Beyond Good and Evil — Page 1
The Will to Truth, which is to tempt us to many a hazardous enterprise, the famous Truthfulness of which all philosophers have hitherto spoken with respect, what questions has this Will to Truth not laid before us!
우리를 수많은 위험한 모험으로 유혹하려는 진리에의 의지, 지금까지 모든 철학자들이 경의를 표하며 말해온 저 유명한 진실성, 이 진리에의 의지는 우리 앞에 얼마나 많은 물음들을 던져놓지 않았던가!
What strange, perplexing, questionable questions!
얼마나 기이하고, 당혹스럽고, 의심스러운 물음들인가!
It is already a long story; yet it seems as if it were hardly commenced.
그것은 이미 오랜 이야기이지만, 마치 이제 막 시작된 것처럼 보인다.
Is it any wonder if we at last grow distrustful, lose patience, and turn impatiently away?
우리가 마침내 불신하게 되고, 인내를 잃고, 참지 못하고 외면하게 된다면 그것이 과연 이상한 일인가?
That this Sphinx teaches us at last to ask questions ourselves?
이 스핑크스가 마침내 우리 스스로 질문을 던지도록 가르친다는 것이?
WHO is it really that puts questions to us here?
여기서 우리에게 질문을 던지는 자는 과연 누구인가?
WHAT really is this "Will to Truth" in us?
우리 안에 있는 이 "진리에의 의지"란 과연 무엇인가?
In fact we made a long halt at the question as to the origin of this Will--until at last we came to an absolute standstill before a yet more fundamental question.
사실 우리는 이 의지의 기원에 관한 물음 앞에서 오랫동안 멈춰 서 있었다--마침내 더욱 근본적인 물음 앞에서 완전히 정지하게 될 때까지.
We inquired about the VALUE of this Will.
우리는 이 의지의 가치에 대해 물었다.
Granted that we want the truth: WHY NOT RATHER untruth?
우리가 진리를 원한다고 가정하자: 왜 차라리 비진리는 안 되는가?
And uncertainty?
그리고 불확실성은?
Even ignorance?
심지어 무지는?
The problem of the value of truth presented itself before us--or was it we who presented ourselves before the problem?
진리의 가치라는 문제가 우리 앞에 나타난 것인가--아니면 우리가 그 문제 앞에 나타난 것인가?
Which of us is the Oedipus here?
우리 중 누가 여기서 오이디푸스인가?
Which the Sphinx?
누가 스핑크스인가?
It would seem to be a rendezvous of questions and notes of interrogation.
그것은 물음들과 의문부호들의 만남의 장인 것처럼 보인다.
And could it be believed that it at last seems to us as if the problem had never been propounded before, as if we were the first to discern it, get a sight of it, and RISK RAISING it?
그리고 마침내 우리에게 마치 이 문제가 이전에 한 번도 제기된 적이 없었던 것처럼, 마치 우리가 그것을 처음으로 식별하고, 발견하고, 감히 제기하는 첫 번째 사람들인 것처럼 느껴진다는 것을 믿을 수 있겠는가?
Vocabulary
- 우리를
- urireul — Object form of 'we/us' in a sentence
- 수많은
- sumaneun — Countless, very many, numerous
- 위험한
- wiheomhan — Dangerous, hazardous, risky
- 모험으로
- moheomeuro — Into or toward adventure or venture
- 유혹하려는
- yuhokaryeoneun — Intending to tempt, seduce, or lure
- 진리에의
- jillieui — Pertaining to or toward truth
- 의지
- uiji — Will, determination, resolve
- 지금까지
- jigeumkkaji — Until now, up to this point
- 모든
- modeun — All, every, entire
- 철학자들이
- cheolhakjadeuri — Subject form of 'philosophers'
- 경의를
- gyeongeuireul — Object form of 'respect, reverence, homage'
- 표하며
- pyohамyeo — While expressing or paying tribute
- 말해온
- malhaeон — Have been saying, spoken over time
- 저
- jeo — That (over there); humble 'I'
- 유명한
- yumyeonghan — Famous, well-known, renowned
- 진실성
- jinsilseong — Truthfulness, sincerity, veracity
- 이
- i — This; subject particle; the number two
- 의지는
- uijineun — Topic form of 'will, determination'
- 우리
- uri — We, us, our
- 앞에
- ape — In front of, before
- 얼마나
- eolmana — How much, how many, to what extent
- 많은
- maneun — Many, much, numerous
- 물음들을
- mureumdeureul — Object form of 'questions, inquiries'
- 던져놓지
- deonjyeonochi — Has not thrown down or posed (questions)
- 않았던가
- anhassdeonga — Rhetorical: hasn't it? wasn't it so?
- 기이하고
- giihago — Strange, odd, peculiar and...
- 당혹스럽고
- danghokseureопgo — Perplexing, bewildering, embarrassing and...
- 의심스러운
- uisimseureoпun — Doubtful, suspicious, questionable
- 물음들인가
- mureumdeulinga — Are they questions? (rhetorical inquiry)
- 그것은
- geugeoseun — That thing (topic); it is
- 이미
- imi — Already, by now
- 오랜
- oraen — Long (time), longstanding, old
- 이야기이지만
- iyagiijiman — It is a story, but...; although a tale
- 마치
- machi — Just as if, as though, like
- 이제
- ije — Now, from now on
- 막
- mak — Just now, right away, barely
- 시작된
- sijakdoen — Having begun, started
- 것처럼
- geotcheoreom — As if, like, seeming as though
- 보인다
- boinda — Appears, seems, looks like
- 우리가
- uriga — Subject form of 'we, us'
- 마침내
- machimnae — Finally, at last, in the end
- 불신하게
- bulsinhaге — To come to distrust or disbelieve
- 되고
- doego — Becoming and...; turning into
- 인내를
- innaereul — Object form of 'patience, endurance'
- 잃고
- ilko — Losing and...; having lost
- 참지
- chamji — Not enduring, unable to bear (with negative)
- 못하고
- mothago — Cannot do and...; being unable
- 외면하게
- oемуnhage — To turn away, avert one's eyes from
- 된다면
- doendamyeon — If it comes to be, if it happens that
- 그것이
- geugeosi — Subject form of 'that thing, it'
- 과연
- gwayeon — Indeed, really, as expected
- 이상한
- isanghan — Strange, unusual, odd
- 일인가
- iringa — Is it a matter/thing? (rhetorical)
- 스스로
- seusеuro — By oneself, on one's own, voluntarily
- 질문을
- jilmuneul — Object form of 'question, inquiry'
- 던지도록
- deonjidorok — So as to throw, in order to pose
- 가르친다는
- gareucindaneun — Said to teach, claims to instruct
- 것이
- geosi — Subject form of 'thing, fact that'
- 여기서
- yeogiseo — Here, from this place
- 우리에게
- uriegе — To us, for us
- 던지는
- deonjineun — Who throws, posing (a question)
- 자는
- janeun — Topic form of 'person who does'
- 누구인가
- nuguinga — Who is it? who is this person?
- 안에
- ane — Inside, within
- 있는
- inneun — Existing, being, present
- 란
- ran — Topic particle emphasizing definition: 'as for'
- 무엇인가
- mueosinga — What is it? what is this?
- 사실
- sasil — Fact; actually, in truth
- 우리는
- urineun — Topic form of 'we, us'
- 의지의
- uijiui — Possessive form of 'will, volition'
- 기원에
- giwone — At/to the origin, source, beginning
- 관한
- gwanhan — Concerning, regarding, about
- 물음
- mureum — Question, inquiry, asking
- 앞에서
- apeseo — In front of, before, facing
- 오랫동안
- oraetdongan — For a long time, over a long period
- 멈춰
- meomchwo — Stopping, halting, pausing
- 서
- seo — Standing; from (place particle)
- 있었다
- isseotda — Was existing, had been, remained
- 더욱
- deouk — Even more, further, increasingly
- 근본적인
- geunbonjeogIn — Fundamental, basic, essential
- 완전히
- wanjeonhi — Completely, entirely, perfectly
- 정지하게
- jeongjihage — To come to a stop, halt completely
- 될
- doel — Will become, about to be
- 때까지
- ttaekkaji — Until the time, up to the point
- 가치에
- gachie — To/at value, worth, significance
- 대해
- daehae — About, concerning, regarding
- 물었다
- mureotda — Asked, inquired, questioned
- 진리를
- jillireul — Object form of 'truth, the truth'
- 원한다고
- wonhandago — Saying that one wants or desires
- 가정하자
- gajeonghaja — Let us assume, suppose, hypothesize
- 왜
- wae — Why, for what reason
- 차라리
- charari — Rather, preferably, instead
- 비진리는
- bijillineun — Topic form of 'untruth, non-truth'
- 안
- an — Not, inside, within
- 되는가
- doeneunга — Why not? can it not become?
- 그리고
- geurigo — And, and then, furthermore
- 불확실성은
- bulhwaksilseongеun — Topic form of 'uncertainty, ambiguity'
- 심지어
- simjieo — Even, going so far as
- 무지는
- mujineun — Topic form of 'ignorance, lack of knowledge'
- 진리의
- jilliui — Possessive of 'truth'; of truth
- 가치라는
- gachiraneun — Called value, said to be worth
- 문제가
- munjeга — Subject form of 'problem, issue, question'
- 나타난
- natanan — Appeared, emerged, came to light
- 것인가
- geosiпga — Is it the case that? (rhetorical question)
- 아니면
- animyeon — Or else, otherwise, if not
- 그
- geu — That, the (third person reference)
- 문제
- munje — Problem, issue, question, matter
- 중
- jung — Among, in the middle of, during
- 누가
- nuga — Who (subject), who is it
- 물음들과
- mureumdeulgwa — Questions and...; along with inquiries
- 의문부호들의
- uimunbuhoдeului — Possessive of 'question marks, interrogations'
- 만남의
- mannamui — Possessive of 'meeting, encounter'
- 장인
- jangin — Place of; craftsman (context-dependent)
- 이전에
- ijeone — Before, previously, prior to
- 한
- han — One, a, single; Korean (people)
- 번도
- beondo — Not even once (with negative)
- 제기된
- jegidoen — Having been raised, proposed, posed
- 적이
- jeogi — Subject of 'experience of having done'
- 없었던
- eopseotdeon — Had not existed, there was none
- 그것을
- geugeoseul — Object form of 'that thing, it'
- 처음으로
- cheoeumeuro — For the first time, initially
- 식별하고
- sikbyeolhago — Identifying, distinguishing, and...
- 발견하고
- balgyeonhago — Discovering, finding out, and...
- 감히
- gamhi — Boldly, daringly, with audacity
- 제기하는
- jegihaпeun — Who raises, poses, brings up (question)
- 첫
- cheot — First, initial
- 번째
- beonjjae — Ordinal counter: -th time/place
- 사람들인
- saramdeurin — Who are people, being persons
- 느껴진다는
- neukkkyeojindaneun — Said to feel, perceived as feeling
- 것을
- geoseul — Object form of 'thing, fact'
- 믿을
- mideul — To believe, trust (future/modifier form)
- 수
- su — Ability, possibility; number
- 있겠는가
- itgenneunга — Can one really? is it possible? (rhetorical)
Unlock audio playback, vocabulary games, and reading progress tracking.
Create free account →