàng — Above; upon; on top of something.
- 而
- ér — And; but; yet; conjunction linking clauses.
- 若要
- ruò yào — If one wants to; should one wish to.
- 具有
- jùyǒu — To possess; to have; to be endowed with.
- 价值
- jiàzhí — Value; worth; importance of something.
- 历史学家
- lìshǐ xuéjiā — Historian; a scholar who studies history.
- 就
- jiù — Then; precisely; used for emphasis or result.
- 必须
- bìxū — Must; have to; an obligation or requirement.
- 有
- yǒu — To have; there is/are; to exist.
- 理由
- lǐyóu — Reason; grounds; justification for a belief.
- 相信
- xiāngxìn — To believe; to trust; to have confidence in.
- 这些
- zhèxiē — These; referring to multiple nearby things.
- 由
- yóu — By; from; due to; caused by something.
- 与
- yǔ — And; with; together with something or someone.
- 我们
- wǒmen — We; us; first person plural pronoun.
- 目前
- mùqián — Currently; at present; at this moment.
- 经验
- jīngyàn — Experience; practical knowledge gained over time.
- 中
- zhōng — In; within; among; middle of something.
- 产生
- chǎnshēng — To produce; to generate; to give rise to.
- 原因
- yuányīn — Cause; reason; factor producing an effect.
- 相
- xiāng — Mutually; each other; indicates reciprocal action.
- 类似
- lèisì — Similar; resembling; alike in some way.
- 所
- suǒ — Particle preceding verbs to nominalize them.
- 造成
- zàochéng — To cause; to bring about; to result in.
- 如果
- rúguǒ — If; supposing; conditional conjunction.
- 一部
- yī bù — A volume; one part; a piece of writing.
- 文字
- wénzì — Written characters; text; written language.
- 可以
- kěyǐ — Can; may; to be permitted or able to.
- 非
- fēi — Not; non-; contrary to; negation prefix.
- 人类
- rénlèi — Humanity; humankind; the human species.
- 力量
- lìliang — Force; power; strength; capability.
- 或者
- huòzhě — Or; either...or; expressing alternatives.
- 撰写
- zhuànxiě — To write; to compose; to author a text.
- 某一
- mǒu yī — A certain; some particular; a specific one.
- 人
- rén — Person; people; human being.
- 受
- shòu — To receive; to be subject to; to undergo.
- 寻常
- xúncháng — Ordinary; usual; common; not special.
- 动机
- dòngjī — Motivation; motive; driving reason for action.
- 驱使
- qūshǐ — To drive; to impel; to urge into action.
- 那么
- nàme — Then; in that case; so; consequently.
- 便
- biàn — Then; thereupon; consequently; used for result.
- 一堆
- yī duī — A pile of; a heap of; a bunch of.
- 花纹
- huāwén — Pattern; decorative design; ornamental markings.
- 无异
- wúyì — No different from; equivalent to; indistinguishable.
- 考古学
- kǎogǔxué — Archaeology; study of ancient human remains.
- 无能为力
- wú néng wéi lì — Powerless; unable to do anything; helpless.
- 之处
- zhī chù — The place where; the point at which.
- 接续
- jiēxù — To continue; to pick up; to carry on from.
- 线索
- xiànsuǒ — Clue; thread; lead guiding an investigation.
- 若非
- ruòfēi — If not for; were it not for; unless.
- 充分
- chōngfèn — Sufficient; ample; fully adequate for a purpose.
- 根据
- gēnjù — Based on; according to; basis or grounds.
- 地
- de — Adverbial particle linking adverb to verb.
- 那些
- nàxiē — Those; referring to multiple distant things.
- 纪念碑
- jìniànbēi — Monument; memorial; commemorative structure or stone.
- 以及
- yǐjí — As well as; and also; together with.
- 艺术
- yìshù — Art; artistic works; creative expression.
- 或
- huò — Or; either; alternatively connecting two options.
- 人工
- réngōng — Artificial; man-made; done by human hands.
- 制品
- zhìpǐn — Products; manufactured items; made goods.
- 从未
- cóngwèi — Never; at no time; not ever before.
- 其
- qí — Its; their; his/her; third person possessive particle.
- 现今
- xiànjīn — Nowadays; currently; in the present time.
- 起源
- qǐyuán — Origin; source; the beginning of something.
- 性质
- xìngzhì — Nature; character; intrinsic quality of something.
- 不同
- bùtóng — Different; unlike; not the same as another.
- 无从
- wúcóng — Have no way to; unable to; no means of.
- 存在
- cúnzài — To exist; existence; to be present or real.
- 地质学
- dìzhìxué — Geology; science studying Earth's physical structure.
- 将
- jiāng — Will; shall; future marker; to take/bring.
- 进程
- jìnchéng — Process; progress; course of development over time.
- 追溯
- zhuīsù — To trace back; to go back to an origin.
- 至
- zhì — To; until; reaching as far as a point.
- 界限
- jièxiàn — Boundary; limit; dividing line between areas.
- 之外
- zhī wài — Beyond; outside of; past a certain boundary.
- 基于
- jīyú — Based on; premised upon; founded on something.
- 这样
- zhèyàng — Like this; in this way; such a manner.
- 一个
- yī gè — One; a single; general measure word for things.
- 假设
- jiǎshè — Assumption; hypothesis; a supposition for argument.
- 即
- jí — Namely; that is; i.e.; immediately.
- 数百万年
- shù bǎi wàn nián — Millions of years; an immense span of time.
- 前
- qián — Before; ago; in front of; prior to.
- 水
- shuǐ — Water; liquid; a fundamental natural substance.
- 热
- rè — Heat; hot; warmth; thermal energy.
- 引力
- yǐnlì — Gravity; gravitational force; attraction between masses.
- 摩擦
- mócā — Friction; rubbing; resistance between surfaces.
- 动植物
- dòng zhíwù — Animals and plants; living organisms collectively.
- 生命
- shēngmìng — Life; living existence; vitality of organisms.
- 效果
- xiàoguǒ — Effect; result; outcome of an action.
- 它们
- tāmen — They; them; third person plural for objects.
- 如今
- rújīn — Nowadays; at present; in today's times.
- 属于
- shǔyú — To belong to; to be part of a category.
- 同一
- tóngyī — The same; identical; one and the same.
- 类型
- lèixíng — Type; category; kind; classification of things.
- 告诉
- gàosu — To tell; to inform; to let someone know.
- 任何
- rènhé — Any; whatever; whichever; no matter which.
- 事情
- shìqing — Matter; thing; affair; an event or situation.
- 不仅如此
- bùjǐn rúcǐ — Not only that; moreover; beyond this point.
- 就连
- jiùlián — Even; going so far as to include something.
- 物理
- wùlǐ — Physics; the science of matter and energy.
- 天文学
- tiānwénxué — Astronomy; study of celestial bodies and space.
- 带回
- dài huí — To bring back; to carry back to a point.
- 所能
- suǒ néng — What is possible; that which can be done.
- 抵达
- dǐdá — To arrive at; to reach a destination.
- 时间
- shíjiān — Time; duration; a period or point in time.
- 最远端
- zuì yuǎn duān — Farthest end; most distant extremity or point.
- 而言
- éryán — As for; in terms of; speaking with regard to.
- 也是
- yě shì — Also is; likewise; equally the case.
- 同样
- tóngyàng — Same; equally; in the same way or manner.
- 定律
- dìnglǜ — Law; scientific law; fixed principle of nature.
- 那一
- nà yī — That one; referring to a specific distant time.
- 时期
- shíqī — Period; era; a span of historical time.
- 曾
- céng — Once; formerly; indicating past experience.
- 有过
- yǒuguò — Has had; once experienced; to have occurred.
- 哪怕
- nǎpà — Even if; even though; no matter how slight.
- 微小
- wēixiǎo — Tiny; minute; extremely small in degree.
- 程度
- chéngdù — Degree; extent; level of something's intensity.
- 失效
- shīxiào — To become invalid; to cease to be effective.
- 天文学家
- tiānwénxué jiā — Astronomer; scientist who studies celestial bodies.
- 计算
- jìsuàn — To calculate; to compute; mathematical reckoning.
- 毫无
- háowú — Completely without; utterly lacking; not at all.
- 适用
- shìyòng — Applicable; suitable; able to be applied here.
Unlock audio playback, vocabulary games, and reading progress tracking.
Create free account →