The Odyssey: Rendered into English prose for the use of those who cannot read the original — Page 8
Any one who at the present day discusses the questions that have arisen round the "Iliad" since Wolf's time, without keeping it well before his reader's mind that the "Odyssey" was demonstrably written from one single neighbourhood, and hence (even though nothing else pointed to this conclusion) presumably by one person only—that it was written certainly before 750, and in all probability before 1000 B.C.—that the writer of this very early poem was demonstrably familiar with the "Iliad" as we now have it, borrowing as freely from those books whose genuineness has been most impugned, as from those which are admitted to be by Homer—any one who fails to keep these points before his readers, is hardly dealing equitably by them.
Qualquer pessoa que nos dias de hoje discuta as questões que surgiram em torno da "Ilíada" desde os tempos de Wolf, sem manter bem presente na mente de seu leitor que a "Odisseia" foi comprovadamente escrita a partir de uma única localidade, e portanto (mesmo que nada mais apontasse para essa conclusão) presumivelmente por uma única pessoa — que foi escrita certamente antes de 750, e com toda a probabilidade antes de 1000 a.C. — que o autor deste poema tão antigo estava comprovadamente familiarizado com a "Ilíada" tal como a temos hoje, tomando emprestado tão livremente daqueles livros cuja autenticidade foi mais contestada, quanto daqueles que são reconhecidos como sendo de Homero — qualquer pessoa que não consiga manter esses pontos diante de seus leitores, dificilmente estará agindo com equidade para com eles.
Any one on the other hand, who will mark his "Iliad" and his "Odyssey" from the copies in the British Museum above referred to, and who will draw the only inference that common sense can draw from the presence of so many identical passages in both poems, will, I believe, find no difficulty in assigning their proper value to a large number of books here and on the Continent that at present enjoy considerable reputations.
Qualquer pessoa, por outro lado, que marcar sua "Ilíada" e sua "Odisseia" a partir das cópias do Museu Britânico acima mencionadas, e que tirar a única conclusão que o bom senso pode tirar da presença de tantas passagens idênticas em ambos os poemas, não encontrará, creio eu, nenhuma dificuldade em atribuir o seu valor adequado a um grande número de obras aqui e no Continente que atualmente desfrutam de considerável reputação.
Furthermore, and this perhaps is an advantage better worth securing, he will find that many puzzles of the "Odyssey" cease to puzzle him on the discovery that they arise from over-saturation with the "Iliad.
Além disso, e esta é talvez uma vantagem que vale mais a pena conquistar, ele descobrirá que muitos enigmas da "Odisseia" deixam de intrigá-lo ao descobrir que surgem de uma saturação excessiva com a "Ilíada".
Vocabulary
- Qualquer
- Any, whichever; used to indicate any option
- pessoa
- Person; a human being or individual
- que
- That, which, who; a versatile connector word
- nos
- In the, us; preposition combined with article
- dias
- Days; plural of dia, unit of time
- de
- Of, from; basic preposition indicating origin or possession
- hoje
- Today; the current day
- discuta
- Discuss, debate; subjunctive form of discutir
- as
- The; feminine plural definite article
- questões
- Questions, issues; matters under discussion or debate
- surgiram
- Arose, emerged; past tense of surgir
- em
- In, at; basic preposition of location or time
- torno
- Around, concerning; used in phrase em torno de
- da
- Of the; contraction of de and a
- desde
- Since, from; indicating a starting point in time
- os
- The; masculine plural definite article
- tempos
- Times, eras; periods or epochs in history
- sem
- Without; preposition indicating absence or lack
- manter
- To keep, maintain; to hold something in a state
- bem
- Well, clearly; adverb indicating quality or degree
- presente
- Present, in mind; current or immediately available
- na
- In the; contraction of em and a
- mente
- Mind; the faculty of thought and consciousness
- seu
- His, her, your, its; third-person possessive pronoun
- leitor
- Reader; a person who reads a text
- a
- The; feminine singular definite article
- foi
- Was, went; past tense of ser or ir
- comprovadamente
- Provably, demonstrably; in a manner that has been proven
- escrita
- Written; past participle of escrever, feminine form
- partir
- From, starting from; to depart or proceed from
- uma
- A, one; feminine indefinite article or numeral
- única
- Unique, single, only; the sole one of its kind
- localidade
- Locality, place; a specific geographic location
- e
- And; basic coordinating conjunction
- portanto
- Therefore, thus; indicating logical consequence
- mesmo
- Even, same; used for emphasis or comparison
- nada
- Nothing; absence of anything
- mais
- More, else; indicating addition or greater degree
- apontasse
- Pointed to, indicated; past subjunctive of apontar
- para
- For, to, toward; preposition of direction or purpose
- essa
- That; feminine demonstrative pronoun or adjective
- conclusão
- Conclusion; the final result or logical deduction
- presumivelmente
- Presumably; as one would reasonably assume or suppose
- por
- By, through, for; preposition of agency or means
- certamente
- Certainly, surely; with confidence or assurance
- antes
- Before, previously; indicating earlier time
- com
- With; preposition indicating accompaniment or means
- toda
- All, entire, every; feminine form of todo
- probabilidade
- Probability, likelihood; chance that something will occur
- o
- The; masculine singular definite article
- autor
- Author; a person who writes a literary work
- deste
- Of this; contraction of de and este
- poema
- Poem; a piece of literary verse writing
- tão
- So, as; adverb indicating degree or comparison
- antigo
- Ancient, old; existing from a very early time
- estava
- Was; past imperfect tense of estar
- familiarizado
- Familiar, acquainted; having knowledge or experience of something
- tal
- Such, so; used to indicate a degree or comparison
- como
- How, like, as; conjunction or adverb of comparison
- temos
- We have; first-person plural present of ter
- tomando
- Taking; present participle of tomar
- emprestado
- Borrowed, lent; past participle of emprestar
- livremente
- Freely; in an unrestricted or unconstrained manner
- daqueles
- From those; contraction of de and aqueles
- livros
- Books; plural of livro, written or printed works
- cuja
- Whose; feminine relative pronoun indicating possession
- autenticidade
- Authenticity; quality of being genuine and original
- contestada
- Contested, disputed; questioned or challenged by others
- quanto
- As much as, how much; indicating degree or quantity
- são
- Are; third-person plural present tense of ser
- reconhecidos
- Recognized, acknowledged; accepted as genuine or valid
- sendo
- Being; present participle of ser
- qualquer
- Any, whatever; referring to an unspecified choice
- não
- No, not; basic negation word
- consiga
- Manages, succeeds; present subjunctive of conseguir
- esses
- Those; masculine plural demonstrative pronoun
- pontos
- Points; key aspects or arguments in a discussion
- diante
- Before, in front of; indicating presence or position
- seus
- His, her, their; masculine plural possessive pronoun
- leitores
- Readers; plural of leitor, persons who read
- dificilmente
- Hardly, barely; indicating something unlikely to happen
- estará
- Will be; future tense of estar
- agindo
- Acting; present participle of agir
- equidade
- Equity, fairness; impartiality and justice in treatment
- eles
- They, them; third-person masculine plural pronoun
- outro
- Other, another; referring to a different person or thing
- lado
- Side; one of two or more parts or directions
- marcar
- To mark, note; to indicate or record something
- sua
- His, her, your; feminine singular possessive pronoun
- das
- Of the; contraction of de and as
- cópias
- Copies; reproductions of an original text or document
- do
- Of the; contraction of de and o
- Museu
- Museum; institution preserving and displaying cultural artifacts
- Britânico
- British; relating to Britain or the United Kingdom
- acima
- Above, previously; referring to something mentioned earlier
- mencionadas
- Mentioned; previously referred to or cited
- tirar
- To draw, derive, remove; to extract or take out
- bom
- Good; of high quality or favorable nature
- senso
- Sense; rational judgment or common understanding
- pode
- Can, may; third-person singular of poder
- presença
- Presence; the state of being present or existing
- tantas
- So many; feminine plural indicating a large number
- passagens
- Passages; sections of a text or written work
- idênticas
- Identical; exactly the same in every detail
- ambos
- Both; referring to two things or people together
- poemas
- Poems; plural of poema, literary verse compositions
- encontrará
- Will find; future tense of encontrar
- creio
- I believe; first-person singular present of crer
- eu
- I; first-person singular subject pronoun
- nenhuma
- No, none; feminine form indicating absence of any
- dificuldade
- Difficulty; a situation that is hard to deal with
- atribuir
- To attribute, assign; to give credit or assign a quality
- valor
- Value, worth; the importance or usefulness of something
- adequado
- Adequate, suitable; meeting the required standard
- um
- A, one; masculine indefinite article or numeral
- grande
- Great, large; of considerable size or importance
- número
- Number; a quantity or count of things
- obras
- Works; literary, artistic, or scholarly productions
- aqui
- Here; in this place or location
- no
- In the; contraction of em and o
- Continente
- Continent; large landmass, here likely mainland Europe
- atualmente
- Currently, nowadays; at the present time
- desfrutam
- Enjoy; third-person plural present of desfrutar
- considerável
- Considerable; notably large or significant in degree
- reputação
- Reputation; the general opinion held about someone
- Além
- Beyond, furthermore; indicating addition or further point
- disso
- Of that, besides that; contraction of de and isso
- esta
- This; feminine singular demonstrative pronoun
- é
- Is; third-person singular present tense of ser
- talvez
- Perhaps, maybe; expressing uncertainty or possibility
- vantagem
- Advantage; a condition or circumstance that benefits someone
- vale
- Is worth; third-person singular present of valer
- pena
- Worth, trouble; used in vale a pena meaning worthwhile
- conquistar
- To conquer, achieve, win; to gain through effort
- ele
- He, him; third-person masculine singular pronoun
- descobrirá
- Will discover; future tense of descobrir
- muitos
- Many; masculine plural indicating a large quantity
- enigmas
- Enigmas, puzzles; things difficult to understand or explain
- deixam
- Let, allow, stop; third-person plural of deixar
- intrigá-lo
- To intrigue him; to puzzle or fascinate him
- ao
- To the; contraction of a and o
- descobrir
- To discover, find out; to learn something new
- surgem
- Arise, emerge; third-person plural present of surgir
- saturação
- Saturation; the state of being overly filled or saturated
- excessiva
- Excessive; going beyond normal or reasonable limits
Unlock audio playback, vocabulary games, and reading progress tracking.
Create free account →