The Odyssey: Rendered into English prose for the use of those who cannot read the original — Page 2
The points in question are:
문제가 되는 요점들은 다음과 같다:
(1) that the "Odyssey" was written entirely at, and drawn entirely from, the place now called Trapani on the West Coast of Sicily, alike as regards the Phaeacian and the Ithaca scenes; while the voyages of Ulysses, when once he is within easy reach of Sicily, solve themselves into a periplus of the island, practically from Trapani back to Trapani, via the Lipari islands, the Straits of Messina, and the island of Pantellaria.
(1) 『오디세이』는 파이아키아 장면과 이타카 장면 모두에 관하여, 시칠리아 서해안에 현재 트라파니라고 불리는 장소에서 전적으로 집필되었으며, 그 장소로부터 전적으로 소재를 끌어왔다는 것; 한편 율리시스의 항해는, 그가 일단 시칠리아에 쉽게 닿을 수 있는 거리 안에 들어오면, 리파리 제도, 메시나 해협, 그리고 판텔라리아 섬을 거쳐 트라파니에서 트라파니로 돌아오는 섬의 주항기(periplus)로 자연스럽게 귀결된다는 것이다.
(2) That the poem was entirely written by a very young woman, who lived at the place now called Trapani, and introduced herself into her work under the name of Nausicaa.
(2) 그 시는 현재 트라파니라고 불리는 곳에 살았던 아주 젊은 여성에 의해 전적으로 쓰였으며, 그녀는 나우시카아라는 이름으로 자신을 작품 속에 등장시켰다는 것이다.
The main arguments on which I base the first of these somewhat startling contentions, have been prominently and repeatedly before the English and Italian public ever since they appeared (without rejoinder) in the "Athenaeum" for January 30 and February 20, 1892.
다소 놀라운 이 주장들 중 첫 번째 주장의 근거가 되는 주요 논거들은, 1892년 1월 30일과 2월 20일자 『아테나이움』에 (반론 없이) 게재된 이후로 영국과 이탈리아 대중 앞에 줄곧 두드러지게 그리고 반복적으로 제시되어 왔다.
Both contentions were urged (also without rejoinder) in the Johnian "Eagle" for the Lent and October terms of the same year.
두 주장 모두 같은 해 사순절 학기와 10월 학기의 존이언 『이글』에 (역시 반론 없이) 강력히 제기되었다.
Nothing to which I should reply has reached me from any quarter, and knowing how anxiously I have endeavoured to learn the existence of any flaws in my argument, I begin to feel some confidence that, did such flaws exist, I should have heard, at any rate about some of them, before now.
어떠한 방면으로부터도 내가 답해야 할 만한 것이 내게 전달된 바 없으며, 내 논거의 어떠한 결함이라도 파악하고자 내가 얼마나 간절히 노력해 왔는지를 잘 알기에, 나는 만약 그러한 결함이 존재했다면 지금쯤은 적어도 그 일부에 대해서라도 들었을 것이라는 어느 정도의 확신을 갖기 시작한다.
Vocabulary
- 문제가
- munje-ga — the problem (subject marker attached)
- 되는
- doe-neun — becoming; that becomes or applies
- 요점들은
- yojeom-deul-eun — the key points (topic marker attached)
- 다음과
- da-eum-gwa — with the following; as follows
- 같다
- gat-da — to be the same; to be as follows
- 장면과
- jang-myeon-gwa — scene and; passage and (conjunctive)
- 장면
- jang-myeon — scene; passage; setting in a narrative
- 모두에
- mo-du-e — in both; regarding all of them
- 관하여
- gwan-ha-yeo — concerning; regarding; with respect to
- 서해안에
- seo-hae-an-e — on the west coast (locative marker attached)
- 현재
- hyeon-jae — currently; at the present time
- 불리는
- bul-li-neun — called; known as; named
- 장소에서
- jang-so-e-seo — at the place; from the location
- 전적으로
- jeon-jeok-eu-ro — entirely; wholly; completely
- 집필되었으며
- jip-pil-doe-eoss-eu-myeo — was written and; was composed and
- 소재를
- so-jae-reul — the material; the subject matter (object marker)
- 끌어왔다는
- kkeu-reo-wat-da-neun — drew from; derived material from (quotative)
- 것
- geot — thing; fact; nominalized concept
- 한편
- han-pyeon — on the other hand; meanwhile
- 항해는
- hang-hae-neun — the voyage; the sea journey (topic marker)
- 그가
- geu-ga — he; that person (subject marker attached)
- 일단
- il-dan — once; for now; first of all
- 쉽게
- swip-ge — easily; without difficulty
- 닿을
- da-eul — to reach; to arrive at (future modifier)
- 수
- su — ability; possibility (used in ~ㄹ 수 있다)
- 있는
- it-neun — existing; being; present (modifier form)
- 거리
- geo-ri — distance; range; street
- 안에
- an-e — inside; within
- 들어오면
- deu-reo-o-myeon — if one enters; once inside (conditional)
- 제도
- je-do — archipelago; island group
- 해협
- hae-hyeop — strait; narrow sea passage
- 그리고
- geu-ri-go — and; and then; furthermore
- 섬을
- seom-eul — the island (object marker attached)
- 거쳐
- geo-chyeo — passing through; via; by way of
- 돌아오는
- do-ra-o-neun — returning; coming back (modifier form)
- 섬의
- seom-eui — of the island; the island's
- 자연스럽게
- ja-yeon-seu-reop-ge — naturally; in a natural manner
- 것이다
- geo-si-da — it is the case that; the fact is
- 시는
- si-neun — the poem; the verse (topic marker attached)
- 곳에
- got-e — at the place; in the location
- 살았던
- sa-rat-deon — who lived; who used to live (past modifier)
- 아주
- a-ju — very; quite; extremely
- 젊은
- jeol-meun — young; youthful
- 여성에
- yeo-seong-e — by/to a woman (locative/dative marker)
- 의해
- eui-hae — by means of; by (passive agent marker)
- 쓰였으며
- sseu-yeoss-eu-myeo — was written and; was authored and
- 그녀는
- geu-nyeo-neun — she; that woman (topic marker attached)
- 이름으로
- i-reum-eu-ro — under the name of; by the name
- 자신을
- ja-sin-eul — oneself; herself (object marker attached)
- 작품
- jak-pum — work; literary or artistic creation
- 속에
- so-ge — inside; within; in the middle of
- 등장시켰다는
- deung-jang-si-kyeot-da-neun — made appear; inserted as a character (quotative)
- 다소
- da-so — somewhat; rather; to some extent
- 놀라운
- nol-la-un — surprising; astonishing; remarkable
- 이
- i — this; these (demonstrative determiner)
- 주장들
- ju-jang-deul — claims; arguments; assertions (plural)
- 중
- jung — among; in the middle of
- 첫
- cheot — first; the very first
- 번째
- beon-jjae — ordinal suffix meaning '-th' (e.g., first)
- 주장의
- ju-jang-eui — of the claim; the argument's
- 근거가
- geun-geo-ga — the basis; the grounds (subject marker)
- 주요
- ju-yo — main; major; principal
- 논거들은
- non-geo-deul-eun — the arguments; the grounds (topic marker, plural)
- 1월
- i-rwol — January; the first month
- 30일과
- sam-sip-il-gwa — the 30th and (conjunctive marker)
- 2월
- i-wol — February; the second month
- 20일자
- i-sip-il-ja — dated the 20th; of the 20th date
- 반론
- bal-lon — objection; counterargument; rebuttal
- 없이
- eop-si — without; lacking; in the absence of
- 게재된
- ge-jae-doen — published; printed; carried in a publication
- 이후로
- i-hu-ro — since then; from that point onward
- 영국과
- yeong-guk-gwa — Britain and; the UK and
- 이탈리아
- i-tal-li-a — Italy, country in southern Europe
- 대중
- dae-jung — the public; the general population
- 앞에
- ap-e — in front of; before; to the audience of
- 줄곧
- jul-got — consistently; all along; throughout
- 두드러지게
- du-deu-reo-ji-ge — prominently; noticeably; conspicuously
- 반복적으로
- ban-bok-jeok-eu-ro — repeatedly; in a repetitive manner
- 제시되어
- je-si-doe-eo — presented; put forward; proposed
- 왔다
- wat-da — has come; has been (continuative perfect)
- 두
- du — two; both (numeral determiner)
- 주장
- ju-jang — claim; argument; assertion
- 모두
- mo-du — all; both; everyone
- 같은
- ga-teun — the same; identical; similar
- 해
- hae — year; the sun; that year
- 학기와
- hak-gi-wa — semester and; term and (conjunctive)
- 10월
- si-wol — October; the tenth month
- 학기의
- hak-gi-eui — of the semester; the term's
- 역시
- yeok-si — also; too; likewise; as well
- 강력히
- gang-nyeok-i — strongly; forcefully; vigorously
- 제기되었다
- je-gi-doe-eot-da — was raised; was put forward; was proposed
- 어떠한
- eo-tteo-han — any; whatsoever; of any kind
- 방면으로부터도
- bang-myeon-eu-ro-bu-teo-do — from any quarter; from any direction either
- 내가
- nae-ga — I; me (subject marker attached)
- 답해야
- dap-hae-ya — must answer; should respond (obligation form)
- 할
- hal — will do; to do (future modifier)
- 만한
- man-han — worth; deserving of; sufficient to
- 것이
- geo-si — thing that; the fact that (subject marker)
- 내게
- nae-ge — to me; for me (dative marker)
- 전달된
- jeon-dal-doen — conveyed; delivered; communicated (past modifier)
- 바
- ba — the fact that; what; that which
- 없으며
- eop-seu-myeo — there is none and; lacking and (conjunctive)
- 내
- nae — my; mine (first-person possessive)
- 논거의
- non-geo-eui — of the argument; the reasoning's
- 결함이라도
- gyeol-ham-i-ra-do — even a flaw; any defect whatsoever
- 파악하고자
- pa-ak-ha-go-ja — in order to grasp; wishing to identify
- 얼마나
- eol-ma-na — how much; how greatly; to what extent
- 간절히
- gan-jeol-hi — earnestly; desperately; with deep longing
- 노력해
- no-ryeok-hae — making effort; trying hard (verb stem)
- 왔는지를
- wan-neun-ji-reul — how I have been doing (object marker, indirect)
- 잘
- jal — well; skillfully; properly
- 알기에
- al-gi-e — because I know; knowing well (causal)
- 나는
- na-neun — I; as for me (topic marker attached)
- 만약
- man-yak — if; supposing that; in case
- 그러한
- geu-reo-han — such; that kind of; like that
- 결함이
- gyeol-ham-i — the flaw; the defect (subject marker)
- 존재했다면
- jon-jae-haet-da-myeon — if it had existed; had there been (conditional)
- 지금쯤은
- ji-geum-jjeum-eun — by now; around this time (topic marker)
- 적어도
- jeok-eo-do — at least; at a minimum
- 일부에
- il-bu-e — about some; regarding a portion
- 대해서라도
- dae-hae-seo-ra-do — even concerning; at least regarding
- 들었을
- deu-reot-eul — would have heard; would have learned (past supposition)
- 것이라는
- geo-si-ra-neun — that it would be; the fact that (quotative)
- 어느
- eo-neu — some; a certain; which
- 정도의
- jeong-do-eui — of a degree; to some extent (possessive)
- 확신을
- hwak-sin-eul — conviction; certainty (object marker attached)
- 갖기
- gat-gi — having; possessing (nominalised verb form)
- 시작한다
- si-jak-han-da — begins; starts (present tense declarative)
Unlock audio playback, vocabulary games, and reading progress tracking.
Create free account →