Beyond Good and Evil — Page 3
For it may be doubted, firstly, whether antitheses exist at all; and secondly, whether the popular valuations and antitheses of value upon which metaphysicians have set their seal, are not perhaps merely superficial estimates, merely provisional perspectives, besides being probably made from some corner, perhaps from below--"frog perspectives," as it were, to borrow an expression current among painters.
なぜなら、まず第一に、対立命題がそもそも存在するかどうか疑わしく、第二に、形而上学者たちがその刻印を押してきた通俗的な価値評価や価値の対立命題が、おそらくはただの表面的な見積もりに過ぎず、単なる暫定的な視点に過ぎないのではないか、しかもおそらくはある片隅から、あるいは下方から作られたものではないか――画家たちの間で流通している表現を借りれば、いわば「蛙の視点」ではないかと疑うことができるからである。
In spite of all the value which may belong to the true, the positive, and the unselfish, it might be possible that a higher and more fundamental value for life generally should be assigned to pretence, to the will to delusion, to selfishness, and cupidity.
真なるもの、積極的なもの、そして無私なるものに属するかもしれないあらゆる価値にもかかわらず、見せかけ、妄想への意志、利己心、そして貪欲に対して、生全般にとってより高く、より根本的な価値が与えられるべきである可能性があるかもしれない。
It might even be possible that WHAT constitutes the value of those good and respected things, consists precisely in their being insidiously related, knotted, and crocheted to these evil and apparently opposed things--perhaps even in being essentially identical with them.
それどころか、それらの善く尊ばれるものの価値を構成するものが、まさにそれらがこれらの悪しき、一見対立する事物と陰険に関係し、結びつき、絡み合っていることにあるのかもしれない――おそらくは本質的にそれらと同一であることにさえあるのかもしれない。
Perhaps! But who wishes to concern himself with such dangerous "Perhapses"!
おそらく!しかし、誰がそのような危険な「おそらく」に関わりたいと思うだろうか!
For that investigation one must await the advent of a new order of philosophers, such as will have other tastes and inclinations, the reverse of those hitherto prevalent--philosophers of the dangerous "Perhaps" in every sense of the term.
その探究のためには、これまで支配的であったものとは逆の、別の趣味と傾向を持つ新たな種類の哲学者たちの到来を待たなければならない――あらゆる意味における危険な「おそらく」の哲学者たちを。
And to speak in all seriousness, I see such new philosophers beginning to appear.
そして真剣に語るならば、私にはそのような新しい哲学者たちが現れ始めているのが見える。
3.
三。
Vocabulary
- なぜなら
- nazenara — because; the reason being that
- まず
- mazu — first of all; to begin with
- 第
- dai — prefix indicating ordinal numbers
- 一
- ichi / hito — the number one
- に
- ni — particle indicating direction, time, or purpose
- 対立
- tairitsu — opposition; conflict; confrontation between two sides
- 命題
- meidai — proposition; thesis; problem to be addressed
- が
- ga — subject-marking particle in Japanese grammar
- 存在
- sonzai — existence; being; presence of something
- する
- suru — to do; to perform an action
- か
- ka — question particle; or; whether
- どう
- dō — how; in what way
- 疑わしく
- utagawashiku — doubtfully; in a suspicious or questionable manner
- 二
- ni / futa — the number two
- 形而上学
- keijijōgaku — metaphysics; branch of philosophy studying abstract reality
- 者
- sha / mono — person; one who does something
- たち
- tachi — plural suffix for people or beings
- その
- sono — that; the (referring to something previously mentioned)
- 刻印
- kokuin — stamp; seal; imprint; brand mark
- を
- wo / o — object-marking particle in Japanese grammar
- 押し
- oshi — pushing; pressing; stamping
- て
- te — conjunctive particle linking verbs or clauses
- き
- ki — auxiliary indicating completed past action
- た
- ta — past tense auxiliary verb marker
- 通俗
- tsūzoku — popular; common; vulgar; ordinary and accessible
- 的
- teki — suffix meaning '-ic', '-al', or '-like'
- な
- na — adjectival linking particle; negative imperative
- 価値
- kachi — value; worth; merit of something
- 評価
- hyōka — evaluation; assessment; appraisal of value
- や
- ya — particle listing examples; and; or
- の
- no — possessive or nominalizing particle
- おそらく
- osoraku — probably; perhaps; most likely
- は
- wa — topic-marking particle in Japanese grammar
- ただ
- tada — merely; only; just; for free
- 表面
- hyōmen — surface; face; outward appearance of something
- 見積もり
- mitsumori — estimate; assessment; rough calculation
- 過ぎ
- sugi — too much; excessive; passing beyond a limit
- ず
- zu — negative auxiliary; without doing (classical)
- 単なる
- tannaru — mere; simple; nothing more than
- 暫定
- zantei — provisional; temporary; tentative arrangement
- 視点
- shiten — viewpoint; perspective; point of view
- ない
- nai — not; does not exist; negative form
- で
- de — particle indicating place, means, or reason
- しかも
- shikamo — moreover; furthermore; and yet
- ある
- aru — to exist; to be; to have (inanimate)
- 片隅
- katasumi — corner; nook; out-of-the-way place
- から
- kara — from; because; after; particle of origin
- い
- i — verb stem of いる; to be (animate)
- 下方
- kahō — lower direction; downward; below
- 作ら
- tsukura — stem of 作る; to make, create
- れ
- re — passive or potential auxiliary verb suffix
- もの
- mono — thing; object; matter; something
- 画家
- gaka — painter; artist who paints pictures
- 間
- aida / ma / kan — between; among; interval; space
- 流通
- ryūtsū — circulation; distribution; flow of goods or ideas
- し
- shi — conjunctive verb form; and; moreover
- いる
- iru — to be; to exist (for animate beings)
- 表現
- hyōgen — expression; representation; manner of conveying meaning
- 借りれ
- karire — conditional form of 借りる; to borrow
- ば
- ba — conditional particle meaning 'if' or 'when'
- いわば
- iwaba — so to speak; as it were; in a sense
- 蛙
- kaeru — frog; small amphibian living near water
- と
- to — particle meaning 'and', 'with', or quotation marker
- 疑う
- utagau — to doubt; to suspect; to question something
- こと
- koto — thing; fact; matter (abstract nominalizer)
- できる
- dekiru — to be able to; to be possible; can do
- 真
- shin / makoto — truth; genuine; real; authentic
- なる
- naru — to become; to be (classical attributive form)
- 積極
- sekkyoku — positivity; proactiveness; affirmative attitude
- そして
- soshite — and then; and; moreover; after that
- 無私
- mushi — selflessness; unselfishness; absence of self-interest
- 属する
- zokusuru — to belong to; to be affiliated with
- も
- mo — also; too; even; as well (particle)
- しれ
- shire — conditional form of しれる; may be; might
- あらゆる
- arayuru — all; every; any kind of thing
- かかわら
- kawara — stem of にかかわらず; regardless of; despite
- 見せかけ
- misekake — pretense; appearance; facade; show
- 妄想
- mōsō — delusion; fantasy; wild or baseless imagination
- へ
- e — directional particle meaning 'to' or 'toward'
- 意志
- ishi — will; volition; intention; determination
- 利己
- riko — selfishness; self-interest; egoism
- 心
- kokoro / shin — heart; mind; spirit; feelings; soul
- 貪欲
- don'yoku — greed; avarice; insatiable desire for more
- 対し
- taishi — toward; against; in contrast to (対する)
- 生
- sei / nama / sho — life; living; raw; birth
- 全般
- zenpan — overall; in general; all aspects of something
- とって
- totte — for; from the standpoint of (にとって)
- より
- yori — than; from; more (comparative particle)
- 高く
- takaku — highly; at a high level; expensively
- 根本
- konpon — root; foundation; basis; fundamental principle
- 与え
- atae — stem of 与える; to give; to grant
- られる
- rareru — passive/potential auxiliary; can be; is given
- べき
- beki — should; ought to; must (obligation marker)
- 可能
- kanō — possible; feasible; capable of being done
- 性
- sei / sho — suffix for nature, quality, or possibility
- それどころ
- soredokoro — far from it; on the contrary; even more so
- それら
- sorera — those (things); those items previously mentioned
- 善く
- yoku — well; in a good manner; virtuously
- 尊ば
- tattoba — conditional of 尊ぶ; to respect, revere
- れる
- reru — passive auxiliary verb suffix; is done to
- 構成
- kōsei — composition; structure; making up of something
- まさに
- masani — exactly; precisely; certainly; just as expected
- これら
- korera — these (things); referring to nearby items
- 悪しき
- ashiki — evil; bad; wicked (classical attributive form)
- 一見
- ikken — at first glance; apparently; on the surface
- 事物
- jibutsu — things; matters; objects and affairs collectively
- 陰険
- inken — sinister; underhanded; treacherous; sly and malicious
- 関係
- kankei — relationship; connection; involvement; relevance
- 結び
- musubi — tying; binding; ending; connection
- つき
- tsuki — attached to; per; stem of つく (to be linked)
- 絡み合っ
- karamiat(te) — intertwined; entangled with each other
- 本質
- honshitsu — essence; true nature; fundamental character
- 同一
- dōitsu — identical; the same; one and the same
- さえ
- sae — even; as long as; if only (emphasis particle)
- しかし
- shikashi — however; but; nevertheless; yet
- 誰
- dare — who; which person; someone
- そのような
- sono yōna — such; that kind of; like that
- 危険
- kiken — danger; risk; hazardous situation
- 関わり
- kakawari — involvement; connection; relationship with something
- たい
- tai — desiderative suffix meaning 'want to do'
- 思う
- omou — to think; to feel; to believe
- だろう
- darō — probably; I suppose; right? (conjecture)
- 探究
- tankyū — investigation; inquiry; pursuit of knowledge
- ため
- tame — for the sake of; in order to; because of
- これまで
- koremade — until now; up to this point; so far
- 支配
- shihai — domination; control; rule over something
- あった
- atta — past tense of ある; there was; existed
- 逆
- gyaku / saka — reverse; opposite; contrary; inverse
- 別
- betsu — different; separate; another; distinction
- 趣味
- shumi — hobby; taste; interest; aesthetic preference
- 傾向
- keikō — tendency; trend; inclination toward something
- 持つ
- motsu — to have; to hold; to possess something
- 新た
- arata — new; fresh; newly; anew
- 種類
- shurui — type; kind; sort; category of things
- 哲学
- tetsugaku — philosophy; love of wisdom; philosophical study
- 到来
- tōrai — arrival; advent; coming of something new
- 待た
- mata — stem of 待つ; to wait for something
- なけれ
- nakere — conditional negative; must; unless (ば follows)
- なら
- nara — if; in that case; speaking of (conditional)
- 意味
- imi — meaning; significance; sense of something
- おける
- okeru — in; at; concerning (literary locative expression)
- 真剣
- shinken — serious; earnest; in dead earnest
- 語る
- kataru — to speak; to tell; to narrate a story
- 私
- watashi / watakushi — I; me; first-person pronoun
- 新しい
- atarashii — new; fresh; novel; recently made or arrived
- 現れ
- araware — appearance; manifestation; emergence of something
- 始め
- hajime — beginning; start; to begin doing something
- 見える
- mieru — to appear; to seem; to be visible
- 三
- san / mi — the number three
Unlock audio playback, vocabulary games, and reading progress tracking.
Create free account →