The Odyssey: Rendered into English prose for the use of those who cannot read the original — Page 2
The points in question are:
問題となっている点は以下の通りである:
(1) that the "Odyssey" was written entirely at, and drawn entirely from, the place now called Trapani on the West Coast of Sicily, alike as regards the Phaeacian and the Ithaca scenes; while the voyages of Ulysses, when once he is within easy reach of Sicily, solve themselves into a periplus of the island, practically from Trapani back to Trapani, via the Lipari islands, the Straits of Messina, and the island of Pantellaria.
(1)「オデュッセイア」は、ファイアキア人の場面およびイタカの場面のいずれに関しても、現在シチリア島西海岸のトラーパニと呼ばれる地において全編が執筆され、かつ全編がその地を素材として描かれたものであること;またウリュッセスの航海は、彼がシチリア島に容易に到達できる地点に達した後は、実質的にトラーパニを出発点として、リパリ諸島、メッシーナ海峡、パンテッレリア島を経由してトラーパニへと戻る島の周航記へと帰着するものであること。
(2) That the poem was entirely written by a very young woman, who lived at the place now called Trapani, and introduced herself into her work under the name of Nausicaa.
(2)この詩は、現在トラーパニと呼ばれる地に住んでいた非常に若い女性によって全編が書かれ、彼女はナウシカアという名のもとに自らを作品の中に登場させたものであること。
The main arguments on which I base the first of these somewhat startling contentions, have been prominently and repeatedly before the English and Italian public ever since they appeared (without rejoinder) in the "Athenaeum" for January 30 and February 20, 1892.
これらのやや驚くべき主張のうち最初のものの根拠となる主要な論拠は、1892年1月30日および2月20日付の「アシニーアム」誌に(反論なしに)掲載されて以来、英国およびイタリアの読者の前に繰り返し広く提示されてきた。
Both contentions were urged (also without rejoinder) in the Johnian "Eagle" for the Lent and October terms of the same year.
両方の主張は、同年の四旬節学期および10月学期の「ジョニアン・イーグル」誌においても(同様に反論なしに)提唱された。
Nothing to which I should reply has reached me from any quarter, and knowing how anxiously I have endeavoured to learn the existence of any flaws in my argument, I begin to feel some confidence that, did such flaws exist, I should have heard, at any rate about some of them, before now.
いかなる方面からも、私が返答すべき意見は届いておらず、私が自らの論拠における欠陥の存在を知ろうと如何に熱心に努めてきたかを顧みるならば、もしそのような欠陥が存在するならば、少なくともその一部については今日までに耳にしていたはずであるという確信を次第に抱くようになっている。
Vocabulary
- 問題
- mondai — Problem or issue under discussion
- と
- to — Particle indicating quotation or conjunction
- なっ
- natt(e) — Became; connective form of naru
- て
- te — Conjunctive particle connecting clauses
- いる
- iru — To exist; indicates ongoing state or action
- 点
- ten — Point or aspect of a matter
- は
- wa — Topic-marking particle highlighting subject
- 以下
- ika — The following; below a certain level
- の
- no — Possessive or nominalizing particle
- 通り
- toori — As stated; in the manner described
- で
- de — Copula particle indicating state or means
- ある
- aru — To be; formal existential or copula verb
- 人
- hito / jin — Person or people of a group
- 場面
- bamen — Scene or setting within a narrative
- および
- oyobi — And; as well as; formal conjunction
- いずれ
- izure — Either; any; eventually; one of them
- に
- ni — Particle indicating direction, location, or time
- 関し
- kanshi — Concerning; regarding; relating to something
- も
- mo — Also; too; even; inclusive particle
- 現在
- genzai — Present time; currently existing situation
- 島
- shima — Island surrounded by water
- 西
- nishi — West, cardinal direction
- 海岸
- kaigan — Coastline or seashore area
- 呼ば
- yoba — Called; named; stem of yobu
- れる
- reru — Passive auxiliary verb suffix
- 地
- chi / tochi — Land; place; ground; locality
- おい
- oite — At; in; within a location (te-form)
- 全編
- zenpen — Entire work; whole text or volume
- が
- ga — Subject marker particle in Japanese grammar
- 執筆
- shippitsu — Writing; authoring a literary work
- さ
- sa — Nominalizing suffix or passive auxiliary stem
- れ
- re — Passive or potential verb conjugation ending
- かつ
- katsu — Moreover; furthermore; at the same time
- その
- sono — That; the aforementioned thing or place
- を
- wo — Object-marking particle in Japanese grammar
- 素材
- sozai — Material; subject matter used as source
- し
- shi — And; conjunctive form of suru verb
- 描か
- ega(ka) — Depicted; drawn; stem of egaku
- た
- ta — Past tense auxiliary verb ending
- もの
- mono — Thing; object; work; product
- こと
- koto — Fact; matter; nominalizer for verbal phrases
- また
- mata — Also; again; furthermore; in addition
- 航海
- kokai — Voyage; sea voyage; navigation by ship
- 彼
- kare — He; him; that male person
- 容易
- youi — Easy; simple; without difficulty
- 到達
- tootatsu — Reaching; arriving at a destination
- でき
- deki — Can do; be able to; stem of dekiru
- る
- ru — Dictionary form verb ending suffix
- 地点
- chiten — Location; specific point on a map
- 達し
- tass(hi) — Reached; arrived at; stem of tassuru
- 後
- ato / go — After; later; following a certain event
- 実質
- jisshitsu — Substance; actual content; real nature
- 的
- teki — Suffix meaning -like or -ical in nature
- 出発点
- shuppatsu-ten — Starting point; point of departure
- 諸島
- shotou — Islands; archipelago; group of islands
- 海峡
- kaikyo — Strait; narrow sea passage between lands
- 経由
- keiyu — Via; passing through a route or place
- へ
- e — Directional particle toward a destination
- 戻る
- modoru — To return; to go back to origin
- 記
- ki — Record; account; written narrative document
- する
- suru — To do; general-purpose action verb
- この
- kono — This; referring to something nearby
- 詩
- shi — Poem; poetry; verse composition
- 住ん
- sund(e) — Living; residing; stem of sumu
- い
- i — Conjunctive or stem form of iru
- 非常
- hijou — Extremely; very; exceptional degree
- 若い
- wakai — Young; youthful in age
- 女性
- josei — Woman; female person
- よっ
- yot(te) — By means of; due to; te-form of yoru
- 書か
- kaka — Written; stem of kaku (to write)
- 彼女
- kanojo — She; her; that female person
- いう
- iu — To say; named; called something
- 名
- na / mei — Name; given name of a person
- もと
- moto — Under; based on; origin or foundation
- 自ら
- mizukara — Oneself; personally; by one's own hand
- 作品
- sakuhin — Work of art, literature, or music
- 中
- naka / chuu — Inside; within; among a group
- 登場
- toujou — Appearance; entering the scene or stage
- せ
- se — Causative verb stem; let or make do
- これ
- kore — This; referring to nearby thing
- ら
- ra — Plural suffix for pronouns or nouns
- やや
- yaya — Somewhat; slightly; a little bit
- 驚く
- odoroku — To be surprised; to be astonished
- べき
- beki — Should; ought to; expected obligation
- 主張
- shuchou — Claim; assertion; argument put forward
- うち
- uchi — Among; within; inside a group
- 最初
- saisho — First; the very beginning
- 根拠
- konkyo — Basis; grounds; evidence for a claim
- なる
- naru — To become; to turn into something
- 主要
- shuyou — Main; principal; most important
- な
- na — Adjectival particle linking na-adjectives
- 論拠
- ronkyo — Argument; logical basis for reasoning
- 年
- nen — Year; counter for years
- 月
- tsuki / gatsu — Month; the moon
- 日
- hi / nichi — Day; sun; counter for days
- 付
- zuke / fu — Dated; attached to; bearing a date
- 誌
- shi — Magazine; periodical; journal publication
- 反論
- hanron — Counterargument; objection; rebuttal
- なし
- nashi — Without; none; absence of something
- 掲載
- keisai — Publication in print; carrying an article
- 以来
- irai — Since; ever since a past point in time
- 英国
- Eikoku — England; United Kingdom
- 読者
- dokusha — Reader; person who reads publications
- 前
- mae — Before; in front of; earlier
- 繰り返し
- kurikaeshi — Repeatedly; again and again; repetition
- 広く
- hiroku — Widely; broadly; extensively
- 提示
- teiji — Presentation; showing; putting forward evidence
- き
- ki — Past or conjunctive form of kuru or suffix
- 両方
- ryouhou — Both sides; both parties or things
- 同年
- dounen — The same year; that same calendar year
- 学期
- gakki — Academic term; school semester
- 同様
- douyou — Similarly; in the same way; likewise
- 提唱
- teishou — Advocacy; proposing or championing an idea
- いかなる
- ikanaru — Any; whatever; of any kind whatsoever
- 方面
- houmen — Direction; quarter; area or field
- から
- kara — From; because; since; starting point particle
- 私
- watashi — I; me; first-person pronoun
- 返答
- hentou — Reply; answer; response to a question
- す
- su — Shortened form of suru; to do
- 意見
- iken — Opinion; view; one's perspective
- 届い
- todoi — Reached; arrived; was delivered; stem of todoku
- おら
- ora — Not present; informal negative of oru
- ず
- zu — Negative verb suffix meaning without doing
- おける
- okeru — In; within; existing at a location
- 欠陥
- kekkan — Defect; flaw; shortcoming in something
- 存在
- sonzai — Existence; presence; being somewhere
- 知ろう
- shirou — Shall know; volitional form of shiru
- 如何
- ika / ikaga — How; in what way; formal interrogative
- 熱心
- nesshin — Enthusiastic; earnest; passionate effort
- 努め
- tsutome — Effort; striving; stem of tsutomeru
- か
- ka — Question particle at end of sentence
- 顧みる
- kaerimiru — To reflect on; to look back upon
- なら
- nara — If; conditional form expressing hypothesis
- ば
- ba — Conditional suffix meaning if or when
- もし
- moshi — If; supposing that; hypothetical opener
- よう
- you — It seems; like; in the manner of
- 少なく
- sukunaku — At least; few; small in number
- 一部
- ichibu — Part; some; a portion of the whole
- つい
- tsui — Unintentionally; just; recently; inadvertently
- 今日
- kyou / konnichi — Today; the present day
- まで
- made — Until; up to; as far as
- 耳
- mimi — Ear; the sense of hearing
- はず
- hazu — Expected; supposed to be the case
- 確信
- kakushin — Conviction; firm belief; certainty
- 次第
- shidai — Depending on; as soon as; order of things
- 抱く
- idaku / daku — To hold; to embrace; to harbor a feeling
Unlock audio playback, vocabulary games, and reading progress tracking.
Create free account →