Beyond Good and Evil — Page 2
Is there not ground for suspecting that all philosophers, in so far as they have been dogmatists, have failed to understand women--that the terrible seriousness and clumsy importunity with which they have usually paid their addresses to Truth, have been unskilled and unseemly methods for winning a woman?
모든 철학자들이, 그들이 독단론자였던 한, 여성을 이해하는 데 실패했다고 의심할 근거가 없는가--즉, 그들이 진리에 구애할 때 통상적으로 보여온 그 끔찍한 진지함과 서툰 강요가, 여성을 얻기 위한 미숙하고 어울리지 않는 방법이었다고?
Certainly she has never allowed herself to be won; and at present every kind of dogma stands with sad and discouraged mien--IF, indeed, it stands at all!
확실히 진리는 결코 스스로 정복당하도록 허락하지 않았다; 그리고 현재 모든 종류의 독단은 슬프고 낙담한 표정으로 서 있다--만약 정말로 서 있기라도 하다면!
For there are scoffers who maintain that it has fallen, that all dogma lies on the ground--nay more, that it is at its last gasp.
왜냐하면 독단이 쓰러졌다고, 모든 독단이 땅바닥에 쓰러져 있다고--아니, 더 나아가 마지막 숨을 헐떡이고 있다고 주장하는 조롱꾼들이 있기 때문이다.
But to speak seriously, there are good grounds for hoping that all dogmatizing in philosophy, whatever solemn, whatever conclusive and decided airs it has assumed, may have been only a noble puerilism and tyronism; and probably the time is at hand when it will be once and again understood WHAT has actually sufficed for the basis of such imposing and absolute philosophical edifices as the dogmatists have hitherto reared:
그러나 진지하게 말하자면, 철학에서의 모든 독단화가, 그것이 어떠한 엄숙함을, 어떠한 결정적이고 단호한 태도를 취해왔든 간에, 단지 고귀한 유치함과 초심자의 미숙함에 불과했을지도 모른다는 희망을 품을 충분한 근거가 있다; 그리고 아마도 독단론자들이 지금까지 세워온 그토록 웅장하고 절대적인 철학적 건축물들의 토대로 실제로 무엇이 충분했는지가 다시금 이해될 시간이 가까이 와 있을 것이다:
perhaps some popular superstition of immemorial time (such as the soul-superstition, which, in the form of subject- and ego-superstition, has not yet ceased doing mischief): perhaps some play upon words, a deception on the part of grammar, or an audacious generalization of very restricted, very personal, very human--all-too-human facts.
아마도 태고의 민간 미신(주체 미신과 자아 미신의 형태로 아직도 해악을 끼치기를 멈추지 않은 영혼 미신과 같은): 아마도 어떤 언어 유희, 문법 측면에서의 기만, 혹은 매우 제한적이고, 매우 개인적이며, 매우 인간적인--지나치게 인간적인 사실들의 대담한 일반화.
Vocabulary
- 모든
- mo-deun — All, every; referring to the entirety of something
- 철학자들이
- cheol-hak-ja-deul-i — Philosophers (subject marker attached)
- 그들이
- geu-deul-i — They, them (subject marker attached)
- 독단론자였던
- dok-dan-non-ja-yeot-deon — Who were dogmatists; past attributive form
- 한
- han — One; a certain; used as indefinite article
- 여성을
- yeo-seong-eul — Woman, female (object marker attached)
- 이해하는
- i-hae-ha-neun — Understanding; present attributive form of understand
- 데
- de — In doing; a nominalizer indicating act or matter
- 실패했다고
- sil-pae-haet-da-go — That they failed; quotative form of failure
- 의심할
- ui-sim-hal — To doubt; future attributive form of doubt
- 근거가
- geun-geo-ga — Grounds, basis, reason (subject marker attached)
- 없는가
- eom-neun-ga — Is there not? Questioning the absence of something
- 즉
- jeuk — That is, namely; used to clarify or restate
- 진리에
- jil-li-e — To truth; truth with directional particle attached
- 구애할
- gu-ae-hal — To court, woo; to be constrained or bound by
- 때
- ttae — When, time; indicating a point or period of time
- 통상적으로
- tong-sang-jeok-eu-ro — Usually, ordinarily, in the customary manner
- 보여온
- bo-yeo-on — Has shown; past continuative attributive of show
- 그
- geu — That; definite article-like demonstrative pronoun
- 끔찍한
- kkeum-jjik-han — Terrible, dreadful, horrifying, awful
- 진지함과
- jin-ji-ham-gwa — Seriousness, earnestness (with conjunction and)
- 서툰
- seo-tun — Clumsy, unskilled, awkward, inept
- 강요가
- gang-yo-ga — Coercion, compulsion, imposition (subject marker)
- 얻기
- eot-gi — Getting, obtaining; nominalized form of obtain
- 위한
- wi-han — For the sake of; attributive form of purpose
- 미숙하고
- mi-suk-ha-go — Immature, inexperienced, unskilled, and…
- 어울리지
- eo-ul-li-ji — Not fitting; negative stem of to suit or match
- 않는
- an-neun — Not doing; negative present attributive form
- 방법이었다고
- bang-beob-i-eot-da-go — That it was a method; quotative past form
- 확실히
- hwak-sil-hi — Certainly, surely, definitely, without doubt
- 진리는
- jil-li-neun — Truth (topic marker attached); the concept of truth
- 결코
- gyeol-ko — Never, by no means; strong negation adverb
- 스스로
- seu-seu-ro — By oneself, on one's own, of one's own accord
- 정복당하도록
- jeong-bok-dang-ha-do-rok — So as to be conquered or subjugated by another
- 허락하지
- heo-rak-ha-ji — Not permitting; negative stem of to allow
- 않았다
- an-at-da — Did not; past tense negative ending
- 그리고
- geu-ri-go — And; coordinating conjunction linking clauses
- 현재
- hyeon-jae — Present, current; referring to the current time
- 종류의
- jong-ryu-ui — Of a kind, type, or sort (possessive attached)
- 독단은
- dok-dan-eun — Dogma, dogmatism (topic marker attached)
- 슬프고
- seul-peu-go — Sad, sorrowful, and…; connective form of sad
- 낙담한
- nak-dam-han — Discouraged, dejected, disheartened, downcast
- 표정으로
- pyo-jeong-eu-ro — With an expression; facial expression with particle
- 서
- seo — Standing; short connective form of to stand
- 있다
- it-da — To exist, to be; basic existential verb
- 만약
- man-yak — If, supposing; conditional conjunction
- 정말로
- jeong-mal-lo — Really, truly, indeed; emphatic adverb
- 있기라도
- it-gi-ra-do — Even if it exists; concessive existential form
- 하다면
- ha-da-myeon — If it does; conditional form of to do/be
- 왜냐하면
- wae-nya-ha-myeon — Because, the reason being; causal conjunction
- 독단이
- dok-dan-i — Dogma, dogmatism (subject marker attached)
- 쓰러졌다고
- sseu-reo-jyeot-da-go — That it has fallen; quotative past of collapse
- 땅바닥에
- ttang-ba-dak-e — On the ground, on the floor (locative attached)
- 쓰러져
- sseu-reo-jyeo — Having fallen, collapsed; connective fallen form
- 아니
- a-ni — No, not; interjection of negation or surprise
- 더
- deo — More, further; comparative adverb
- 나아가
- na-a-ga — Going further, advancing; connective form
- 마지막
- ma-ji-mak — Last, final; the very end of something
- 숨을
- sum-eul — Breath (object marker attached); breathing
- 헐떡이고
- heol-tteok-i-go — Gasping, panting, and…; connective form of gasp
- 주장하는
- ju-jang-ha-neun — Claiming, asserting; present attributive form
- 조롱꾼들이
- jo-rong-kkun-deul-i — Mockers, scoffers, jeerers (subject marker attached)
- 있기
- it-gi — Existing, being present; nominalized form of exist
- 때문이다
- ttae-mun-i-da — It is because; causal closing expression
- 그러나
- geu-reo-na — However, but; adversative conjunction
- 진지하게
- jin-ji-ha-ge — Seriously, earnestly; adverbial form of serious
- 말하자면
- mal-ha-ja-myeon — So to speak, to put it another way
- 철학에서의
- cheol-hak-e-seo-ui — Within philosophy; philosophy with locative possessive
- 독단화가
- dok-dan-hwa-ga — Dogmatization, dogmatic process (subject marker)
- 그것이
- geu-geo-si — It, that thing (subject marker attached)
- 어떠한
- eo-tteo-han — Whatever kind of; any sort of, no matter what
- 엄숙함을
- eom-suk-ham-eul — Solemnity, gravity (object marker attached)
- 결정적이고
- gyeol-jeong-jeok-i-go — Decisive, definitive, and…; connective form
- 단호한
- dan-ho-han — Resolute, firm, decisive, unwavering
- 태도를
- tae-do-reul — Attitude, stance (object marker attached)
- 취해왔든
- chwi-hae-wat-deun — Whatever attitude has been taken; concessive past
- 간에
- gan-e — Regardless of; between; concessive particle
- 단지
- dan-ji — Merely, only, just; limiting adverb
- 고귀한
- go-gwi-han — Noble, lofty, exalted, dignified
- 유치함과
- yu-chi-ham-gwa — Childishness, immaturity (with conjunction and)
- 초심자의
- cho-sim-ja-ui — Of a beginner, novice (possessive attached)
- 미숙함에
- mi-suk-ham-e — In immaturity, inexperience (locative attached)
- 불과했을지도
- bul-gwa-haet-seul-ji-do — May have been nothing more than; speculative past
- 모른다는
- mo-reun-da-neun — That one does not know; attributive quotative form
- 희망을
- hui-mang-eul — Hope, wish, aspiration (object marker attached)
- 품을
- pum-eul — To harbor, cherish; future attributive of embrace
- 충분한
- chung-bun-han — Sufficient, enough, adequate, ample
- 아마도
- a-ma-do — Perhaps, probably, maybe; probabilistic adverb
- 독단론자들이
- dok-dan-non-ja-deul-i — Dogmatists (plural, subject marker attached)
- 지금까지
- ji-geum-kka-ji — Until now, up to the present, so far
- 세워온
- se-wo-on — Have built, erected; past continuative attributive
- 그토록
- geu-to-rok — So much, to that extent, so greatly
- 웅장하고
- ung-jang-ha-go — Grand, magnificent, majestic, and…
- 절대적인
- jeol-dae-jeok-in — Absolute, unconditional, total, definitive
- 철학적
- cheol-hak-jeok — Philosophical; of or relating to philosophy
- 건축물들의
- geon-chuk-mul-deul-ui — Of structures, buildings (plural possessive attached)
- 토대로
- to-dae-ro — As a foundation, as a basis (instrumental attached)
- 실제로
- sil-je-ro — Actually, in reality, in practice
- 무엇이
- mu-eot-i — What (subject marker attached); what thing
- 충분했는지가
- chung-bun-haet-neun-ji-ga — Whether it was sufficient (subject marker attached)
- 다시금
- da-si-geum — Once again, anew; emphatic form of again
- 이해될
- i-hae-doel — To be understood; future passive attributive form
- 시간이
- si-gan-i — Time (subject marker attached); a moment or period
- 가까이
- ga-kka-i — Near, close, nearby; proximity adverb
- 와
- wa — Coming; short connective of to come, and/with
- 있을
- it-seul — Will be, likely exists; future attributive of exist
- 것이다
- geot-i-da — It is the case that; certainty/expectation ending
- 태고의
- tae-go-ui — Of ancient times, primordial (possessive attached)
- 민간
- min-gan — Folk, popular, civilian; of ordinary people
- 미신
- mi-sin — Superstition; irrational belief in supernatural
- 주체
- ju-che — Subject, agent; the main entity acting
- 미신과
- mi-sin-gwa — Superstition (with conjunction and attached)
- 자아
- ja-a — Self, ego; one's own identity or consciousness
- 미신의
- mi-sin-ui — Of superstition (possessive marker attached)
- 형태로
- hyeong-tae-ro — In the form of; shape or form with particle
- 아직도
- a-jik-do — Still, even now, yet; continuing up to present
- 해악을
- hae-ak-eul — Harm, evil, malice (object marker attached)
- 끼치기를
- kki-chi-gi-reul — Inflicting, causing harm (nominalized object form)
- 멈추지
- meom-chu-ji — Not stopping; negative stem of to stop
- 않은
- an-eun — Not having done; past negative attributive form
- 영혼
- yeong-hon — Soul, spirit; the inner spiritual essence
- 같은
- gat-eun — Like, same as; attributive form of to be like
- 어떤
- eo-tteon — Some, certain, any; indefinite determiner
- 언어
- eon-eo — Language; system of human communication
- 유희
- yu-hui — Play, game, amusement; playful activity
- 문법
- mun-beop — Grammar; rules governing a language
- 측면에서의
- cheuk-myeon-e-seo-ui — From the aspect/side of (locative possessive)
- 기만
- gi-man — Deception, trickery, fraud, deceit
- 혹은
- hok-eun — Or, either; disjunctive conjunction
- 매우
- mae-u — Very, extremely, highly; intensifying adverb
- 제한적이고
- je-han-jeok-i-go — Limited, restricted, and…; connective form
- 개인적이며
- gae-in-jeok-i-myeo — Personal, individual, and…; connective form
- 인간적인
- in-gan-jeok-in — Human, humane; pertaining to human nature
- 지나치게
- ji-na-chi-ge — Excessively, too much; going beyond proper bounds
- 사실들의
- sa-sil-deul-ui — Of facts, truths (plural possessive attached)
- 대담한
- dae-dam-han — Bold, daring, audacious, courageous
- 일반화
- il-ban-hwa — Generalization; process of making something general
Unlock audio playback, vocabulary games, and reading progress tracking.
Create free account →