The Odyssey: Rendered into English prose for the use of those who cannot read the original — Page 8
Any one who at the present day discusses the questions that have arisen round the "Iliad" since Wolf's time, without keeping it well before his reader's mind that the "Odyssey" was demonstrably written from one single neighbourhood, and hence (even though nothing else pointed to this conclusion) presumably by one person only—that it was written certainly before 750, and in all probability before 1000 B.C.—that the writer of this very early poem was demonstrably familiar with the "Iliad" as we now have it, borrowing as freely from those books whose genuineness has been most impugned, as from those which are admitted to be by Homer—any one who fails to keep these points before his readers, is hardly dealing equitably by them.
볼프의 시대 이후로 『일리아드』를 둘러싸고 제기된 문제들을 오늘날 논하는 사람이라면 누구든, 『오디세이』가 단 하나의 지역에서 쓰였음이 명백히 입증되었으며, 따라서 (다른 어떤 것도 이 결론을 가리키지 않는다 하더라도) 아마도 한 사람에 의해서만 쓰였을 것이라는 점—그것이 분명히 기원전 750년 이전에, 그리고 십중팔구 기원전 1000년 이전에 쓰였다는 점—이 매우 이른 시기의 시의 작가가 현재 우리가 가지고 있는 『일리아드』에 명백히 친숙했으며, 그 진정성이 가장 많이 의심받아 온 책들에서도 호메로스의 작품으로 인정받는 책들에서만큼이나 자유롭게 차용했다는 점을 독자들의 마음속에 충분히 각인시키지 않는다면, 그는 독자들을 공정하게 대하고 있다고 보기 어렵다.
Any one on the other hand, who will mark his "Iliad" and his "Odyssey" from the copies in the British Museum above referred to, and who will draw the only inference that common sense can draw from the presence of so many identical passages in both poems, will, I believe, find no difficulty in assigning their proper value to a large number of books here and on the Continent that at present enjoy considerable reputations.
반면에, 앞서 언급한 대영박물관 소장본을 바탕으로 자신의 『일리아드』와 『오디세이』에 표시를 하고, 두 시에서 이토록 많은 동일한 구절들이 존재한다는 사실로부터 상식이 도출할 수 있는 유일한 결론을 이끌어내는 사람은, 현재 상당한 명성을 누리고 있는 이곳과 유럽 대륙의 수많은 책들에 대해 그 적절한 가치를 평가하는 데 아무런 어려움도 없을 것이라고 나는 믿는다.
Furthermore, and this perhaps is an advantage better worth securing, he will find that many puzzles of the "Odyssey" cease to puzzle him on the discovery that they arise from over-saturation with the "Iliad.
더 나아가, 이것이 아마도 더욱 확보할 만한 가치 있는 이점이겠지만, 그는 『오디세이』의 많은 수수께끼들이 『일리아드』에 지나치게 포화된 데서 비롯된다는 것을 발견함으로써 더 이상 그를 어리둥절하게 하지 않게 됨을 알게 될 것이다.
Vocabulary
- 시대
- sidae — Era, age, or period of time
- 이후로
- ihuro — Since, from a certain point onward
- 둘러싸고
- dulleossago — Surrounding, encircling, or concerning a topic
- 제기된
- jegidoen — Raised, brought up, or posed (as a question)
- 문제들을
- munjedeureul — Problems or issues; object-marked plural form
- 오늘날
- oneullal — Nowadays, in the present day
- 논하는
- nonhaneun — Discussing or debating a topic
- 사람이라면
- saramiramieon — If one is a person who; conditional form
- 누구든
- nugeudeun — Anyone, whoever it may be
- 단
- dan — Only, merely, just one
- 하나의
- hanaui — Of one; a single (modifier)
- 지역에서
- jiyeogeseo — In or from a region or area
- 쓰였음이
- sseuieosseumi — The fact that it was written
- 명백히
- myeongbaekhi — Clearly, evidently, plainly
- 입증되었으며
- ipjeungdoeeosseumyeo — Has been proven and (furthermore); demonstrated conclusively
- 따라서
- ttaraseo — Therefore, consequently, as a result
- 다른
- dareun — Other, different, another
- 어떤
- eotteon — Any, some, what kind of
- 것도
- geotdo — Even something; anything at all
- 결론을
- gyeollon-eul — Conclusion; object-marked form of conclusion
- 가리키지
- garikiji — Does not point to or indicate
- 않는다
- anneunda — Does not; negative present tense ending
- 하더라도
- hadeorado — Even if, although, granting that
- 아마도
- amado — Probably, perhaps, most likely
- 한
- han — One; a single person or thing
- 사람에
- sarame — By or to a person; locative/dative form
- 의해서만
- uihaesoman — Only by means of; exclusively through
- 쓰였을
- sseuieosseul — Would have been written; past presumptive
- 것이라는
- geosiraneun — That it is; nominalizing connective clause
- 점
- jeom — Point, fact, aspect worth noting
- 그것이
- geugeos-i — That it; subject-marked pronoun for a thing
- 분명히
- bunmyeonghi — Clearly, obviously, without doubt
- 기원전
- giweonjeon — Before the Common Era; BC
- 이전에
- ijeone — Before, prior to a certain time
- 십중팔구
- sipjungpalgu — In all likelihood; nine times out of ten
- 쓰였다는
- sseuieotdaneun — That it was written; reported past clause
- 매우
- maeu — Very, extremely, greatly
- 이른
- ireun — Early; preceding the expected time
- 시기의
- sigiui — Of a period or time; possessive form
- 시의
- siui — Of a poem; possessive modifier for poetry
- 작가가
- jakgaga — Writer, author; subject-marked form
- 현재
- hyeonjae — Currently, at present, now
- 우리가
- uriga — We; subject-marked first-person plural
- 가지고
- gajigo — Having, possessing; connective gerund form
- 있는
- inneun — That exists; present tense modifier of 있다
- 친숙했으며
- chinsukhaessseumyeo — Was familiar with and (furthermore)
- 그
- geu — That, the; third-person pronoun or determiner
- 진정성이
- jinjeongseong-i — Authenticity; genuineness as subject
- 가장
- gajang — Most, the greatest degree; superlative marker
- 많이
- mani — A lot, much, in great quantity
- 의심받아
- uisimbada — Being doubted or questioned; receiving suspicion
- 온
- on — That has come; modifier meaning 'which has been'
- 책들에서도
- chaekdeureseodo — Even in the books; locative plural with also
- 작품으로
- jakpeum-euro — As a work or artwork; instrumental marker
- 인정받는
- injeongbakneun — Being recognized or acknowledged as genuine
- 자유롭게
- jayuropge — Freely, without restriction
- 차용했다는
- chayonghaetdaneun — That one borrowed or adopted; reported past
- 점을
- jeom-eul — The point or fact; object-marked form
- 독자들의
- dokjadeul-ui — Of the readers; possessive plural form
- 마음속에
- maeumsoge — Inside the mind or heart
- 충분히
- chungbunhi — Sufficiently, adequately, enough
- 각인시키지
- gakinsikeoji — Does not imprint or engrave deeply in mind
- 않는다면
- anneundamyeon — If one does not; negative conditional form
- 그는
- geuneun — He; topic-marked third-person pronoun
- 독자들을
- dokjadeureul — Readers; object-marked plural form
- 공정하게
- Fairly, justly, in an impartial manner
- 대하고
- daehago — Treating, dealing with; connective gerund
- 있다고
- itdago — That one is; reported present declarative
- 보기
- bogi — To see; nominalized form meaning 'viewing as'
- 어렵다
- eoryeopda — Is difficult, hard, challenging
- 반면에
- banmyeone — On the other hand, by contrast
- 앞서
- apseo — Previously, beforehand, ahead of time
- 언급한
- eongeuphan — Mentioned, referred to earlier
- 대영박물관
- Daeyeong Bangmulgwan — The British Museum in London
- 소장본을
- sojangbon-eul — Owned copy or held edition; object-marked form
- 바탕으로
- batang-euro — Based on, on the basis of
- 자신의
- jasin-ui — One's own; reflexive possessive pronoun
- 표시를
- pyosireul — Mark, indication; object-marked form
- 하고
- hago — Doing and; connective gerund of 하다
- 두
- du — Two; numeral preceding a noun
- 시에서
- sieseo — In the poem; locative-marked form of 시
- 이토록
- itorok — This much, to this extent
- 많은
- maneun — Many, numerous, a large amount of
- 동일한
- dongilhan — Identical, same, one and the same
- 구절들이
- gujeoldeuri — Passages or phrases; subject-marked plural
- 존재한다는
- jonjaehandan-eun — That they exist; reported present clause
- 사실로부터
- sasillo-buteo — From the fact that; starting from a truth
- 상식이
- sangsigi — Common sense; subject-marked form
- 도출할
- dochulhal — To derive or draw out a conclusion
- 수
- su — Ability, possibility; can (auxiliary noun)
- 유일한
- yuilhan — Sole, only, unique
- 이끌어내는
- ikkeureone-neun — Drawing out, deriving, leading to a conclusion
- 사람은
- sarameun — A person; topic-marked form of 사람
- 상당한
- sangdanghan — Considerable, significant, substantial
- 명성을
- myeongseong-eul — Fame, renown; object-marked form
- 누리고
- nurigo — Enjoying, benefiting from; connective gerund
- 이곳과
- igotgwa — This place and; conjunctive-marked location
- 유럽
- Yurop — Europe; the European continent
- 대륙의
- daeryugui — Of the continent; possessive form
- 수많은
- sumaneun — Countless, very many, numerous
- 책들에
- chaekdeule — In or among the books; locative plural
- 대해
- daehae — Regarding, about, concerning
- 적절한
- jeokjeolhan — Appropriate, suitable, proper
- 가치를
- gachireul — Value, worth; object-marked form
- 평가하는
- pyeonggahaneun — Evaluating, assessing, appraising
- 데
- de — In doing; nominalizing particle for actions
- 아무런
- amureon — No, not any, none whatsoever
- 어려움도
- eoryeumdo — Even difficulty; no difficulty at all
- 없을
- eopseul — Will not have; future presumptive of 없다
- 것이라고
- geosirago — That it will be; reported future form
- 나는
- naneun — I; topic-marked first-person pronoun
- 믿는다
- mitneunda — Believe, trust; present declarative form
- 더
- deo — More, further, additionally
- 나아가
- naaga — Going further, advancing, moreover
- 이것이
- igeosi — This; subject-marked demonstrative pronoun
- 더욱
- deouk — Even more, all the more, increasingly
- 확보할
- hwakbohal — To secure, obtain, or ensure something
- 만한
- manhan — Worth doing; deserving of; as much as
- 가치
- gachi — Value, worth, merit
- 이점이겠지만
- ijeom-igetjiman — It would be an advantage, but
- 수수께끼들이
- susukkekkeodeuri — Riddles, mysteries, puzzles; subject-marked plural
- 지나치게
- jinachige — Excessively, too much, overly
- 포화된
- pohwadoen — Saturated, oversaturated; having too much
- 데서
- deseo — From the fact of; in the place of doing
- 비롯된다는
- birotdoendaneun — That it stems from or originates from
- 것을
- geoseul — The thing; object-marked nominalizer
- 발견함으로써
- balgyeonhameuro-sseo — By discovering or finding out something
- 이상
- isang — No longer, anymore; beyond this point
- 그를
- geureul — Him; object-marked third-person pronoun
- 어리둥절하게
- eoriduungjeonhage — In a bewildering way; causing confusion
- 하지
- haji — Does not do; negative connective form
- 않게
- ank-e — So as not to; negative purposive form
- 됨을
- doemlul — The fact of becoming; nominalized form
- 알게
- alge — Come to know; resultative connective form
- 될
- doel — Will become; future modifier of 되다
- 것이다
- geosida — It is the case; declarative sentence-final form
Unlock audio playback, vocabulary games, and reading progress tracking.
Create free account →