On Liberty — Page 12
Taylor's assistance in the _Political Economy_ is confined to certain definite points.
테일러가 《정치경제학》에서 기여한 부분은 특정한 몇 가지 사항에 한정되어 있다.
The purely scientific part was, we are assured, not learnt from her.
순수하게 학문적인 부분은, 우리가 확신하건대, 그녀에게서 배운 것이 아니었다.
"But it was chiefly her influence which gave to the book that general tone by which it is distinguished from all previous expositions of political economy that had any pretensions to be scientific, and which has made it so useful in conciliating minds which those previous expositions had repelled.
"그러나 그 책에 전반적인 논조를 부여한 것은 주로 그녀의 영향이었으니, 그 논조로 인해 이 책은 학문적 면모를 갖추고자 했던 기존의 모든 정치경제학 해설서들과 구별되며, 기존의 해설서들이 반감을 불러일으켰던 독자들의 마음을 화해시키는 데 이 책이 유용하게 쓰일 수 있었다.
This tone consisted chiefly in making the proper distinction between the laws of the production of wealth, which are real laws of Nature, dependent on the properties of objects, and the modes of its distribution, which, subject to certain conditions, depend on human will....
이 논조는 주로 부의 생산 법칙과 분배 방식 사이의 적절한 구분을 짓는 데 있었는데, 전자는 사물의 속성에 의존하는 자연의 실제 법칙이며, 후자는 일정한 조건 하에서 인간의 의지에 달려 있는 것이다….
_I had indeed partially learnt this view of things from the thoughts awakened in me by the speculations of St. Simonians_; but it was made a living principle, pervading and animating the book, by my wife's promptings."[4]
나는 실제로 생시몽주의자들의 사색이 내 안에서 불러일으킨 생각들로부터 이러한 사물관을 부분적으로 배운 바 있었다. 그러나 그것이 책 전체에 스며들어 생동감을 불어넣는 살아 있는 원리가 된 것은 아내의 독려 덕분이었다."[4]
The part which is italicised is noticeable.
이탤릭체로 표시된 부분은 주목할 만하다.
Here, as elsewhere, Mill thinks out the matter by himself; the concrete form of the thoughts is suggested or prompted by the wife.
여기서도, 다른 곳에서와 마찬가지로, 밀은 스스로 문제를 사고하며, 생각의 구체적인 형태는 아내에 의해 제안되거나 촉발된다.
Apart from this "general tone," Mill tells us that there was a specific contribution.
이 "전반적인 논조" 외에도, 밀은 구체적인 기여가 있었다고 우리에게 말한다.
"The chapter which has had a greater influence on opinion than all the rest, that on the Probable Future of the Labouring Classes, is entirely due to her.
"다른 모든 장보다 여론에 더 큰 영향을 미친 장, 즉 노동자 계급의 가능한 미래에 관한 장은 전적으로 그녀 덕분이다.
In the first draft of the book that chapter did not exist.
책의 초고에는 그 장이 존재하지 않았다.
Vocabulary
- 기여한
- giyeohan — Contributed; having made a contribution to something
- 부분은
- bubуneun — The part; referring to a specific portion or section
- 특정한
- teukjunghan — Specific; particular; referring to a definite thing
- 몇
- myeot — A few; several; a small number of things
- 가지
- gaji — Kind; type; sort of thing or item
- 사항에
- sahange — To matters; regarding specific items or points
- 한정되어
- hanjungdoeeo — Being limited; restricted to a certain scope
- 있다
- itda — To exist; to be; indicates existence or state
- 순수하게
- sunsuhage — Purely; in a pure or unmixed manner
- 학문적인
- hangmunjeogин — Academic; scholarly; relating to academic study
- 우리가
- uriga — We (subject marker); we as the subject
- 확신하건대
- hwaksinhageondae — We are certain that; expressing strong conviction
- 그녀에게서
- geunyeoegeseo — From her; originating from her person
- 배운
- baeun — Learned; having studied or acquired knowledge
- 것이
- geosi — Thing that; nominalizer indicating what was done
- 아니었다
- anieotda — Was not; negation of past state or identity
- 그러나
- geureona — However; but; conjunction indicating contrast
- 그
- geu — That; the; definite demonstrative article
- 책에
- chaege — In the book; to the book
- 전반적인
- jeonbanjeogin — Overall; general; pertaining to the whole
- 논조를
- nonjoreul — Tone; the overall tone or argument of writing
- 부여한
- buyeohan — Granted; bestowed; given a certain quality
- 것은
- geoseun — The thing that; nominalizer as topic marker
- 주로
- juro — Mainly; primarily; for the most part
- 그녀의
- geunyeoui — Her; possessive form referring to her
- 영향이었으니
- yeonghyangieotsseuni — Because it was her influence; causal past clause
- 인해
- inhae — Due to; because of; owing to a cause
- 이
- i — This; demonstrative pronoun for nearby referent
- 책은
- chaegeun — The book (topic); the book as subject of discussion
- 학문적
- hangmunjeok — Academic; scholarly in character or nature
- 면모를
- myeonmoreul — Aspect; appearance; facet of character or nature
- 갖추고자
- gatchuгoja — Wishing to equip; intending to possess a quality
- 했던
- haetdeon — Had done; past modifier indicating prior action
- 기존의
- gijonui — Existing; pre-existing; already established before
- 모든
- modeun — All; every; referring to the entirety of something
- 정치경제학
- jeongchi gyeongjehak — Political economy; study of economics and politics
- 해설서들과
- haeseolseodeulgwa — With commentaries; alongside explanatory texts
- 구별되며
- gubyeoldoemyeo — Being distinguished; differentiated from others
- 반감을
- bangameul — Antipathy; feeling of aversion or resistance
- 불러일으켰던
- bulleorikeotdeon — Had provoked; had stirred up a feeling
- 독자들의
- dokjadeului — Of the readers; possessive referring to readers
- 마음을
- maeumeul — Heart; mind; inner feelings or disposition
- 화해시키는
- hwahaeсikiнеun — Reconciling; bringing to a state of harmony
- 데
- de — In doing; a nominalizer for purpose or situation
- 책이
- chaegi — The book (subject); book as grammatical subject
- 유용하게
- yuyonghage — Usefully; in a useful or beneficial manner
- 쓰일
- sseuil — To be used; able to be utilized or employed
- 수
- su — Ability; possibility; can; expressing potential
- 있었다
- isseotda — There was; existed; past tense of existence
- 부의
- buui — Of wealth; possessive relating to wealth
- 생산
- saengsan — Production; the act of producing goods or wealth
- 법칙과
- beopchikgwa — Laws and; natural laws together with something
- 분배
- bunbae — Distribution; the allocation of resources or wealth
- 방식
- bangsik — Method; manner; way of doing something
- 사이의
- saiui — Between; in the space separating two things
- 적절한
- jeokjeolhan — Appropriate; proper; fitting for the context
- 구분을
- gubуneul — Distinction; division; act of distinguishing things
- 짓는
- jitneun — Making; drawing; forming a distinction or shape
- 있었는데
- isseotneunde — There was; existed; conjunction linking clauses
- 전자는
- jeonjaneun — The former; the first of two mentioned items
- 사물의
- samurui — Of things; possessive relating to physical things
- 속성에
- sokseонge — In the nature; in the inherent properties of things
- 의존하는
- uijonhaneun — Depending on; relying upon something else
- 자연의
- jayeonui — Of nature; possessive relating to the natural world
- 실제
- silje — Actual; real; in actuality or practice
- 법칙이며
- beopchigiмyeo — Is a law; being a natural law and furthermore
- 후자는
- hujaneun — The latter; the second of two mentioned items
- 일정한
- iljeonghan — Certain; fixed; a definite or established condition
- 조건
- jogeon — Condition; prerequisite; a required circumstance
- 하에서
- haeseo — Under; beneath certain conditions or circumstances
- 인간의
- inganui — Human; of humans; relating to human beings
- 의지에
- uijie — On the will; dependent on human volition
- 달려
- dallyeo — Hanging on; depending on; hinging upon something
- 있는
- inneun — That is; existing; present-tense modifier
- 것이다
- geosida — It is; a thing that is; declarative ending
- 나는
- naneun — I; me (topic); first-person singular topic
- 실제로
- siljero — Actually; in reality; in actual fact
- 사색이
- sasaegi — Contemplation; reflective thought as subject
- 내
- nae — My; belonging to me; first-person possessive
- 안에서
- aneseo — Inside; within; from within a place or mind
- 불러일으킨
- bulleorieukin — Stirred up; provoked; evoked thoughts or feelings
- 생각들로부터
- saenggakdeullobuta — From the thoughts; originating from ideas within
- 이러한
- ireohan — Such; this kind of; of this particular nature
- 사물관을
- samulgwaneul — View of things; outlook on the nature of things
- 부분적으로
- Partially; in part; to a certain degree only
- 바
- ba — What; the fact that; nominalizer for a result
- 그것이
- geugeosi — That; it (subject); that thing as subject
- 책
- chaek — Book; a written or printed publication
- 전체에
- jeonchee — Throughout the whole; in the entirety of something
- 스며들어
- seumyeodeureo — Permeating; seeping into; infiltrating gradually
- 생동감을
- saengdonggameul — Vitality; liveliness; a sense of living energy
- 불어넣는
- bureoneoneun — Breathing in; infusing life or spirit into something
- 살아
- sara — Living; alive; being in a living state
- 원리가
- wonriga — Principle (subject); a fundamental rule or law
- 된
- doen — Became; turned into; past modifier of becoming
- 아내의
- anaeui — Wife's; possessive referring to one's wife
- 독려
- dungnyeo — Encouragement; urging someone to action or effort
- 덕분이었다
- deokbuniеotda — Was thanks to; was owing to someone's help
- 표시된
- pyosidoen — Marked; indicated; shown with a special notation
- 주목할
- jumokhal — Worth noting; deserving attention or observation
- 만하다
- manhada — Worth doing; deserving of a certain action
- 여기서도
- yeogiseodo — Here too; also in this place or context
- 다른
- dareun — Other; different; another distinct thing or place
- 곳에서와
- goseseoва — As in other places; just like elsewhere
- 마찬가지로
- machangajiro — Likewise; similarly; in the same way as before
- 스스로
- seuseurо — By oneself; independently; on one's own initiative
- 문제를
- munjereul — The problem; an issue or question as object
- 사고하며
- While thinking through; pondering a problem
- 생각의
- saenggagui — Of thought; possessive relating to ideas or thinking
- 구체적인
- guchejeogнын — Concrete; specific; tangible and well-defined
- 형태는
- hyeongtaeneun — The form (topic); the shape or form as topic
- 아내에
- anaee — By the wife; to the wife; relating to his wife
- 의해
- uihae — By; through; via the agency of someone
- 제안되거나
- jeandoeguna — Being suggested or; proposed or alternatively
- 촉발된다
- chokbaldoenda — Is triggered; is sparked by an external stimulus
- 논조
- nonjo — Tone; argumentative tone of a written work
- 외에도
- oeedo — In addition to; besides; beyond something else
- 기여가
- giyeoga — Contribution (subject); act of contributing as subject
- 있었다고
- isseotdago — That there was; reported existence of something
- 우리에게
- uriegе — To us; directed toward us; for our benefit
- 말한다
- malhanda — Says; tells; states something to someone
- 장보다
- jangboda — Than the chapter; comparative more than a chapter
- 여론에
- yeorone — On public opinion; regarding public sentiment
- 더
- deo — More; greater degree; comparative particle
- 큰
- keun — Big; large; great in size or importance
- 영향을
- yeonghyangeul — Influence; effect; impact on something or someone
- 미친
- michin — Exerted; had an effect on; reached an impact
- 장
- jang — Chapter; a main division of a book
- 즉
- jeuk — That is; namely; in other words clarifying
- 노동자
- nodongja — Worker; laborer; a person who performs labor
- 계급의
- gyegeubui — Of the class; possessive relating to social class
- 가능한
- ganeunghan — Possible; potential; capable of happening
- 미래에
- miraeе — In the future; at a future point in time
- 관한
- gwanhan — Regarding; concerning; about a certain topic
- 장은
- jangeun — The chapter (topic); a chapter as topic of discussion
- 전적으로
- jeonjeogеuro — Entirely; wholly; completely due to someone
- 그녀
- geunyeo — She; her; third-person singular female pronoun
- 덕분이다
- deokbunida — Is thanks to; is owing to a person's contribution
- 책의
- chaegui — Of the book; possessive relating to the book
- 초고에는
- chogоeneun — In the draft; in the initial manuscript version
- 장이
- jangi — The chapter (subject); chapter as grammatical subject
- 존재하지
- jonjehaji — Does not exist; lacking existence in something
- 않았다
- anatda — Did not; negation of a past action or state
Unlock audio playback, vocabulary games, and reading progress tracking.
Create free account →