The Republic — Page 4
We can only guess why the great design was abandoned; perhaps because Plato became sensible of some incongruity in a fictitious history, or because he had lost his interest in it, or because advancing years forbade the completion of it;
우리는 왜 그 위대한 계획이 포기되었는지 추측할 수 있을 뿐이다. 아마도 플라톤이 허구적 역사 속의 어떤 불일치를 감지했기 때문이거나, 그것에 대한 흥미를 잃었기 때문이거나, 혹은 나이가 들어감에 따라 그것의 완성이 불가능해졌기 때문일 것이다.
and we may please ourselves with the fancy that had this imaginary narrative ever been finished, we should have found Plato himself sympathising with the struggle for Hellenic independence (cp. Laws, iii. 698 ff.),
그리고 우리는 이 상상의 이야기가 완성되었더라면 플라톤 자신이 헬라스의 독립을 위한 투쟁에 공감했을 것이라는 상상으로 스스로를 즐겁게 할 수 있다(『법률』 3권 698절 이하 참조).
singing a hymn of triumph over Marathon and Salamis, perhaps making the reflection of Herodotus (v. 78) where he contemplates the growth of the Athenian empire—
마라톤과 살라미스에서의 승리를 찬양하는 송가를 노래하고, 아마도 아테네 제국의 성장을 고찰한 헤로도토스(5권 78절)의 성찰을 되새겼을 것이다.
'How brave a thing is freedom of speech, which has made the Athenians so far exceed every other state of Hellas in greatness!'
'언론의 자유는 얼마나 용감한 것인가, 그것은 아테네인들로 하여금 헬라스의 다른 모든 국가들을 훨씬 능가하게 만들었도다!'
or, more probably, attributing the victory to the ancient good order of Athens and to the favor of Apollo and Athene (cp. Introd. to Critias).
혹은, 더 가능성 있게는, 그 승리를 아테네의 고대의 훌륭한 질서와 아폴론과 아테나의 은총에 돌렸을 것이다(『크리티아스』 서론 참조).
Again, Plato may be regarded as the 'captain' ('arhchegoz') or leader of a goodly band of followers;
또한, 플라톤은 훌륭한 추종자들의 무리를 이끄는 '선장'('아르케고스') 또는 지도자로 여겨질 수 있다.
for in the Republic is to be found the original of Cicero's De Republica, of St. Augustine's City of God, of the Utopia of Sir Thomas More, and of the numerous other imaginary States which are framed upon the same model.
왜냐하면 『국가』에서 키케로의 『국가론』, 성 아우구스티누스의 『신국론』, 토머스 모어 경의 『유토피아』, 그리고 같은 모델을 바탕으로 구성된 수많은 다른 상상의 국가들의 원형을 찾을 수 있기 때문이다.
The extent to which Aristotle or the Aristotelian school were indebted to him in the Politics has been little recognised, and the recognition is the more necessary because it is not made by Aristotle himself.
아리스토텔레스 또는 아리스토텔레스 학파가 『정치학』에서 그에게 얼마나 많은 빚을 지고 있는지는 거의 인정받지 못해왔으며, 그 인정은 아리스토텔레스 자신에 의해 이루어지지 않았기 때문에 더욱 필요하다.
Vocabulary
- 우리는
- urineun — We (subject marker attached); refers to the speaker's group
- 왜
- wae — Why; used to ask for a reason or cause
- 그
- geu — That; a demonstrative pronoun or determiner
- 위대한
- widaehan — Great, magnificent; describing something of grand importance
- 계획이
- gyehoegi — Plan or project (subject form); an intended course of action
- 포기되었는지
- pogidoeeonneunji — Whether it was abandoned or given up
- 추측할
- achuseukal — To guess or speculate (modifier form)
- 수
- su — Ability or possibility; used in 'can' constructions
- 있을
- isseul — Will be; future modifier form of 'to exist/have'
- 뿐이다
- ppunida — Only; indicates limitation or restriction to one thing
- 아마도
- amado — Perhaps, probably; expresses uncertainty or conjecture
- 허구적
- heogujeok — Fictional, fictitious; relating to invented or imagined content
- 역사
- yeoksa — History; the study or record of past events
- 속의
- sogui — Inside of, within; indicating something contained in something
- 어떤
- eotteon — Some, certain, what kind of; an indefinite determiner
- 불일치를
- burirchirul — Inconsistency or discrepancy (object form)
- 감지했기
- gamjihaetgi — Because (he/she) detected or sensed something
- 때문이거나
- ttaemunigona — Because of, or due to; indicating one possible cause
- 그것에
- geugeose — To/about it; referring to a previously mentioned thing
- 대한
- daehan — Regarding, about; a postposition indicating subject matter
- 흥미를
- heungmireul — Interest (object form); curiosity or fascination in something
- 잃었기
- ireotgi — Because (he/she) lost something; past causal form
- 혹은
- hogeun — Or; a conjunction presenting an alternative option
- 나이가
- naiga — Age (subject form); the number of years one has lived
- 들어감에
- deurogame — As one advances in age; entering into older years
- 따라
- ttara — According to, following; in accordance with something
- 그것의
- geugeosui — Its; possessive form referring to a previously mentioned thing
- 완성이
- wanseongi — Completion (subject form); the state of being finished
- 불가능해졌기
- bulganeunghaejyeotgi — Because it became impossible; past causal form
- 때문일
- ttaemunil — Likely because of; causal modifier suggesting a reason
- 것이다
- geosida — It is the case that; a concluding assertive expression
- 그리고
- geurigo — And; a conjunction connecting two clauses or ideas
- 이
- i — This; a demonstrative determiner indicating something nearby
- 상상의
- sangsangui — Imaginary, of imagination; relating to something imagined
- 이야기가
- iyagiga — Story (subject form); a narrative or tale
- 완성되었더라면
- wanseomdoeeotdeoramyeon — If it had been completed; a contrary-to-fact conditional
- 자신이
- jasini — Oneself (subject form); referring reflexively to the subject
- 독립을
- dongnipeul — Independence (object form); freedom from external control
- 위한
- wihan — For the sake of; indicating purpose or benefit
- 투쟁에
- tujaenge — In the struggle or fight; a conflict for a cause
- 공감했을
- gonggamhaesseul — Would have sympathized or empathized with something
- 것이라는
- geosiraneun — That it would be; a nominal modifier expressing supposition
- 상상으로
- sangsanguro — Through imagination; by means of imagining something
- 스스로를
- seuseureul — Oneself (object form); reflexively referring to the subject
- 즐겁게
- jeulgeobge — Pleasurably, enjoyably; in a joyful or entertaining manner
- 할
- hal — To do (modifier form); future or potential action modifier
- 있다
- itda — To exist, to have; basic verb of existence or possession
- 3권
- 3 gwon — Volume 3, Book 3; indicating a section of a text
- 이하
- iha — Below, and following; indicating continuation after a point
- 참조
- chamjo — Reference, see also; directing reader to consult a source
- 승리를
- seungnirul — Victory (object form); triumph over an opponent or obstacle
- 찬양하는
- chanyanghanun — Praising, glorifying; expressing admiration or celebration
- 송가를
- songgareul — Ode (object form); a lyrical poem of praise or celebration
- 노래하고
- noraehago — Singing and; performing a song and doing something else
- 제국의
- jegugui — Of the empire; possessive relating to an imperial power
- 성장을
- seongjangul — Growth (object form); the process of developing or expanding
- 고찰한
- gochalhan — Examined, considered carefully; having reflected on something
- 성찰을
- seongchaleul — Reflection, introspection (object form); thoughtful self-examination
- 되새겼을
- doesaegyeosseul — Would have reflected on or pondered; past suppositional form
- 언론의
- eollonui — Of speech or press; relating to freedom of expression
- 자유는
- jayuneun — Freedom (topic form); the state of being free or unrestricted
- 얼마나
- eolmana — How much, how; an exclamatory or interrogative adverb
- 용감한
- yonggamhan — Brave, courageous; showing boldness in the face of danger
- 것인가
- geosingga — What a thing it is; an exclamatory concluding expression
- 그것은
- geugeoseun — It (topic form); referring to a previously mentioned subject
- 하여금
- hayeogeum — Causing someone to; used in causative constructions
- 다른
- dareun — Other, different; indicating something distinct from the rest
- 모든
- modeun — All, every; referring to the entirety of something
- 국가들을
- gukgadeulreul — States, nations (object plural); multiple countries or governments
- 훨씬
- hwolssin — Far, much more; indicating a large degree of difference
- 능가하게
- neunggahage — So as to surpass or exceed; going beyond others in ability
- 더
- deo — More; a comparative adverb indicating greater degree
- 가능성
- ganeungseong — Possibility, likelihood; the chance that something may occur
- 있게는
- itgeneun — More likely; adverbial form suggesting greater probability
- 고대의
- godaeui — Ancient, of antiquity; relating to very old historical periods
- 훌륭한
- hullyunghan — Excellent, admirable; of outstanding quality or character
- 질서와
- jilseowa — Order and; referring to orderliness combined with something else
- 은총에
- eunchonge — In the grace or favor of; divine blessing or benevolence
- 돌렸을
- dollyeosseul — Would have attributed or turned to; past suppositional form
- 서론
- seoron — Introduction, preface; the opening section of a written work
- 또한
- ttohan — Also, furthermore; an additive conjunction or adverb
- 추종자들의
- chujongjadurul — Of followers or disciples; possessive form for group of adherents
- 무리를
- murireul — Group, crowd (object form); a collection of people or animals
- 이끄는
- ikkeunun — Leading, guiding; present modifier form of 'to lead'
- 선장
- seonjang — Captain; the leader or commander of a ship or group
- 또는
- ttoneun — Or; a conjunction offering an alternative
- 지도자로
- jidojaro — As a leader; indicating the role or capacity of guiding others
- 여겨질
- yeogyeojil — To be regarded or considered as; future passive modifier
- 왜냐하면
- waenyahamyeon — Because, the reason is; introduces an explanatory clause
- 같은
- gateun — Such as, like; indicating similarity or giving an example
- 모델을
- modeleul — Model (object form); a template or example to be followed
- 바탕으로
- batangeuro — Based on, on the foundation of; using something as a basis
- 구성된
- guseongdoen — Composed, constructed; past passive modifier of 'to compose'
- 수많은
- sumaneun — Numerous, countless; a very large number of things
- 국가들의
- gukgadeurui — Of states or nations; possessive plural of country or state
- 원형을
- wonhyeongeul — Archetype, prototype (object form); the original model or form
- 찾을
- chajeul — To find (modifier form); future potential of 'to search/find'
- 있기
- itgi — There being; nominal form of 'to exist' used in explanations
- 때문이다
- ttaemuniida — It is because; a concluding causal statement
- 학파가
- hakpaga — School of thought (subject form); a group sharing a philosophy
- 그에게
- geuege — To him; dative form referring to a previously mentioned person
- 많은
- maneun — Many, much; indicating a large quantity or amount
- 빚을
- bicheul — Debt (object form); something owed intellectually or financially
- 지고
- jigo — Bearing, owing; present gerund of carrying a burden or debt
- 있는지는
- inneunji neun — Whether (they) owe; embedded question about a state of owing
- 거의
- geoui — Almost, barely; indicating something is close to but not quite
- 인정받지
- injeongtbatji — Not acknowledged; failing to receive recognition or credit
- 못해왔으며
- mothaewasseumyeo — Has not been able to, and; continued failure with continuation
- 인정은
- injeongeun — Acknowledgment (topic form); recognition or admission of something
- 자신에
- jasine — By oneself, to oneself; reflexive reference to the subject
- 의해
- uihae — By means of, by; indicates the agent of a passive action
- 이루어지지
- irueojiji — Not being accomplished; negative form of 'to be achieved'
- 않았기
- anatgi — Because (it) was not done; negative past causal connector
- 때문에
- ttaemune — Because of; a causal postposition indicating a reason
- 더욱
- deouk — Even more, increasingly; a comparative intensifying adverb
- 필요하다
- piryohada — Is necessary, needed; expressing that something is required
Unlock audio playback, vocabulary games, and reading progress tracking.
Create free account →